[–] 1 point 48 minutes ago

I explained in other comments. But, first, a reminder. I'm writing my analysis. I'm not saying this is good or bad. People keep misunderstanding that. So I guess I gotta preface.

The main suspicion is that he was open to trade with China and pushing Nvidia itself to start working on the software development side. The trade with China part is the part being pushed in the media; but has very little evidence around it apart from normal methods of avoiding trade restrictions that all capitalist do. It's not to say it is good. CEOs should follow trade laws. But, none of them do. The whole world trade is made up of middlemen. So why is he special?

Google and others have been developing in house chips to remove their dependence on Nvidia hardware. Nvidia started to do the same. Realizing that if this AI game keeps going they can't stay in their hardware monopoly forever and world be forced to compete on both hardware (what they excell in) and software (what they do not).

Haung wanted to capitalize on their current hardware monopoly and sell to China. A huge market that any capitalist is dying to enter. So, any evidence of him circumventing trade restrictions is within the same separation via middlemen, that all corporations engage in. It keeps them safe from consequences. Notice how he's not being arrested. He just got pushed out.

Haung was not only looking to have Nvidia move more towards direct competition, but, using their advantage in hardware to manufacturer application specific chips that would run on Nvidias own proprietary hardware and software. Software that would be largely developed from open source models.

Now, a lot of people get this next part wrong. He was not looking to "put Chinese open source AI models" into Nvidia products. That's not how it works for corporations. He was going to leverage the base structures of open source models that outperform many of the closed source models from American companies, but, develop on top of them to develop a completely closed source dependency. Closed hardware, closed software, and all the benefits open source software development giving free labor.

The tech oligarchs aligned with the part of the Trump administration that are anti China. They see the writing on the wall for the life of the Trump admin, and are positioning themselves for an industry, in totality, that is non competitive. They want government mandates and restrictions on AI. But, not in the way the normal person does. Not stopping datacenters, no no no. They want to use the fear mongering of China to have the government ban open source AI models and basically place the keys to AI development in their hands and their hands only.

They are trying to monopolize the entire tech industry into a closed system. All while using "national security" as a reason for them to be given that monopoly power.

That is why I said that this is capitalist infighting. Haung was not playing this game. He was still playing a game of competition. Which died a long long time ago; and has really never been the goal of capitalism anyway.

They admit all this shit. You just have to actually listen to them.

https://youtu.be/3Fx5Q8xGU8k

"Competition is for losers"

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 0 points 9 hours ago* (3 children)

    Everytime someone says this thought terminating cliche instead of addressing a comment directly; normal people reading get turned off from people like you. So, thank you.

    Normal people want to read discussion. But, when the only people, time after time, that are actually trying to discuss and analyze the world, that are doing more than just reacting, are the people that call themselves Socialist, Marxist, or Communist. Well, we gain more attention and more credibility. And people like you look ridiculous.

    If you're only response is like this, which most people responding are, you are doing damage to your own position.

    If you have criticisms of something I said. I'm all ears. But, holy shit mate, there are already a bunch of replies already filled with your thought terminating cliche. A downvote is more useful for you, if you hate Marxist, than your comment. You're just screaming "nuh uh" like a toddler.

    I shouldn't be giving you advice. But, I'm a Marxist, I am incapable of not pointing out contradictions when I see them.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 21 hours ago

    Our weapons manufactures have been selling weapons to Russia via middlemen. We sure seem to be ok with those CEOs staying around.

    Like, I guess people don't follow this shit. And you won't hear CNN or your newsfeed saying it. But, it's wild to me that people can't see that this specific case of a CEO from Nvidia being terminated is just filled with contradictions.

    You should be suspicious when the tech oligarchs and the feds start punishing one of their own for lesser crimes than they all are already guilty of. With significantly more evidence I might add.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 21 hours ago (2 children)

    My dude. Elon musk sexually assaulted an employee on his private jet. Look, I'm autistic, I sometimes hyper-focus and miss the larger picture. So, I get it.

    But, holy shit, the way online comments do shit like you just did all the time. I don't know where it comes from. But it's a debate lord way of purposely misunderstanding the context of what is being talked about, looks for a single way to pretend someone is saying something else. And then defeating your own misunderstanding.

