[–] 1 point 2 months ago (1 child)

except accidentally trying low carb diets

Oh, thats quite a accident!

May I suggest getting fasting insulin checked as well? from my reading of the literature, it's the single biggest lever in getting t2d and cardiovascular issues under control or even reversed. the best way to achieve low insulin levels is the low carb diets you accidentally tried before.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

    This is exciting! Everyone should have easy turn key access to their essential biometrics

    there is zero evidence that continually measuring ketones would be useful in any sense. That's different from the purported use of CGMs, which is to monitor for glucose spikes in response to specific foods (and even then, the evidence that monitoring glucose spikes in healthy people has any benefits is really thin).

    If someone really wanted to measure their ketone levels there are simple urine tests that do it - there is no need to measure it continuously for healthy people.

    It's nice to see know it all bias exists on hackernews too. This person clearly hasn't heard of the gki

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 2 months ago

    A whole article on scientific evidence and no mention of the evidence pyramid, no discussion of observational epidemiology and its strength in predicting causal relationships? Seems like very preliminary article.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 2 months ago

    Reconcile that people who go ketogenic / zero carb tend to resolve their hypertension.... so maybe the benefit isn't the elevated blood pressure itself, but adequate blood flow at all?

  • source
  •  

    This is how a literature review and critique is done, just talking about the power, scope, and gaps in data. No name calling, just a discussion of what data is available.

    TLDW - a MD makes a pro-seed oil video, and Westman goes over the strength and applicability of their evidence to a ketogenic population, intermediate markers, and confounders.

    Seed-oils are a problem, but they are less impactful than hyperi-insulinemia - So if you can only fix one, fix the carbohydrate intake.

    Seed oils have become one of the most controversial topics in nutrition, with people online calling them toxic, inflammatory, and one of the biggest drivers of modern disease. In this video, Dr. Eric Westman reacts to Dr. Brad Stanfield’s evidence-based breakdown of the seed oil debate and examines whether the science actually supports the fear. The discussion covers where the anti-seed oil concerns came from, including the history of replacing saturated fat with polyunsaturated fats, the omega-3 to omega-6 ratio, heating seed oils, oxidation, trans fats, and the role of processed food. Dr. Westman also explains why this debate can be confusing in the context of low-carb and keto metabolism, where the effects of carbohydrates, glucose, insulin, and metabolic syndrome may matter far more than many people realize. This is a nuanced discussion on butter, margarine, seed oils, inflammation, heart disease risk, and what the clinical relevance of all this may actually be in the real world. If you’ve been wondering whether seed oils are truly dangerous or whether the internet has overblown the issue, this video will help you think through the evidence more clearly.

