Sucks that legal options so very often lack functions that are more or less standard otherwise. Reminds me of unskippable piracy warnings on purchased movie media
comments
Elixirs of life are nonmagical. Pretty much any alchemical healing will be, can't think of anything that's alchemical and magical simultaneously off the top of my head.
@Reshirams_Rad_Slam @pathfinder Life Oracle's curse sounds like a real pain in the neck... unless you've got battle medicine to soothe your soul. Spirit Familiar, too, I suppose - as long as they don't try to cuddle with you while casting spells
😛
Yeah, i'm actually traveling right now, so i'll take care of it when i get a chance later.
Edit: it is done
I guess I could ping the mod: hey @eerongal@ttrpg.network you should add a community avatar.
Not a bad idea; Someone with the power to do something should do something about that!
When my players' party (of 3) was Level 2, I ran them through the core of the DCC module Legend of the Ripper, which culminates in a battle with a Redcap. I ran the module, and the Redcap, as written, just substituting in PF2e versions of the monsters and hazards (the conversion was buttery smooth, really), which meant I was putting the party up against an Extreme encounter. The players had circumvented a fight with a ghost earlier, and in fact had managed to befriend it, so I decided to use it as an intervention if and when the party got the Redcap down below a certain HP threshold, or if the fight turned totally sideways.
Well, the Redcap managed to down the party's only melee character -- a Champion -- in the first round with a critical hit, which turned the party into a little bit of a reactive mess. The Cleric had recently respec'd into an Oracle, so they were lacking a dedicated healing option, but I gave the Oracle a custom Celestial Relic with Word of Faith so that they'd have some sort of free and easy healing. So, they locked themself into the roll of keeping the Champion alive, and the Champion locked themself into the role of keeping the Oracle alive, while the Druid did what they could to pick away at the Redcap's health and outpace its fast healing, and the Redcap skirmished with the Champion and the Druid. This went on for a few rounds, with the Druid doing most of the damage, and the Oracle and Champion doing chip damage where they could, until they were just a few HP away from the narrative trigger I'd decided on.
Then the Champion managed to catch up to and trip the Redcap, while the Druid walked over and pulled out Horizon Thunder Sphere.
Natural 20, with a high damage roll. More than enough to kill the Redcap.
It was a great encounter, with a mobile enemy, in a setting with lots of crates and boxes that it could take cover behind, and a party that felt pretty consistently on the ropes, right up until the dice gods blessed them into a decisive victory.
The number of APs that qualify as "remastered" is fairly limited. We're really just talking about Wardens of Wildwood and later. That means Wardens, Curtain Call, Triumph of the Tusk, Spore War, Shades of Blood, and Myth-Speaker. Of these, I don't think any of them easily follow from Menace Under Otari or Trouble in Otari.
Seven Dooms of Sandpoint, though, is a pretty good fit level-wise, but it's not remastered, and it has enemies in it that utilize alignment damage. Some small efforts would need to be taken to adjust for the removal of alignment from the game.
I believe this is what you're looking for
https://paizo.com/threads/rzs5t5jd?Tarondors-2025-Guide-to-the-Pathfinder
And here is u/Killchrono's reply, which I think is must-read:
So there's a line of thought that's come to make me realize why a lot of the discussions surrounding PF2e seem so needlessly antagonistic, and a big part of it comes down to a weird quirk and hypocrisy I've noticed in discussions about it over the years.
Back before Remaster, there was a tonne of discussion about how the online community about the game is hostile to homebrew and house rules. Obviously there still is, but after the Remaster came out (particularly PC2, where a lot of the more controversial changes were made like the orcale rework), there was a notable shift in tone towards saying things like 'use the old rules' and 'just change it if you don't like it' was poo-poo'd.
Now you'd think it would be the people who were 'enforcing' the so-called RAW purity who were doing this, or it was just a plain old Goomba Fallacy where the people complaining about the changes weren't the same as the ones who were complaining about the rules purity...except they were, because even barring the fact I'm a chronically online pedant who knows too many of the regular usernames around here and I recognized a lot of the same ones popping up in those discussions, it was clear it was the people who were already dissatisfied with the game who were making complaints about the changes like the oracle rework, or cantrips or poisons being nerfed, or the mistaken changes to the death rules before they were clarified in errata.