    The point I was making literally never had anything to do with the subordinate relationship or not. You're arguing about IF he should have been let go. I'm not. I'm ok with him being let go for that.

    I'm talking about WHY he was let go. Because there is a massive contradiction in the weight between the crimes he is guilty of and the crimes other current tech CEOs are guilty of.

    This contradiction should scream to you that the narrative and explanation for his termination are not truthful. That's my point.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 22 hours ago

    Sure. That'd be great. But, my comment is about analysis of a conflict within tech CEOs. The point of which is that the downfall of this specific CEO is not because of any power or pressure from the working class for justice. It is being done by and for the interest of the larger tech oligarchs. This isnt a win that gives the working class any meaningful progress of power. It is an example of the capitalists class concentration of power in fewer hands.

    Saying "let's bring more to justice" is only meaningful if there is a means of actually achieving that. If the CEO was taken down by something that could be learned from or replicated it would be meaningful to say what you are saying.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 8 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago)

    Hitting on the historical point you're making; Some people might not realize what point you're making.

    Though JFK was extremely anti catro and communist. He was rational enough to not fall in line with the larger interest to force a further direct cuban conflict. It's a part of history that still lives on to today.

    I'll plug a personal favorite podcast of mine because this post reminded me I need to listen to it again.

    https://blowback.show/Season-2

    Or for those that don't do podcast links. a YouTube playlist from a random channel

    Old seasons are free after a new season comes out. So, I don't feel bad linking a random re-upload. And, no, this isn't an ad. I'm just an autistic dude that loves these history podcasts. Cuba is probably a massively misunderstood topic for most Americans because of how it's taught in history class.

    The justifications for the oppression of a small island that dared to resist slavery and Imperialism still live on today.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 1 day ago*

    Notifications, sits on my phone, expand, read, reply. No worries mate. I respect anyone that takes the time to doubt their initial bias and take a second to realize it's wrong. I don't expect people to follow the problems with public schools. I just expect people to not assume their individual experience is standard. And writing a comment from personal experience and then being smart enough to realize it's wrong is the opposite of a person that I first assumed I was replying to. So, respect for that.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -30 points 1 day ago* (last edited 21 hours ago) (16 children)

    Fuck the former nvidia CEO. I'm not defending him. I'm analyzing why those with power want and allow one of their own to be purged. That's what you missed. And, honestly, I expected some anti China response even though the feds have admitted it was bull shit. I didn't expect someone to actually try to defend this as a moral choice by a corporation. The corporations working to burn our planet with datacenters? Those ones?

    Did you miss the part where a current CEO, Elon Musk, did a Nazi salute at the inauguration of the current president? Do you really think these choices are made on some moral grounds? By some HR rules? As a CEO? Dude, I got a fucking bridge for sale.

    Like, you're showing me the rule book. I get that. But you're living in a world in which we pretend the rule book is still being followed. You're pointing to the rule book, saying "dogs can't play basketball" while you get dunked on by a golden retriever.

    I get it. It's a nice idea. "Oh man, the real point is that he had a consensual relationship with an employee. It's against the rules".

    Are we living in the same world where Musk exist? Bill Gates? Bobby Kotick? Les Wexner? Leon Black? Howard Lutnick?

    I'm not being critical of a system that is working. I'm being critical of a system that has failed miserably. I know we're all looking for a win. And it's awesome to see a CEO get fucked. I get that.

    But that's an emotional response. It's not actually analyzing what is going on with the class conflict. If you understood your class position; you'd understand that this is nothing more than a conflict within the upper class. They point to the rules when it is convenient for their interests, and they will write black bars on pages that are not.

    This is an example of the ruling class of this country concentrating a common interest. Anyone that is not following the path, that is not falling in line with tech fascism, will be purged. And the most important to purge are those who's material capitalist interest do not align with the others. This is a purge of someone within the capitalist class that, ironically, like yourself, is not understanding their class position.

    Like, restrictions on exports? My dude, our weapons manufactures sell weapons through proxies to Russia. Capital does this shit. They go through the global trade networks to maximize profits. You should be asking why it's being punished in this case. Not believing the people, that do the same shit every day, pretend they are appalled by it.

    I'm not defending. I'm analyzing.

