the TLDW take away is discuss health span and quality of life outcomes not only with your care team but other people who have done the operation so you can make informed decisions.
Drains!!! Make sure you have water in all your ubends
Quality of life expectations are really the missing piece of taking on these major medical operations.
Can you share a study that points to such fast recovery of normal insulin response among zc dieters?
No, but if you look at the glucose tolerance test literature, is called priming. And it's well known. Especially when ogtts were done in populations that weren't quite so processed food heavy in the 1900s.
If you look for one of the keto papers I posted in the ketogenic group, on ogtts, you'll see it - https://discuss.online/post/39394356 here you go, they talk all about priming
I'm so curious though how will you make that argument without knowing anything about me or the zero carber?
I'll use the same general assumptions you use to call the zero carbers sick, just reversed in my favor.
The point is, you can be perfectly healthy on pretty much any diet, including zero carb. Just being on the diet does not mean you're unhealthy.
tolerate carb heavy meals, ocassional sugary treats etc for years (or entire lives) without adverse effects
If someone get's sick when they walk into Chernobyl, and their sickness resolves when they leave Chernobyl, then that person should avoid going to Chernobyl. Saying they are sick because they can't survive in Chernobyl is presupposing the solution to the problem.
Someone who is zero carb for a long time, doesn't have excess adiposity, i.e. great metabolic health - they can go back to binging on pizza for a long time.... if they want to. No reason they can't, they are not disabled.
However, someone who is UNWELL, and does zero carb to help their issues - is going to take a long time to fix all of their metabolic problems. If it takes 20 years to get to the edge of diabetes, stepping back from the edge is a good idea, but your not safe. The behavior that pushed them right to the edge is the same behavior that will push them over if they return to it.
It's reasonable to say this morbidly obese T2D resolves (cures) their diabetes going low carb... but that only puts them back on the edge of the cliff, now they have to climb all the way down to build up the "tolerance" so they can indulge again like they did for 20 years.
My main complaint with the word "treat" is it doesn't communicate resolution. People can treat their diabetes with crystal therapy, doesn't mean it does anything. Keto cures diabetes (for many people), if you want to call that remission fine, but treat is too weak of a expression.
I don’t think the damage caused by alcohol is reversed in a person with ALD if they stop drinking. Sure the symptoms are reduced
keto reverses (not treats, reverses) FLD
ut don’t you feel there’s still some abnormality? If a zc dieter tries to eat a pound or 2 of cake they probably won’t process it as well as a healthy person.
First off, that is unfair - I would argue a zero carber (especially the lean ones) are far healthier then you! Zero carb people are not unhealthy.
Second - if you prime your pancreas, it will have a cache of insulin it can use. - so yes, the first bit of cake will have a higher elevated glucose levels, but the next piece of cake - totally normal. You can argue you NEVER want to spike your glucose, but if you look at area under the curve, the zero carb person will have less elevated area then the high carb eater.
Update - a better analogy occurs to me, a seasoned alcoholic can drink you under the table. They have a very high alcohol tolerance. However, that does not make them healthier.
Some diseases result in exercise or some food intolerance. You can say as long as I don’t exercise or avoid these foods I have no symptoms. But that’s not the disease itself being cured or reversed.
You can consider T2D a condition of carbohydrate intolerance, but per the definition of controlled blood glucose the condition of T2D can be cured without medicine.
Using your logic someone with "PREDIABETES" has T2D, right? They haven't demonstrated the problem, but they show a intolerance, but you wouldn't describe these pre-diabetics as having type 2 diabetes, would you?
What is a carb tolerance? Please define it
A alcoholic with fatty liver who treats their fatty liver by not drinking alcohol is not cured because if they start drinking again they will get sick again?
Type 2 diabetes is a condition defined by uncontrolled blood glucose levels, if you can treat it to the point where you don't need medicine and your glucose is under control... It's cured by definition of the condition.
I will argue, even if the true intervention has a varying effect, it’s sorta-mostly OK to just take a hazard ratio from a paper and convert it to a change in life expectancy using this curve
This assume the interventions are independent.
This math salad is exactly why weak hazard ratios should not be used for personal health advice, but to form a falsifiable hypothesis and do a actual interventional test.
You cannot inform on cause and effect from weak observational "signals" and no amount of mathematical gymnastics changes that. You actually have to perform experiments
If you are in a one-on-one back and forth conversation, and your partner is downvoting everything you post, they are not having a good faith discussion with you.
It is a fuck you. Why spend time and effort on someone just throwing negativity at you?
There is a list of known working banking apps on gos: https://privsec.dev/posts/android/banking-applications-compatibility-with-grapheneos/
Basically mine all work, but I had to enable compatibility mode or other hoops for them
They have never been good.
At best they are "less bad" then sugar. That's harm reduction not a endorsement.
I.e. just because nicotine patches are less bad then smoking we don't consider them a good long term thing non smokers should use.
Cephalic response : insulin goes high anticipating sugar, but the carbs don't arrive, causing blood sugar to come down, causing increased hunger.
Take a look at finetune as well https://github.com/ronitsingh10/FineTune