    summerizerSeed oils and the real target

    • The video starts with the question of whether internet warnings about seed oils being toxic, inflammatory, and terrible for health are wrong.
    • Seed oils are common cooking and processed-food fats from soybean, corn, sunflower, and similar seeds; olive oil is separate because it comes from fruit.
    • Westman agrees that seed oils are overrated as a proven problem, because clinical trials have not nailed down seed oils as an independent risk.
    • The practical problem is ultra-processed food, takeaway food, repeated high-heat frying, and carb-heavy junk food. Historical shift from saturated fat to seed oils
    • The low-fat era pushed people away from butter, lard, and animal fats and toward margarine, seed oils, and higher-carbohydrate foods.
    • That shift followed weak science against saturated fat and helped build the processed-food environment that came with obesity, diabetes, and heart disease.
    • Stanfield stays closer to the old saturated-fat paradigm, where moving away from saturated fat is tied to heart-health improvement.
    • Westman's view is that insulin resistance, glucose, insulin, metabolic syndrome, and type 2 diabetes matter more than saturated fat in food. Omega-3, omega-6, and inflammation
    • Linoleic acid is an essential omega-6 fat, so the issue cannot be simplified into omega-6 is bad and omega-3 is good.
    • The omega-3 to omega-6 ratio made sense to Westman historically, especially through low-carb teaching about membranes and inflammation.
    • Test-tube and animal mechanisms can look plausible, but the clinical question is whether they matter in humans eating real diets.
    • The ratio concern is often an omega-3 intake problem, not proof that normal omega-6 intake causes widespread inflammation. Human trials, clinical relevance, and low-carb metabolism
    • Stanfield cites a 10-week randomized trial where obese participants eating more omega-6 seed oils had less liver fat, lower inflammation, and lower insulin than the saturated-fat group.
    • Stanfield also cites a 2017 meta-analysis of 30 randomized trials finding no meaningful increase in inflammatory markers from higher linoleic acid intake.
    • Population evidence is used to connect higher linoleic acid intake with lower diabetes and heart-disease risk.
    • Westman handles those findings cautiously because most trials study carbohydrate eaters, not people in low-carb, keto, or carnivore-like metabolism.
    • Low-carb metabolism changes fat handling; Phinney, Volek, and Forsythe showed that higher-fat low-carb diets can have lower circulating fat markers than lower-fat high-carb diets.
    • The Cochrane saturated-fat review shows a cardiovascular-event reduction, but the absolute effect is not huge and the subjects were generally carbohydrate eaters.
    • Books by Gary Taubes and Nina Teicholz lay out the weak saturated-fat and LDL case that belongs to the old paradigm. Heating seed oils, trans fats, and oxidation
    • Early hydrogenated margarines created trans fats and added confusion to the seed-oil and heart-health story.
    • Westman does not accept that the trans-fat association was as large as the public story made it, and he still rejects the saturated-fat avoidance logic behind it.
    • A 2022 meta-analysis found that heating oils below 200°C did not create meaningful trans fats, while very high or prolonged heating did.
    • A sunflower-oil heating study found only small oxidation changes, while repeatedly heated oil in a fryer-like setting increased inflammatory markers.
    • The everyday concern is not fresh seed oil on a salad; it is repeatedly heated oil inside fries, takeaways, and processed foods. Final practical view
    • Westman agrees with Stanfield that seed oils are not a proven central risk and that cutting junk food is a good move.
    • Westman disagrees with Stanfield that moving away from saturated fat is strongly supported for everyone, especially in low-carb metabolism.
    • In Westman's clinical lens, glucose, insulin, A1C, type 2 diabetes, and metabolic syndrome are more measurable and more powerful than seed-oil tracking.
    • When patients reverse very high A1C with food changes while eating more saturated fat and without targeting seed oils, seed-oil avoidance cannot be the main explanation.
    • More follow-up and published results are still needed, and people with success should share outcomes from the metabolic approach.

    References

    Muscle strength memory? (hackertalks.com)
     

    Lost 10kg from my bench press on a two week trip. I was not getting enough protein on the trip, but I stayed on the dirty side of the diet.

    One week later, after eating clean protein at home to satiety, I gain +10kg on my bench press vs before the trip.

    That's a 20kg barbell bench press change in one week!

    How does that work? Do muscles have some sort of strength memory they can rapidly regrow to?

    During the trip: lots of seed oils, some dubious sauces, lots of spices.. I attempted to scrape it off, but you can't get it all. I wasn't hungry, but I definitely wasn't eating my normal protein target.

     

    Dr. Georgia Ede, MD, is a Harvard-trained, board-certified psychiatrist based in Northampton, Massachusetts, USA. Her interest in nutrition arose after discovering a new way of eating that reversed several bewildering health problems she had developed in her early 40′s, including fibromyalgia, migraines, chronic fatigue syndrome and IBS.

    Dr. Ede acquired her bachelor’s in biology from Carleton College in Minnesota. Then for seven years she worked as a research assistant in the fields of biochemistry, diabetes and wound healing. She earned her M.D. from the University of Vermont and completed her residency in general adult psychiatry at Cambridge Hospital in 2002.

    After five years in general practice, she joined Harvard University Health Services from 2007 to 2013 as a staff psychopharmacologist and was the first psychiatrist there to offer nutrition consultation as an option to students, faculty and staff with mental health concerns.

    From 2013 to June 2018 she was the psychiatrist for Smith College in Northampton, Massachusetts, where she provided nutrition consultation as well as medication and psychotherapy services to Smith students.