    Edit: damn, back a day later and tons of downvotes without a single reply that actually responds to any of the points I made.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -87 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago) (34 children)

    So, letting go of your CEO because he cheated on his wife is what we expect from companies now?

    Damn, someone's gotta tell all the companies with CEOs with literal sexual assault lawsuits, visits to Epsteins island, and daily talks with our pedophile in chief in the white house.

    Like, it really goes to show how stupid people are that even though the feds have admitted that the original lady has no connections to Chinese intelligence agencies; that we're acting like this is some big win because a billionaire CEO essentially had a coup occur by other billionaires in the tech industry.

    Yes, the dude is pro trade with China. That was his crime. He wanted to sell shit. So has every single CEO for literally half a century. They want to sell shit to markets that will buy shit.

    This isn't a victory against billionaire CEOs. This is infighting happening within the capitalist class. The rest of the tech oligarchs want to ban open source AI from China. So they can monopolize access to information and make compute a subscription service. He was in favor of open source AI models and as Google and others work towards their own chip manufacturing he shifted nvidia in a similar way to start development on the software side using open source models. THAT IS WHY HE GOT PUSHED OUT.

    They don't give a fuck that he cheated on his wife. They admit he's not a spy and not connected to a spy. They just took you for a ride and pushed out a dude who's own capitalist class interest did not align with the rest of the oligarchy.

    They hang out with the dude that sexually assaulted a woman on his airplane and did a literal Nazi salute twice as Trump was sworn in. They don't give a fuck about affairs and they don't actually believe he was an intelligence threat.

    Edit: Downvote? Nah, reply. I appreciate the one person that did.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 2 days ago* (2 children)

    There are plenty of states and schools that charge for bus pickup. Hawaii being a literal state wide mandate. But even California allows it for public schools.

    Technology fees are everywhere mate. Hell, there are schools requiring online homework programs that use private institutions programs and require a software license.

    I don't think you've been paying attention to the clusterfuck of awful unregulated public schools that exist. Your personal experience from your childhood is not a good way to assume the world works.

    Edit: looks like you deleted. Guess you did a quick Google search. Respect.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 2 days ago

    I think you're confusing maga with capitalism. Or blaming the currently active right wing movement for the larger issues with neoliberalsim and austerity measures.

    Maga didn't invent charging kids for lunch or charter schools. Politics didn't start when you started paying attention to it. The problems with capital attempting to suck profit from every portion of public service has been around long before maga and has been historically a bipartisan process since Reagan and Clinton.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 12 points 3 days ago* (6 children)

    Public school is free for every kid. Accept the lunch fees, the supplies that get pushed onto the teachers when parents can't afford them, technology fees, sports fees, transportation fees, field trip fees, and anywhere the state can suck away funding from mostly non white schools that are underfunded because of property values and property tax structures that fund them. Resulting in a city with a high school tennis court and swimming pool; next to a city with students using history books from before 9/11.

    So, yeah, I'd like Medicare for all to NOT be like public schools. I'd rather it more like current Medicare. But, for all. And fix public schools too.

  • source
  • [–] 22 points 3 days ago* (last edited 3 days ago) (1 child)

    That's true for a lot of parts of evolutionary biology. Especially on a species level in terms of "micro evolution".

    But the distribution of blood vessels and their branch points are a fundamental optimization that exists not only for humans but for essentially all living things that have blood.

    It's a very well optimized part of evolution that seems to only "break" with more recent extreme changes in humans and lifestyles of lower activity.

    It's why we get stories of people randomly dying from blood clots in the legs. The system is being forced into a state that it never had to deal with. A level of inactivity that reaches the degree of modern humans would have, in the past, meant you were dead from some other reason long before the body had to deal with blood clots. In addition to levels of obesity and blood pressure that could never have been obtained by any meaningful percentage of the population until now.

    It's well optimized for millions of years of, what is essentially, an extremely complex fluid dynamics problem that evolution solved impressively well. Meaning, the best computer simulations optimizing for the same goals create nearly identical paths for what we see today.

    The TLDR being that you should go to the gym, take your dog for a long walk, shake your legs when you're at your desk. Your body is telling you to move for a reason. It's systems are optimized around the assumption that you'd be moving a lot every day.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 4 points 3 days ago*

    The leagues of nations is debating how many troops Germany is allowed to have in the 1920s.

