[–] [S] 2 points 4 weeks ago

And how successful has any luddite movement in history been, ever?

A little history. I hope you find this interesting and enjoyable. https://socialistworker.co.uk/in-depth/the-real-luddites/ Quote:

The effects of the Luddites’ revolt were considerable. It encouraged the birth of the trade union and socialist movement in Britain.

.........

Will I be employable in 10 years if I choose to live without it? Doubtful. It is here, and it won’t go away.

Not saying it would be easy but we could have more intentional communities where AI tech is kept to a minimum and in which food could be grown, and skills learnt in building, and so on, e.g the Amish and similar groups.

Ok, so that may sound extreme but we need to live lives in which AI is not an evil presence that takes over every aspect. AI and the fiddlers behind it need to be strictly regulated and not allowed to destroy the remaining vestiges of democracy and social order. If malicious AI agents break into banking or security / weapons systems we could have the destruction of much of 'advanced' society and/or the imposition of extreme authoritarianism. Those village folks who live off their vegie gardens, their chooks and a few other stock may be the only civilisation that can survive.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 4 points 4 weeks ago

    This is why "centrism" and the Labor Party chasing centrist voters is a scourge and the Labor party should be abandoned.

    This just fits in to my view that the only way to fight Liberal and One Nation is to go further left and actually make peoples lives better by providing public services, nationalise natural resource extraction, increase company and wealth taxes, and, not capitulate to the right wing rhetoric.

    Instead Labor go after competing unions (RAFFWU), put funding into and lend credence to the nonsense that is "tough on crime", don't fund our schools and hospitals properly even after relentless campaigning by the unions. They are demolishing our public housing and replacing it with community housing (often fewer units) and selling off the rest as private dwellings - literally selling of public land and assets...

    And they have no counter to people complaining about the debt because a number of the projects are dumb, and frankly corrupt (Transurban no-bid contract). Big road projects really should be a thing of the past, we have enough roads, to make them work better we need more public transport, so that commercial and emergency vehicles and transport for disability don't have to compete with people who could take PT. No, Metro Tunnel, SRL, and especially the LXRP which is a project for road users, is not enough. The PTUA have a great list of things they ought to have done https://ptua.org.au/advocacy/)

    They allow the dismantling of Cohealth, and don't bother stepping in to bring it back under community control when the board pilfer the rescue package https://archive.li/2026.10.06-193602/https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/cohealth-splurged-on-a-recruiter-then-it-chose-an-internal-applicant-20261007-p612gz.html, because the Labor party are not for public health, they think the current private subsidy system of Medicare is good.

    The Labor party hasn't been the party of the working class for a long time, and are directly responsible for the death of membership in our unions via the Accords in the 80s.

    We need to rebuild the left in this country, and the only party doing that is the Socialists (and to an extent, the Greens, but they're pro-capitalism, which is why we're in this mess to begin with)

    In conclusion, this is the Labor Party's fault, but the UFU is still very silly for essentially endorsing the LNP and One Nation above the Labor Party by saying they should be last.

    If any of what I've said is convincing to you, I encourage you to get involved:

  • source
  • [–] 1 point 4 weeks ago

    I'm not 100% with M3 (Footscray complaint one) but I've seen the M2 (Tullamarine) ones fire up regularly enough. M1 (Fishermen's Bend) fires up fairly regularly though I don't know the exact clocking.

    I feel for the Tullamarine residents more than Footscray though. Sharps Rd Tullamarine will have 3 huge data centres; NextDC and Vantage bordering houses and then Air trunk ~800m up the road. Imagine when all 3 generator test coincide.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 4 weeks ago* (last edited 4 weeks ago)

    The water evaporating off doesn't concern me anywhere near as much as the fact that globally governments have told data centers to use diesel and gas power generators, rather than green energy.

    All data centers should be forced to ahere to strict pollution standards. Including on noise, light, and air pollution.

    The water issue feels like a distraction to the more damaging air pollution and green house emissions from fuel choices.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 4 weeks ago

    That is historically what they do, lie, then vote opposing to the lie. They'll try for killing Blackburn's, too, I bet, because of the rumour it has something to do with first nations people. Whoever the dickhead was who suggested one nation are ok, needs to look at their policy and voting history.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 4 weeks ago (1 child)

    You don't think it's fair enough for an industry that didn't have water rules to fight back when rules start being written that specifically target them?

    I think data centres use too much water and should be forced into building closed loop systems for example but this is the perfect time to fight back against all poor water usage everywhere.

    • Close golf courses to start planting urban native forests
    • Ration meat and dairy to Australians
    • Charge a tax/toll for non native gardens, including soccer and cricket fields
    • Force food packaging to display how much water went into making it
    • Jail time for watering concrete
    • Ordinance forcing bowls clubs to use astroturf instead of real grass
    • Ban pokies machines
  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 4 points 4 weeks ago

    It can be fucking scary how short-sighted the average person can be. I had a discussion with someone recently who lambasted me because I told him that Tasmania shouldn't be spending multiple billion dollars on a stupid sports stadium when we are struggling to afford critical improvements to our education and health systems.