    Now Dr. Ede devotes all of her time to nutritional psychiatry and directs her efforts on studying, writing, and speaking about the strong scientific connection between food and brain health.

    summerizerMental health rests on nutrient sufficiency, toxin avoidance, and stable metabolism, and meat supplies a central nutrient source.

    Nutrient sufficiency

    • The brain is built mostly from fat, protein, cholesterol, and small amounts of carbohydrate, and it uses vitamins and minerals to extract energy from glucose and ketones.
    • Meat supplies needed nutrients in usable forms without anti-nutrients, while plant foods can lack key nutrients, contain harder-to-access forms, and include absorption blockers.
    • Zinc, vitamin B6, and iron matter because low levels impair the same neurotransmitter systems that antidepressants try to amplify.
    • Carnitine and choline matter for energy balance, electrolyte balance, cell integrity, acetylcholine, learning, and memory, and animal foods supply them more easily than plant foods.
    • Brain cholesterol is so important that the brain makes it locally behind the blood-brain barrier, independent of dietary cholesterol.
    • Animal protein is complete, dense, digestible, and bioavailable, while plant protein requires more planning and arrives with anti-nutrients.

    Animal fats and brain structure

    • The brain’s fat includes saturated fat, monounsaturated fat, DHA, and arachidonic acid, so animal fat is part of brain structure and function.
    • DHA supports mitochondrial membranes, retina, synapses, cortical development, cellular communication, and higher intelligence, and plant foods supply non-DHA precursors.
    • Arachidonic acid supports cholesterol metabolism, reproduction, labor, brain development, cell migration, endocannabinoids, inflammation, and healing, so reducing it to inflammation misses its role.
    • Linoleic acid conversion to arachidonic acid is unreliable enough that direct animal-source arachidonic acid is the efficient route.

    Toxicity and immune stress

    • Adding meat is not enough when the diet still contains brain-active plant toxins, because many people with mental illness already eat meat.
    • Nightshade glycoalkaloids, oxalates, lectins, gluten, and dairy peptides can affect acetylcholine, crystals, the blood-brain barrier, immune activity, and psychiatric symptoms.
    • Gluten removal matters in mental illness because schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and autism connect with gluten or casein antibodies, leaky gut markers, and immune activation in some cases.
    • The 14-year-old gluten psychosis case includes severe hallucinations, paranoia, suicidal thinking, no celiac disease, symptom remission on a gluten-free diet, and relapse with wheat capsules.
    • The gut can affect the brain through the vagus nerve, cytokines, inflammation, the microbiome, and blood-brain barrier changes, even when leaky gut is not the whole explanation.

    Metabolic mayhem

    • Mental illness involves inflammation, oxidation, neurotransmitter imbalance, insulin resistance, and related metabolic disruption.
    • Serotonin, dopamine, glutamate, and GABA shift with diet because stress, oxidation, inflammation, refined carbohydrates, and seed oils push tryptophan away from serotonin and toward excessive glutamate.
    • Excess glutamate damages BDNF, neuroplasticity, hippocampal volume, proteins, lipids, DNA, mitochondria, and the blood-brain barrier.
    • Insulin resistance connects with schizophrenia before antipsychotic exposure and with worse bipolar course, rapid cycling, and weaker lithium response.
    • Depression is especially tied to inflammation, and PPAR-gamma agonists and anti-inflammatory medicines point toward metabolic drivers beyond neurotransmitter drugs.
    • Ketogenic diets calm brain chemistry in epilepsy, share mechanisms with anticonvulsant mood stabilizers, lower intracellular sodium, and may apply across psychiatric disorders.

    Why carnivore

    • A carnivore diet removes plant toxins while retaining animal-source nutrients, making it both an inclusion diet for what the brain uses and an elimination diet for what some people no longer tolerate.
    • Some people may lose plant tolerance through gut or immune damage linked to pesticides, plastics, antibiotics, drugs, processed foods, or other environmental pressures.
    • We do not yet have direct studies of carnivore diets for mental health disorders, but carnivore makes sense as a hypothesis because it removes plant toxins, keeps animal-source nutrients, overlaps with ketogenic mechanisms, and people can test whether they feel better.

