Yeah, cool. I'll look into Kohlers idea further. Seems sensible and acheivable?* (*except for the fact it's probably a political mine field and voters aren't great at evaluating long term plans).
comments
Love the A.Smith quotes. I hate how misrepresented he has been in modern monetarianist and neoliberal arguments. Although maybe his better work was always the Theory of Moral Sentiments. I don't know though, i never read it.
Probably that two to three decade time period, but actually deflating is risky.
I like Alan Kohler's idea that you'd spend the time equalising housing as an asset in the market. So slowly backing off the incentives on housing as an investment in the market, while increasing supply, and using the normal run of inflation in the economy to let other activities in the economy catch up in price.
When a long term trend of house price deflation occurs investors will flee the market, resulting in a massive crash.
It is basically unavoidable. So the number must go up.
You'd have to fix this really slowly tho right? Like however many decades it took for housing to inflate to this point, you'd basically have to spend that long deflating it?
Yeah nah. Maybe some government guarantees on reverse mortgages and stamp out the assholes
If you can't afford to support yourself where you live and don't want to move, get some housemates like everyone else.
2 minds on this. For one, if you got that much equity the you should have to fund yourself. But two, once you have lived somewhere for 40,50,60 years you are just used to that and unless you knock down rebuild town houses (not all can afford) you are forced to move to a new area.
Homes should def be part of the pension means test. You can't be sitting in a $3m house and expect to get the aged pension.
the states don't control the currency, loading a state up with non productive debt is a debacle of massive proportions. Eventually it all collapses...painfully,.or the Feds bail the state oit
The RBA's tools are adequate for their role.
I don't agree, they don't have a tool box they have 1 tool
another idea for taking money out is a temp Super tax surcharge increase, the money goes to savings not to the bank.
there's zero reason we can't fix for 20 years but it would blunt the IR only tool even more. NZ and Australia are the worst in the world in that respect.
Sure governments have done lots of stupid shit, like decades of reliance on mega long supply fossil fuel chains and not built enough rail nor moved to PT and medium density housing for example but that's squarely on the shoulders of dopey voters fucking around and now finding out. We're still building roads for fucks sake, no matter what experts like the IPCC have advised for 50 years.
This is fair, though how do you do things like raise taxes without everyone hating you? It's political suicide in the current climate
The RBA's tools are adequate for their role.
The government is supposed to be doing the detailed work of managing the economy through taxes and spending, they just... sometimes don't. And I don't think the solution is to transfer that role to the RBA.
This can't be an Australian post yeah ? Our cites can't raise funds with bonds for example and the city level governments aren't protected by the constitution and can be disbanded at the whim of the state itself.
the second thing is there are zero cities in Australia that would meet your Green criteria. Quite the opposite, we're a shit show of car dependency with hardly any green building imitative, with really shitty building codes seeing urban sprawl dominate, terrible zoning laws, cardboard homes with giant energy Intensive HVACs attached and near zero attention to intercity trains.
Aggressively implement vacancy tax. It's currently set at "self-reported" per Punters Politics recent video.
There there pet.
Perhaps "can live with" but most wouldn't choose it.
Most voters aren't particularly well informed. If you ask a home owner whether they want property prices to increase by 10% or 0% this year of course they will all say 10% because they don't really understand that the current property cycle is hurting everyone.
“Investors”.
Single home owners can live with it. Its investors putting the brakes on these measures.
Yep. No new news. We all know.
Abolish CGT discount, negative gearing. Increase land tax, and implement vacancy tax.
Everyone knows that this is what needs to be done but amazingly home owners don't want to do any of these things.
Well I'm glad the premiers are immune to inflation 🙄
Albo: "It's all the fault of the premiers and states!"
States:"It's all the fault of Albo and the Federal government!"
People:"Guess we're screwed. Again."
Thanks! This is definitely the closest I've come to what I'm looking-for.
Here's the top holdings of GBND, at the time of writing (2026):
- France (3.1%)
- EU (1.6%)
- Italy (1.6%)
- ...
- Germany (1.38%)
It looks like there's a bunch of bonds at different rates for duplicates of more of the EU, France, and Italy.
source: https://www.morningstar.com.au/investments/security/ASX/GBND/portfolio
So this appears to invest in bonds of countries, not cities (as far as I can tell).
But the fund description mentions that it "comprises a portfolio of global green bonds (using the definition applied by the Climate Bonds Initiative)". So I'd be curious if there's any other funds in the world that also get their info from the "Climate Bonds Initiative"
Oh i thought municpial was like, city council bonds? or something like this
if it's just government bonds then:
AGVT Earn attractive income from Australian government bonds
https://www.betashares.com.au/fund/australian-government-bond-etf/
If after specifically 'green' bonds: then this might be best:
GBND A portfolio of high-quality global green bonds that meet stringent ethical standards
Qld does
https://www.qtc.com.au/public-bonds/