    His response, "My kids grown up and I don't get sick. I'd rather watch the Footy than waste money improving our hospital. "

    So we will get a white elephant stadium that he will likely outlive, before he winds up in a shitty underfunded aged care facility, with a skeleton crew for staffing because Tasmania is suffering a critical shortage of young people have left for a more prosperous state, bitching about how he deserves better while actively voting against anyone that might give that to him.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 0 points 4 weeks ago (5 children)

    I've tried to reply to this a couple of times and not come off as condescending. I truly have. But I'm sorry, it just makes me laugh. Hottest UK summer on record "peaked at 38.1C"?

    I mean, yes - that's hot. I'll grant you that. But we get a whole season of that. Hell, parts of Australia (not the cities) get above 50. I think all the cities will see days in the 40s every year.

    So, I stand by my previous comment. You probably haven't had to deal with water restrictions in the UK.

    They are not inevitable, but they need us to believe that they are.

    I hope you are right, and I come back to this in the coming years and apologise to you for my insistence that these things are coming. I don't believe you are right, though.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 4 weeks ago (1 child)

    I'm familiar with Next DC. I spent a weekend moving our data centre into P1. We've spread to P1 and P2, now. I didn't know they fired up their genies every month, though. That actually seems like overkill. Before moving into Next DC, we used to do it annually during the September long weekend, coinciding with power works in the building that always happened that weekend.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 0 points 4 weeks ago (1 child)

    And how successful has any luddite movement in history been, ever?

    AI is just getting started. In fact, what we have now isn't even AI yet. That's just the term used for Language Learning Models. It isn't intelligent at all, it's kind of a turbo Google, which is good at aggregating human knowledge into something that sounds coherent. Do I love it? Not really. Could I personally live without it? Easily and happily. Will I be employable in 10 years if I choose to live without it? Doubtful. It is here, and it won't go away.

    Even if Australia gets zero AI data centres, it won't stop it being widely available to Australians. It is already widely used in Australia. So, at best you can say we saved Australia from the environmental impact of AI, while Australians actively contribute to the impact AI data centres make in other nations.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 4 weeks ago (2 children)

    At critical sites, most generators are fired up monthly for at least a 15 minutes. Most companies hate doing that because of the cost but do it to keep their tier 4 rating.

    I think all of NextDC are tier4 which means they have redundancies and fault tolerance to keep 99.999% uptime (about 5 minute outage per year).

    I don't understand all the NextDC hate though. They are the Australian DC company that just supplies each space to other businesses and government agencies. NextDC don't runs servers that mine your data or generate shitty videos, they supply space to for businesses to run servers. Go hate on Microsoft or Amazon for their massive datacentres that not only kill the environment but sell out our privacy as well.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 4 points 4 weeks ago (1 child)

    The average normie would rather pay a slick-talking conman to take them for a ride than put themselves at risk of committing to an idealistic struggle, and possibly turning into the kind of shabby, funny-smelling buffoon they are used to jeering at. That’s why everyone’s wading through slop and spam on Instagram and Facebook and wouldn’t set foot on Mastodon in a million years, or getting excited about AI-slop mockups of Adobe alternatives that might not work but at least don’t stink of open-source software, or conceding that it may be time to give fascism another try, if the only alternative is those awful over-earnest lefty ratbags.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 1 point 4 weeks ago* (last edited 4 weeks ago) (1 child)

    I think it might just be a product of feeling alienated, and overlooked by other parties:

    In a statement released on Thursday, the UFU said it is not yet endorsing any specific alternative party but “will say more once those parties have announced their own policies.” Marshall said the union had approached all parties, and of the responses it received, “One Nation’s is the most detailed and profound.”

    Marshall suggested this is likely to mean support for One Nation, challenging Labor in its regional city seats and outer suburban Melbourne seats, and the left-wing Greens.

    “One Nation has promised a significant rolling replacement program for fire appliances, the Liberals haven’t announced their policy, and we’re talking to the Greens — who are about community protection as well,” he said.

    “[One Nation’s Victorian leader] Warren Pickering has made some significant statements about firefighter safety — and we support those who support us.”

    I think One Nation are shit, but they're tactically shit. I suspect their tactic is to make a minimum amount of competent promises to a minimum amount of voting blocks (less people to please). Just enough to appear like the better choice (for those voting blocks). Sadly I think this will work in lots of places.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 10 points 4 weeks ago (3 children)

    On the one hand I get where the firefighters are coming from... On the other hand if they think one nation would piss on them if they were on fire...

    This is the problem with having a duopoly and a bunch of racist fascist who people think are the third choice. The Liberals don't give a fuck, PHONeys will give a fuck right up until Gina tells them not to then they will turn tail and bolt, if Labor aren't going to do the right thing then no one with any clout will.

    They should probably endorse the Greens, but they won't cause all the true blue Stralyans would rather die than vote for a bunch of filthy hippies, regardless of how much they agree with them. Greens are usually to dysfunctional to do much damage, at least if the Tasmanian ones are any indication of nationwide calibre.

  • source
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›