    Its cute to think it still matters. But, any nation that isn't preparing itself to be ready has not read a history book.

    Those with good moral intentions that break the "rules" are prepared for those that inevitably don't have good intentions and do the same.

    I hope after ww3. If we aren't fighting with sticks and stones afterwards. We realize that in the years leading up to major conflict; that these "League of Nations" or "United Nations" types of structures only seem to serve the purpose of providing a false sense of order if they have no material means of enforcement.

    You can't have a "global agreement" that has no global enforcement mechanism. Otherwise you're better off not having it. At least then we aren't all pretending the Germans are just "making Germany great" again as they supercharge their military right in front of our eyes.

    The nations agreements to come together against thoss that violate national law was proven to be useless with the US and Israel. These institutions are worse than useless.

    Cool, vote against killer robots. I'm sure that'll stop them from being built. /s

  • source
  • [–] 82 points 3 days ago* (last edited 3 days ago) (9 children)

    The blood path and the way different routes split through the body is actually highly optimized. Like, it looks like a branch network because it is. It's optimized around allowing blood flow and deciding forks based on reducing blood clots while still ensuring all regions of the body have enough blood. Even the angle at which the vessels split is optimized around increasing throughput and then chance of clots. Exceptions of course. But it's really interesting to spend a hyper-focus hour on if you're bored.

    It's actually a really interesting system.

    I know. I know. The meme is a joke. But, I wouldn't be a Linux user for decades if my brain wasn't also interested in these cool parts of evolutionary biology or any other subject around optimization.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 4 days ago

    yet they still prolong civil wars for selfish gain

    Would be interested in what specific conflicts you're referring to. I am definitely critical of China for engaging in trade with essentially zero care for the conditions of the state they are trading with. Israel being the obvious criticism. Are those types of trade relations with countries what you're referring to? I agree if that's what you mean.

    They still let their companies do whatever

    This is in conflict to the normal complaints of China "disappearing" people. So, are you saying they don't do that? Because the famous cases of this are from businessmen that start speaking against the party, or doing actual social crimes.

    I have criticism of China's free speech restrictions on individual citizens. But to say that China "let's companies do whatever they want" is in complete contradiction to the countless "violations of freedom" that the Western media speaks about. Because those are entirely made up of the capitalist of China stepping out of line with the party; or engaging in social murder like crimes.

    They aren't better out of benevolence, but because they have a different imperial strategy.

    I hear the language of the left here being used in a non material way. If you're someone that has the word "imperial strategy" in your vocabulary it shocks me to hear someone describe a system based on idealism as the core. "The purpose of a system is what it does." Its odd to conclude with a point of criticism that is rooted in idealism. It is rooted in the western idea that China is just "waiting for its moment of attack" with no material reason to conclude that.

    If China wanted to start being aggressive and start it's Imperialist expansion there was no better time than the Iran invasion. You think America was ready to defend Taiwan when it was taking interceptors out of Korea to send them to Israel? Yet China decided to "wait" and instead reduce its purchases of oil to assist it's trade partners in East Asia.

    At a certain point this "waiting for the right moment" Imperialist China narrative needs to die. They have proven their intentions are based entirely on offering a less parasitic form of trade than the US offers. One that is entirely without the use of military conflict.

    I'm not sure how you can call that imperial strategy in a world where US Imperialism still exists. If the US was gone. Sure, it would be insane to engage in trade relations with states like Israel. But, you're criticism is in a vacuum and not in the context of the cold war being waged against China by the west.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 26 points 5 days ago*

    Because it definitely is. It's so embarrassing that how much everything about their reasons are bull shit that I don't even feel like it's worth the effort to debunk it anymore.

    Like, is there anyone out there actually believing the crap they regurgitated?

    "It's not the new AI systems, all they do is provide information (data). They aren't connected in anyway"

    "All we know is that the server infrastructure was overloaded with data"

    Like, they added the new AI systems and they ddosed themselves. I'm not quoting directly. But that's basically what the white house briefing said last night.

    This wire crap screams of someone looking for any minor and unrelated problem that occurred yesterday to place blame on. There probably was a construction project that had some problem yesterday. It definitely wasn't the cause though.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: next ›