So the line of questioning becomes, why not use the old rules?
Simply put, it was a combination of people who felt fatalistic about being unable to negotiate or change things about the game they perceived they had no power over, and online pedants who were just trying to score one-ups on people who were defending the changes by enforcing an arbitrary Oberoni Fallacy to discuss it in the most RAW-enforced way possible.
Now the latter in this case can be summarily dismissed because that's the kind of toxic, self-important point-scoring that leads to unproductive discussions, but it's the former here is what I'm interested in. Changing rules at the table really is an insular decision that should be made within your group. Why does it matter what Reddit thinks? Why do you need Reddit's permission to discuss that with your GM, let alone feel the need to change the RAW entirely to what you want to get what you want?
Simply put: the GM isn't letting you under the auspices that they're sticking to the rules, because clearly Paizo knows better and if the rules are designed that way, that's the way the game should be run. So the only way to change your table's experience, is to change the official rules.
Now let's be clear about something: this train of thought is not entirely unfounded. It's why people care so much about releases like Remaster or DnD 2024. The RPG zeitgeist has a more direct influence on people's decision making than the online discourse would have you believe, and most of the time it gives this disproportionate deference to official releases as being the Source of Truth for what the most up to date and polished version of the game is, while completely undermining the wider sentiment that the RPG space is this self-determinate bastion of free thought where you can make the game whatever you want. And there are definitely 'sheeple GMs', for lack of a less crass phrase - that go by what the official sentiment is and stick to RAW as rigidly as possible, not allowing house rules, homebrew, 3pp, etc. even going so far as to assume the official designers inherently know better how to design and tune their own game, even if they've proven they can't.
Simultaneously and non-contradictorily, none of this changes the fact that yes, in the end it really is between you and your GM how you decide to handle rules at your own table. Just because the game 'expects' something as a baseline, doesn't mean you have to abide by it.
This comes down to a more important question I also think gets overlooked here: has your GM not thought about this?
Or do you simply disagree with your GM?
This got me thinking about why these sorts of complaints are less prevalent in the more 'popular' d20s over the past few decades like 3.5/1e and 5e, and it was discussing a completely different topic related to what you're discussing here. I'd regularly point out, having overpowered options in 3.5/1e or 5e was no different to comparing the modifiers, DCs, and wider scaling abilities of lower level creatures in PF2e. What the math is more or less exactly the same, what is the breakpoint?
The thing that gets regularly pointed out is that in 3.5/1e (less so 5e since feats and magic items are technically optional rules, but more so in terms of how they're generally tuned), is that in those systems, that power scale is determined by the player's available RAW choices, not by the GM adjusting the challenges or going out of band of the expected power band each level to grant it. In PF2e, the maths is so tight and foolproof, the baseline is more or less 'normal difficulty' at best. In 3.5/1e and 5e, you can game it so you are superlative to any assumed baselines.
And that's when it hit me: it's about being the determiner of the power cap. In 3.5/1e and 5e, it's very easy for a player running with a sheeple/Abed-type GM who runs perfectly neutrally and says 'well it's in the rules so I'll allow it' to set their own power caps, because the rules permissively allow it. You can't do that in PF2e. In PF2e, it is entirely dependent on the GM to be permissive to those power spikes, because the 'expected baseline' is a more level power cap.
This results in two kinds of players who are dissatisfied: those who are not being selfish or malicious just used to the mechanical permissiveness of those other systems suddenly feeling stifled, and those who's need for enjoyment relies on (if not is entirely dependent on) feeling superior to other people at the table.
That's why a lot of the most hardcore complaints about PF2e are supremely and unnecessarily aggressive and vindictive towards people who like it. The former type are people who think they've done nothing wrong, assuming they've done nothing wrong, and legitimately don't see why what they were doing before was a problem. The latter are the exact kinds of problem players PF2e is setting out to stop, so of course they'll react in the exact way a toxic person reacts when someone puts reasonable boundaries on their behaviour that affects everyone else.
Here's my comment on the Reddit post:
"Balance" is a really awful word for it. Everyone has an internal sense of what "balance" means, while in game design it's usually used in a different way. And the discourse around balance, whether it's fun or not, why it's fun or not, very often completely misses what balance is.
Balance is a tool.
