[–] 3 points 1 month ago (2 children)

Worldbuilding is actually one of the elements I don't particularly enjoy, I'm here to hang out with my friends and tell cool stories. The less effort I have to put in the better from my standpoint. My preference tends towards games with their own settings or settings easily explained with a few touchstones.

My favourite game so far has been in the Dresden files RPG, which is very easy to grasp the setting of even for someone who has never read the books. I set the game in our hometown and scattered a few options for problems around for the players to encounter and just built a story from there. My worldbuilding setup was collaborative presenting aspects of the Dresden universe which I was interested in running and asking what my players were interested in.

I have also run a few Mothership games with great success and very little worldbuilding - you're basically in the Alien universe where "The Company" owns everything. If you have a common touchstone like the Alien films to give everyone a shared idea of the world it makes it so much easier to set the tone and mood of a game with very little effort on my or the players parts.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 1 month ago

    @juergen_hubert I think the real balance is between how complex the world is, and how much is exposed to the players at any single moment. Then the players can decide what matters to them. The downside is that most of the work of the DM might be lost if the players don't explicitly go looking for it.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 1 month ago

    I hate the name, though. Nothing about that site is a Wiki. Call it TTRPG Catalog, Folio, whatever. If there's no way to directly edit anything, it's not a wiki. (And no, I don't think a wiki would be a good idea for a website of this kind.)

  • source
  • [–] 1 point 2 months ago

    How do you feel about tracking equipment and encumbrance?

    Are these two different things to anyone else? "My hoodlum has a knife, some lockpicks, and a lucky charm" is different than "I'm carrying 12 of 50 pounds for light encumbrance"

    Which should be prioritized more in a campaign: realism or drama?

    Also really depends on genre, heh.

    What has the more authority: GM rulings or game rules?

    I put rulings but that's because "I'd love to have fun but the book says no" is kind of stupid. But I do not really like when the GM unilaterally, capriciously, changes things. I like having a workable mental model of how the game works. One that doesn't include the GM's mood.

  • source
  • [–] 1 point 2 months ago

    I don't remember it using the word "prefer" or the word "approve." My point is that you don't have to always play the same way to give an opinion on which way is better, especially when the questions allow you to pick a middle answer.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 2 months ago (2 children)

    Unlike some of the other commenters, I had no problem answering the questions, even though I do not always play the same way.

    Folks, it's asking what you prefer, not what you always do. If you have no personal preference and just go with the flow, pick the middle option. If you have a preference, pick that even if you sometimes do it your less preferred way for some reason, such as the way the game is designed or how the group interacts.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 2 months ago

    I mostly play indie games. Half of these questions barely make sense in some of those. Some of them had me thinking in interesting ways though. I'll be interested to see your results. I expect the weird-combo outliers will have some interesting things to say.

  • source
  • [–] 5 points 2 months ago* (1 child)

    The form lacks a free text box at the end for additional remarks. I feel like a lot of my answers would have been "it depends". There is no one way to handle all tables, it's highly dependent on the players and GM, settings, mood, overall goal, ... I answered a lot of 3s as middle ground in between "strongly approve" and "strongly disapprove" not that I don't care, it just depends. And even when I had stronger opinions about things I feel like it should stay flexible, not fixed in stone. I doubt values from 1 to 5 are going to convey any of this. There isn't one magic formula that is going to work for everyone or every game.

  • source
  • [–] 13 points 2 months ago

    While filling out this survey I noticed this isn't how I run games at all. Or how I experience playing ttrpgs.

    Each of my games and tables works very differently from a playstyle point of view. Do people run all their games the same usually?

    Like realism vs drama, that is a system and table question, not a how do you run your games in general question. If you run a Masks game with the same level of realism and drama as you run The Dark Eye, at least one of your games will feel off imo.

    The same is true for most of the questions made. In narrative games the players will have much more agency over the world than in a hexcrawl. One will have cooperative world building, while the other is about exploring the either preset world and/or randomly generated events and locations. The list goes on.

    My point: this seems to be written by someone who is used to each table or GM or player having a singular way to play. Definitely not true for the two groups I meet with a few times a month.

  • source
  • [–] [S] 5 points 2 months ago

    I answered as if I was playing Shadowdark. It's my current favorite.

    You are right that it depends on the game you're playing. My answers would be drastically different if I was playing Trail of Cthulhu.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 2 months ago

    The "Framing Quest" - or rather, "Framing Mystery" - worked well for my sandbox campaign.

    "What happened to the prior civilizations in this region?" was a great overall motiviator for the PCs to explore the region and gather new clues.

  • source
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›