Me!
comments
Thanks for sharing. I don't usually watch these types of videos but I've been hesitant to map wheelchair related tags so I thought I might learn a few things.... and I did!
That's a great list! I'm going to add one more for Cartes:
https://cartes.app/
The maps usually get updated weekly. The 3D buildings only show up once you zoom in close.
Hey so does Organic Maps! Neat!
Thanks for making me look!
My favorite desktop 3D browsers:
- https://demo.f4map.com/ - OSM data updated near instantly
- https://osmbuildings.org/ - OSM data updated about once a month
Some other notable renderers with old and outdated OSM data:
- https://streets.gl/ - static map data from 2023, but very nice!
- https://ion.cesium.com/stories/viewer/?id=2f0131ab-3948-4467-947c-411d5705a116 old data not updated.
- https://www.arcgis.com/home/webscene/viewer.html - old OSM data mixed with other even lower quality sources
If you want to see what you are doing while editing there is a new and working JOSM plugin UrbanEye3D: https://github.com/Zkir/UrbanEye3D
Kedzi3D was the previous plugin but it wasn't updated for recent Java versions, UrbanEye works like a charm!
Yeah, it seems interesting but the website only goes so far. From the issues about integrating reviews on the git pages of CoMaps and Organic Maps it seems the developer is very invested in implementing review functionality as well.
At least there are many things moving!
No problem! My French still needs a lot of work as well, but I usually just use the browser's translator for their blogs. From what I can see, it looks like they're open to getting the reviews working with ActivityPub eventually.
I agree that it makes sense to have reviews be a part of the social web. Hopefully one of these options takes off, we really need viable alternatives to the current big tech platforms.
I hadn't heard of SocialMaps yet. It's definitely an interesting tool with how it translates search strings into queries on OSM data. It was throwing errors for me instead of returning results, so I'll have to give it another try later on.
That's really cool! I'm a bit tribalistic about my preference for ActivityPub, but I just signed up for an ATProto account (PDS?) for the first time to test this. It seems promising—I'll keep my fingers crossed for some sort of ActivityPub integration down the line. :)
(I just now noticed the latest post in the discussion on cartes.app and protocols also makes reference to xkcd 927 - I guess everyone looking into this are mildly terrified by it)
The review system that Cartes.app developed on ATproto is not centralized. Each review is saved on the PDS of the user who posted it and there are thousands of PDSs now. If you look at my account (at://wake.st) on https://pds.ls you can see a sample review. You are able to reuse all of these reviews freely. They are each all linked to a users DID (either DID:plc or DID:web) and that is the only part that can be argued is centralized. But it is centralized in sorta a similar way as how DNS is centralized in the hands of ICANN
That's interesting - do you know if there is more information about it anywhere? And if it is based on activitypub? Neither the web site nor web searches seems to get me anywhere.
Thank you for this! I was unaware of cartes.app. Their reasoning for not using Mangrove or lib.reviews seems to be similar to my concern that requiring separate user accounts for posting reviews online is not realistic if one needs to get the project off the ground. The problem I can see with it is that it appears to be truly centralized—if this service became successful, could it be reliably kept from enshittifying? As far as I can understand (though my French is broken) it decentralizes user IDs, but keeps the review data base completely centralized. The UI looks nice and intuitive though, and I must admit I always get confused about the inner workings of ATProto.
The other services I can find of course struggle with the same problem of centralization. There appears to be yet another emerging service called socialmaps which pitches sign-on with OSM, but this appears to be based on a centralized infrastructure as well. Of course if reviews are published with an open license it makes it easier to benefit from it across projects, but this still seems like a messy landscape.
As a matter of principle, reviews are part of the social web, and I think it is reasonable to expect them to be powered by ActivityPub which is the established standard for the social web. It also seems to me the ActivityPub infrastructure already in place is pretty much sufficient for handling such reviews, so I believe it would be wiser to build on ActivityPub rather than introducing something new. Then again, I am aware that what I am proposing here is effectively xkcd 927.
Didn't read your whole post in detail but Fediloc is building something that is reviews on OSM places that is federated. Alpha software atm though.
There are some projects working on a review system now. The 3 that I can think of are Cartes.app, Mangrove, and lib.reviews.
The developer of Cartes discusses their review system here, and why they chose to avoid using Mangrove or lib.reviews.
They also answer the question as to why they chose to work on ATproto first instead of starting with ActivityPub.
Map Complete has added Mangrove reviews as a feature in their application.
OsmAnd had a plugin for Openplace reviews, but their service shut down in 2023.
When I was at Meta working on the maps team, we couldn’t afford to hold this “view from nowhere”. Facebook is enormously popular in India where showing a map that doesn’t match the country’s own vision of itself carried criminal penalties for our colleagues. Laws on cartography in India are specific and strict.
I could understand civil penalties, but criminal?
It's hard to tell without some aerial/satellite imagery of your intersection, but assuming there are islands at each crossing, and assuming that "up" is North in your image:
The crossings at the Northwest and Southeast would be tagged as shown at the top of the page you linked:

