[–] 1 point 11 months ago

I've come to describe a thought, the contents of a thought, as magic. Now I don't believe in magic, it's a trick. But, I'll describe the creation of a thought as a magic event, there's no rational explanation of why some people have the thoughts they do, the content of a thought is the result of a magic event. Given drugs, thoughts can get absolutely haywire.

I think everybody has had a holy crap what was I thinking moment. Like wild magic.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 11 months ago

    The trick behind it, and it is a trick, is that they have been fed billions of pages of text that contains the majority of every sentence ever written and they use math to estimate the most appropriate word-by-word response to the question from all of the other examples of text that they have to work on.

    Current LLMs are incapable of creating an original combination of words( in the absolute sense). They don't make anything. They just repeat. They are stochastic parrots.

    Sometimes the answer is obvious, assuming that you have all of the relevant information, that you can provide the right answer without thinking at all. And when LLMs are correct, it is because of this phenomenon, and not because they actually thought about the question, and came up with a response.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 14 points 11 months ago (3 children)

    There's a whole school of philosophy that has argued about this for ... Well forever, but especially the last 100 years, the philosophy of mind. The problem is definition: what does it mean to think. Some may argue that it requires consciousness, but then the problem of definition is what the hell is consciousness?

    So on the trivial side, yes, of course computers can think, if thoughts are nothing special. Computers have states, they can react to and inspect their own states. Is that thinking? LLMs use something like neural networks modeled after the mind to generate streams of words, and encode knowledge and concepts using statistics. Is that thinking?

    On the other side, well no, computers don't think because they don't have souls. Are souls real? Or maybe there's more to human thinking than just neural networks, like quantum effects? Or more complexity due to chemical biology? Is the ability to answer a question the same thing as understanding a concept (see Chinese room experiment)?

    These are the questions that philosophers love to masturbate with, publish many papers on, and make no real progress towards. Definitions are funny like that

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 11 months ago (1 child)

    It must be possible, as I somewhat infrequently have to verbally harass my computer into working. It must be a conscious, thinking and feeling being, or else this behavior can not be explained.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 1 year ago

    Right? I don't have a framework but, I have a dell inspiron 15, keyboard replacement is a simple flathead screwdriver between the case and the keyboard to pop it out, unhook the keybard wire and then install the new keyboard the same way but reverse.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 1 year ago*

    not with the acer nitro 5. I've had to assist in replacing a few. it requires you to take the entire board(and the 2 sub boards) out, which isn't hard, but also if the system has never been worked on before may require you to pry or grind some locktite style plastic pegs off to detach the keyboard from the actual case which risks you actually damaging the case as well.

    It's super tedious. the 20 minute videos you can find on youtube are either cut or in 3 or 4x speed. the actual process can take a bit cause theres a lot of screws holding the case and boards in.

    When compared to the EEE Pc's or Dell Inspirons which were a simple remove the battery, pop the keyboard out with a flathead, and unhook then run in reverse. It's super difficult

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 6 points 1 year ago

    I have done this repair a few times on dells. It sucks but doable. This was during covid and we had huge delays on getting new devices, so was taking parts from diffrent computers to make a working one. All mine worked fine, I'm good with mechanical things, but Practice stopped when coworker tried it and put long screws where short ones go and the case now has very noticeable bumps next to the mouse pad.

    Also shocking how NO ONE knew how to change thermal paste on a 5 year old laptops or why they were all thermal throttling. Corporate waste is real.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›