    References

     

    So beefy... veal glue, portable soup - Your Friend, Obedient and Humble Servant - Miller

    summerizerPocket soup, portable soup, and veal glue

    • The video makes the 18th- and 19th-century travel ration known as pocket soup, portable soup, or veal glue.
    • It is a way to move soup by reducing meat broth into a compact dried piece for land expeditions and naval voyages.
    • It is a precursor to the bouillon cube because hot water can turn a small piece back into broth.
    • The earliest origins are lost, but late-16th-century Hugh Plat, a French dictionary entry, and Lady Anne Blencowe's 1694 veal glue recipe show the idea already circulating.

    Making the broth and glue

    • The recipe begins with 15 pounds, or 7 kilograms, of bone-in beef shank because the bones, tendons, sinew, and connective tissue supply the collagen.
    • The meat is covered with water, heated, skimmed repeatedly, then simmered for 8 to 12 hours until the meat is spent.
    • Old recipes give vivid endpoints: Hannah Glasse says the meat is good for nothing, William Gelleroy says it has lost its virtue, and William Byrd says to boil the meat to rags.
    • After the solids are removed, the broth is cooled so the fat hardens on top, because remaining fat can turn rancid and shorten storage life.
    • The broth is strained through cloth and reduced very slowly, without burning, until only a gelatinous collagen mass remains.
    • A slow cooker on the lowest setting works because modern stovetops struggle to stay low enough for the long reduction.
    • The batch takes about 14 hours to reduce after the first long simmer, then it cools into a rubbery slab.
    • The slab is cut into small pieces and dried on cloth for about 5 days, matching William Byrd's instruction to dry smaller pieces separately.

    Flavor and use

    • A plain beef version keeps the finished soup flexible, while Hannah Glasse's flavored version locks anchovies, mace, cloves, pepper, onions, herbs, and bread crust into every future broth.
    • Reconstitution is simple: a small piece goes into boiling water and dissolves into a clear, beefy broth.
    • The 1694 recipe says a nutmeg-sized piece makes half a pint of broth, and a whole leg of veal produces only a hand-sized piece of glue.
    • Chewing it dry works in principle, and Elizabeth Dubois even advertised it as chewable while hunting, but the concentrated beef flavor makes that a bad way to eat it.
    • The usable form is broth, sauce base, or stew base, not a piece chewed like candy.

    Travel, navy, and scurvy

    • Pocket soup becomes common in early-18th-century home cookbooks because travelers could make a batch before a long journey.
    • The 1747 Art of Cookery advertisement singles out pocket or portable soup as useful for travelers, strong soups, veal broth, sauces, and trips to the Indies and back.
    • Elizabeth Dubois turns it into a commercial product in London and receives a Royal Navy contract in 1756.
    • Captain James Cook carries portable soup among preserved foods on the Endeavour in 1768 and uses it as part of an anti-scurvy regimen.
    • Cook's anti-scurvy logic is partly wrong: sauerkraut and citrus juices help against scurvy, but portable soup, malt, mustard, vinegar, sugar, and molasses do not.
    • Cook still has celery boiled with portable soup and oatmeal for the crew's breakfast when fresh celery is available.

    Lewis and Clark and later decline

    • Meriwether Lewis orders 200 pounds of portable soup in 1803 because he sees it as one of the most essential expedition supplies.
    • He ends up with 193 pounds costing $289.50, packed into 32 canisters for the westward journey.
    • The Corps of Discovery usually saves it for necessity because it is useful but not especially desirable.
    • During the Bitterroot Mountain crossing, scarce food forces the party to use portable soup heavily for about 11 days.
    • Some men dislike it enough to kill and roast a colt, but the portable soup remains one of the few available foods until they leave the mountains.
    • In 1815, Gilbert Blane's comparative health work on the British Navy undercuts portable soup's anti-scurvy reputation and points toward citrus juice.
    • Portable soup continues for overland travel into the mid-19th century, with Eliza Leslie still recommending it in 1857 for friends going to the Pacific.
    • Canned goods, Liebig's extract of meat, Oxo, and eventually bouillon cubes make portable soup obsolete by the 20th century.

