why I've never once denied it
You said its not a modern reasoning. 20th century is considered to be modernity, and pretty sure there are still doctors alive who worked in the 60s. So even if you're using "modern" in another context, there are still people who've been taught using that reasoning, and since most of the reasoning in the US today is contested as well, we can easily argue it's about moral panic and conforming to societal standards more than about actual factual objective medical benefits.
You're still just straight up wrong about "removing all risk of penile cancer", yet you won't admit that.
Sure, it significantly reduces the chances of getting penile cancer, but unless you chop of the glans, it doesn't remove it.
It also significantly alters the sensation in your penis and as far as American media is to be believed, makes jerking off "dry" much more difficult. Can't imagine needing accessories for getting myself off lol. I mean, I have used accessories ofc, but I couldn't imagine not being able to get off without them. Always having to have a bottle of lube just in case I get horny and want to rub my keratinised stem which lacks the prepuce and glans, (so that I won't have even a tiny risk of cancer.)