Ooh, this is a fun game.
Ok, how about "tea"? Is that an English word?
How about "chef"? If not, then how about "chief"?
"Dexterity"?
"History"?
"Anger?" "Egg?" "Justice?"
What about "circle", "cheese", and "wine"?
Do they count as English if the borrowing predates English? "Sand" and "tin"? "Silver"?
What about if they really predate English like "ox"?