    References

     

    This study aimed to characterize the gut microbiota composition and predicted metabolic functionality of healthy individuals with long-term adherence to a carnivore diet and to compare those with confounder-matched omnivore controls. Methods

    A cross-sectional analysis was conducted including ten healthy individuals following a carnivore diet for an average of 36 ± 11·9 months and 874 confounder-matched controls. 16S rRNA sequencing was used to assess composition and predicted functionality. Diversity metrics, differential abundance testing and multivariate regression modeling were applied to evaluate the associations.

    Carnivore diet adherence was a dominant independent predictor of microbiota composition and predicted functionality. Alpha-diversity metrics did not differ significantly between groups, whereas carnivores exhibited higher Chao1 richness. Several low-abundance phyla, including Synergistetes and Desulfobacterota, were enriched. Functional profiling revealed substantial metabolic differences, with significant differences in over 300 metabolic pathways and 13 functional modules, including those related to amino acid degradation, vitamin B synthesis, energy metabolism, gut barrier integrity and protein fermentation. Modules associated with cytotoxicity, inflammation and constipation were also elevated. Regression analyses confirmed that these taxonomic and functional shifts were primarily attributable to the diet itself.

    Long-term carnivore diet adherence leads to distinct taxonomic changes and profound functional alterations of the gut microbiota.

    These findings challenge the assumption that dietary fiber is essential for maintaining microbiota diversity, suggesting the potential prebiotic effects of certain nutrients in the animal-based diet, while highlighting potential long-term risks associated with an exclusively animal-based diet.

    Full Paper - https://doi.org/10.1530/MAH-25-0015

     

    Although the vast majority of patients in forensic psychiatry are treated using pharmacological agents, clinical and ethical concerns about their use have led to the consideration of alternative strategies to reduce aggression that is common in forensic psychiatric settings. One non-invasive and benign biologically-based treatment approach involves nutrition. This article provides a mini-review of the recent evidence on four salient nutritional factors associated with aggressive behavior, namely omega-3 fatty acids, vitamin D, magnesium, and zinc. The current evidence base indicates that lower omega-3 levels are associated with increased aggression. Although research on vitamin D and zinc in relation to aggressive behavior is more limited, there is initial evidence that they are negatively associated with aggression in healthy participants and in psychiatric samples. The relationship between magnesium and aggression varies depending on how magnesium is assessed. Findings from experimental trials reveal that nutritional intervention in the form of omega-3 supplementation has the potential to serve as an effective mode of treatment, with effects that can last beyond the intervention period. There is also support for the utility of nutrition to improve our understanding of how social processes are linked to aggression. In light of the nascent, but promising findings on the role of nutritional factors on aggressive behavior, directions for future research are discussed.

    https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1176061

     

    In a world where 92 million Americans take statins, one man's unexpected health journey uncovers a medical mystery that could upend everything we think we know about cholesterol and heart health.

    When engineer Dave Feldman reverses his pre-diabetes with a low-carb diet, he feels invincible—until a routine blood test reveals sky-high LDL cholesterol, putting him at odds with decades of medical advice. Torn between feeling the healthiest he’s ever been and warnings of catastrophic heart disease, Dave refuses to accept easy answers. What begins as a personal experiment quickly expands into a global investigation, challenging the mainstream science that shapes our beliefs.

    The Cholesterol Code is more than a documentary—it’s a high-stakes David-versus-Goliath battle for truth. What if our fear of cholesterol has been fueled more by profit than the science? What if low-carb and keto diets—dismissed and demonized—hold the key to reversing the global epidemic of chronic disease? Driven by curiosity and grounded in science, the film follows Dave and a team of researchers through a landmark research study using high-resolution heart imaging.