Full disclosure, I am not a game designer, but I work with game designers in the video game industry, and one of my jobs is to assess balance in their designs using empirical data. And the way designers design for balance, and the way I asses it, is to have standard entities (enemies, player-characters, weapons, consumables... whatever the categories of entities are in your game) and assign that a rating -- usually 1, or 100, or 1000, or some other meaningful but easily divisible number -- and then compare your other designs to these standards.
In a leveled game like Pathfinder, we would have one such standard per category at each level. In something like, say, Rainbow Six Siege, there'd just be one for each category. For the most part, these are used for helping to generate ELO scores for matchmaking, but for something like PF2, it'd be used to test designs and make sure things weren't too over- or under-tuned for their level, or for assigning level to a creature or item based on its design (knowing the power scaling for the game, if a Level 1 item has a power rating of 1000, and my item has a power rating of 2500, it would get slotted into Level 3 or Level 4, depending on other factors).
In this respect, balance is a tool for creating predictable or consistent outcomes, something that's very important to module writers.
But it flows both ways. Just as I can try to design an item with a power rating of 4000, so that it is Level 5, I can also (as mentioned above) just design whatever I want, and then see where it lands on the power scale, and assign it its appropriate level. I can choose to make 120 XP encounters, or I can make the encounters I think make sense, and then know that they are 240 XP, and that the party is either going to need some help getting through it, or that I will need to provide fair warning and possible dissuasion should they try to engage. I can choose to only give players on-level items, or I can super-charge them with PL+3 weapons and have a really good sense of how they will impact the game.
The problem is, not everyone seems to see the B-side to balance. They just see the game as demanding, because guidance is apparently something you can never say "no, thank you" to.
And they see a sea of people talking about how great balance is, and see people confusing balance with rigid constraint while celebrating it. People who tell them that "the game expects" them to play it in a certain way (while the actual lead designers are out there championing the flexibility of the system), and in all of that, the very concept of what "balance" is gets completely and totally beaten down into a pulp.
I play this game because I love saying "no" to guidance, and still getting to feel very confident in how things will unfold. Because I get to do things that make my players feel like bosses without it fucking up my whole campaign. Because it provides me a whole toolbox full of tools that I can use whenever I need them, and everything I need to manufacture tools of my own.
I'm glad it provides other people the constrained puzzle box that they are looking for, but hot damn am I tired of people shouting to the world that that's all the game is. Because it is so, so, so much more.
Including my comment on the video here:
Pathfinder 2e gets hit with the "rules-heavy" label a lot, and I find that that is a term that predispositions people to see a lot of what's written in the source books as hard-and-fast rules that are specific to the game. Now, I'm by no means going to argue that PF2e is rules light*, but rules-heavy getting thrown around as the antonym of rules-light style gaming introduces something of an unfair and *unhelpful bias.
From where I sit, Pathfinder 2e is a systemic game, rather than a "rules-heavy" one. Aren't all rules-heavy games systemic in nature? I don't know, I haven't played them all, but of those that I have, yes. But some of these games have a thousand bespoke systems that interact poorly; others have a significant number of highly detailed and complicated systems that don't share DNA; and some have a small number of fairly simple systems that interact well to create complexity at the table.
PF2e sits closer to the latter, without quite reaching the mark.
Here's the thing that often gets overlooked when people discuss PF2e's rules, in no small part because so much discussion about the rules boil down to "this is what this particular rule says, the rules mean what they say, and you should follow the rules". Everyone keeps focusing on the tree bark; they're several steps away from seeing the forest: The overwhelming majority of "rules" in the various xCore books are just codifying how people have been running d20 games since 3e launched, if not earlier. They're not novel, and they're not particular to the game, they're just written down using systemic language, while guarding against bad-faith rules-lawyering. That's it. They gave that CHA check everyone rolls while trying to charm someone a name, and included some guidance on how to come up with a DC in a systemic way, and everyone lost their damn mind.
The various Victory Point systems are no different. They're just clocks. They're just reputation points. They're just ways of abstracting away named actions. They're things GMs have been doing for 25 years now, written up with a little bit of structure and formalism, using a style guide that a lot of the audience finds intimidating or alien. And, unfortunately, the fact that a lot of the stuff that's hung off of the game's core pillars (level standardization, 4 degrees of success, DCs from bonuses/no opposed rolls, multi-tiered proficiency, and modular character design) are just codified community tradition means that they don't always interact meaningfully with the core systems.