While the 4 Northeast and Southwest crossings would be tagged as shown at the bottom of the page you linked:

I guess in that case, a crossing island between each direction would be tagged on both, if the island is not mapped separately?
The way this is mapped, with a separate crossing over each direction of the road, looks correct. Especially because the sidewalks have been mapped separately from the road.
The wiki uses these examples for traffic signals:


https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dtraffic_signals
I would not join the 6 separate crossings into 1. Just tag each crossing as highway=crossing and, if they exist, crossing=traffic_signals.
Check out https://streetcomplete.app/
It is like a simple game app where you walk around your neigbhorhood and answer questions to fill out missing data in the map.
It is actually pretty fun 😄
So the unnamed streets near you will pop up as quests where you can name them.
A week or so later, the data ypu contributed will be public in OSM.
This is freaking magnificent one, and they do have a quite optimized map loading! They seem to be using MapBox service under the hood.
I am searching for such projects with live visualization of data to eventually contribute to!
Thank you very much, dear infeeeee@lemmy.zip ! 💎
"Show me the way" is a similar project: https://osmlab.github.io/show-me-the-way/
Freaking ineffably awesome project, work, and the project is written with minimum dependencies it seems!
Thank you... thank you very much for the marvel you do, dear artists/developers!
Does anyone know relatively same projects with live-changes?
After a fatal train crash in Spain, which occurred by the Adamuz crossover, OSM mappers began mapping the surrounding area in solidarity to improve map quality.
Working on OSM and Wikipedia, it's always a sight to behold when a subject is given a sudden, major boost in quality. It's simultaneously a harrowing reminder of how much work remains and an uplifting one that people like you are working just as tirelessly as you are toward a common goal. Every time it just makes me wish more people got into contributing and found their own little areas to improve.
I'll be careful with nothing, it must be done! Someone's gotta do it so it may as well be me!
Haha nah I definitely already plan to do more, but tbh I don't get out much these days so either I'll just do it when I need it (like this one) or you're right and I'll do the whole town which will get me out more, so win/win!
Thanks for the help! That certainly sounds easy enough, this will be the next thing I try (once I get around to doing it. Just one more time of having to GPS to the next street over and I'll do it in my car before I leave lol.)
I feel you on that hahah
If it's just an unnamed street then it is extremely easy, just click the road and put it a name. Then in the buildings, just click them and you'll see that you can fill the address, the number, zip code and whatever else you want to add.
But be careful, this shit is extremely addictive. First you just want to map your street, then when you're happy about it you go with your city block, then you go with the whole town and then you're screwed trying to map your whole country!
You'd think that, but I'm notoriously slow to do things so I still haven't even tried all the suggestions yet hahaha. It's the ADHD I'm also finishing up 3 other projects and starting another 2 lol.
The buildings actually look to be on the map, just entirely unlabeled and on an unnamed street. I just need to name the street (let's call it) "Pine Street" and then designate the buildings "500 Pine St, 600 Pine St" and so on. I'd settle for just the street lmao.
Thanks I'll check out that method!