It doesn't help that a significant fraction of the game's audience really does just seem to be here for combat, though. I mentioned on [SBG's] Patreon how people complaining about niche skill feats grind my gears because so many of the complaints boil down to "but the designers are supporting somebody else's play!!!", and we can say the same thing here, too. It's just that here, that support kind of boils down to some pocket game modes that haven't been properly tied into the core.
Thanks! They're good reads.
I ran the 1e version for multiple groups and had a great time. I'm not sure how much they revised for 2e, but I do recommend the changes Dudemeister made for Rivers Run Red and maybe for Varnhold Vanishing for the 1e version. They both really help with the story, particularly the RRR changes. IIRC something like them made it into the CRPG.
I have definitely found 2e's grapple rules to be very simple, but this is at the cost of being useful. It lasts only until the end of your next turn, and you don't get any bonus to continue the grapple. You have only very limited ability to Reposition someone you've grabbed. There's no "drag" action. No way for you to move someone already grabbed by more than 10 ft, and even that on a critical success. 5 ft on a normal success. With no grab-related circumstance bonuses.
https://2e.aonprd.com/Feats.aspx?ID=6064
From reading this, it doesn’t look like it would affect your other spells at all:
Your mystery grants you additional magic. You have an extra spell slot of your highest rank, which you can use only to cast one of your mystery's granted spells, heightened to this rank.
Special If you have the divine access class feature or Mysterious Repertoire feat, you can cast spells that you learned from those abilities using the additional spell slot from Gifted Power.
https://2e.aonprd.com/Feats.aspx?ID=5006
Your familiar can subsume its body to become pure spirit. Your familiar gains the Shed Spirit activity.
This firmly puts the action as the familiars.
Sprites have to burn an ancestry feat to gain a 15 foot fly speed. It's a significant boost to their flexibility, and gives them the ability to both reach enemies who might be in places where the party wouldn't otherwise be able to touch, but they have to end their turn on the ground, so it's not like they can really avoid the worst of combat.
I wouldn't stress about it too much. There's utility there, but if it becomes a problem, it can be planned around.
Thank you this really helps a lot. I have a player wanting to play a sprite. I am thinking of limiting his flight to small bursts, because I can see already how it will be game breaking at times.
It's worth noting that rarity is specifically a function of setting and story type. Some things, like the spell Talking Corpse, are marked as Uncommon because they can be narrative win-buttons for certain scenarios. But many things -- like ancestries -- are Uncommon or Rare just because, in Golarion, they are less common than others. Populations are lower, or their home base is farther away.
Thank you, i looked at that table of terms but missed rarity because I was looking for rare specifically, and in the context of the box with the uncommon i posted.
Generally uncommon and rare things just need a good story justification worked out between the player and GM. Some rare feats and items and things are really only useful in the specific adventure they were made for, but i think of uncommon/rare as just guidelines for GMs to determine how appropriate things are for the setting.
I hope I understood your question correctly.
As a Trait, the description of Rare applies to everything it is attached to, ancestory, spell, item, or other. You can find the full description at https://2e.aonprd.com/Traits.aspx?ID=683 but generally in non-PFS play it just means you should ask the GM before selecting it. In PFS play you will need to purchase a Boon.
To add a little more detail, the primary differences are:
- A bunch of things got renamed on the advice of lawyers or to make things clearer. e.gs Magic Missile ->Force Barrage, Spell Level -> Spell Rank
- Alignment got removed and replaced with Sanctification (holy or unholy), Anathema and Edicts
- Wizard Schools got reworked for lawyer reasons
- Witch Class got some reworking
- Lots of ancestries, monsters, and items got renamed, sometimes with small changes, for lawyer reasons. E.g Dragons are no longer color coded, but more based on different mythologies and archetypes.
Edit: Paizo's overview of the changes is available at https://downloads.paizo.com/RemasterCorePreview.pdf
2E Remastered started coming out in November 2023. Mechanically it is a very lightly polished version of 2E. It was created as response to WotCs OGL shenanigans and mostly consists of removing and replacing anything that their lawyers thought might be construed as covered by WotCs OGL bullshit and then released under the new ORC license.