    The results raise a daring question– have we been fighting the wrong enemy all along? Part personal journey, part investigative thriller, The Cholesterol Code explores what happens when science meets an open mind. It’s a story for anyone who’s ever questioned the status quo—and wondered if the truth might be more complex than we’ve been led to believe.

    https://cholesterolcodemovie.com/

    Available for streaming on the standard platforms (Amazon/FMHY 🦜✅)

     

    can nutrition debates be clarified by better language? Amber O’Hearn, independent researcher and writer with a math/computer science background, makes the case across privacy tech, computational linguistics, low-carb history, carnivore nutrition, vitamin C, ketones, LDL, and the tension between anecdotes, mechanisms, and prospective data.

    summerizerCore thesis and wording

    • Meat has nutrients as well as protein, and vegetables having nutrients does not make plants uniquely necessary for every person.
    • Vitamin C need depends on metabolic condition, dietary pattern, scurvy prevention, antioxidant aims, and spare factors from meat; a plant-free person with good health is not automatically harmed by less vitamin C intake.
    • Low measured ketones in keto-adapted people are not automatically proof of better ketone efficiency; when ketones are not high enough for the brain, glucose has to rise.
    • Precision matters because association language can slide into causal language; red meat can be linked with cancer in observational data without proving a causal chain from meat to cancer.
    • The word overeating can become circular when it only means eating followed by weight gain; that wording hides the actual mechanism behind weight gain.
    • Calories-in/calories-out is bookkeeping and thermodynamics, not a causal mechanism; weight loss means more energy left than came in, but it does not prove intentional restriction caused the loss.
    • The useful nutrition dispute is why someone ate less or more and why someone moved less or more, not only whether energy balance arithmetic closed.

    Amber’s background

    • Amber spends her time on family, reading, writing, metabolic topics, neuroscience, evolution, tango, bridge, and synthesis across fields.
    • Her mathematics and computer-science background led into cryptography and the cypherpunk idea that technology can protect freedom and privacy where law alone is incomplete.
    • Bitcoin solved decentralization through public verification, but its open ledger makes transactions viewable once an address is tied to a person or business.
    • Zcash keeps Bitcoin-like decentralization while adding a zero-knowledge proof layer that can verify valid transactions without revealing their contents.
    • Language, mathematics, cognition, and computational linguistics overlap for Amber because all of them involve abstractions central to human thinking and modern AI models.
    • Russian and French are part of her language background, and the Russia period later became a turning point in her diet history.

    Evidence, experiments, and population data

    • Protein Power gave Amber a low-carb entry point and a citation trail that led her into medical papers, experimental nutrition, and low-carb practice.
    • Randomized experiments are stronger for causality because they isolate a variable; epidemiology is useful for hypotheses and for weakening large-effect causal stories.
    • Healthy-user bias bundles official health advice, health motivation, non-smoking, exercise, and food choices, so one observed habit can carry many hidden behaviors.
    • Nutrition datasets can miss the most important contrast; fiber data in grain-eating populations cannot answer what happens with no fiber and no grains.
    • Observational populations with high carbohydrate intake and low diabetes rates weaken the simple idea that carbohydrate itself causes diabetes.
    • Carbohydrate restriction can be useful once diabetes exists without proving carbohydrate was the original cause of the disease.

    Early diet history and low carb

    • Charles Washington’s phrase "the lucky ones get fat" meant visible weight gain can push people to fix inputs that might otherwise create hidden disease later.
    • Amber grew up in a mostly vegetarian household for ethical reasons, and 1990s diet culture made vegetarian, low-fat, and vegan paths feel obvious for weight loss.
    • Meat reduction, vegan eating, more cardiovascular exercise, and fat avoidance did not fix Amber’s weight or health problems.
    • During a 1996 St. Petersburg semester, vegan food was hard to maintain, she ate meat and host food, lost weight, and learned that meat was not the bottleneck.
    • Protein Power opened the low-carb literature for her, and very-low-carb eating quickly removed the excess weight, produced ketosis on urine strips, and felt good for years.
    • Early low-carb practice involved Usenet groups, carb-count books, urine ketone strips, and later expensive blood ketone strips, long before the modern keto boom.

    Pregnancy, fat, brain growth, and tissue repair

    • Pregnancy brought carbohydrate cravings and weight gain, and the same low-carb approach did not remove the weight after pregnancy in the same way.
    • Possible contributors included long antidepressant use, age, hormones, diet trajectory, postpartum physiology, and tissue repair demands.
    • The early pregnancy period can drive maternal fat gain, while the later period transfers fat to the fetus; human babies are unusually fat and keep adding fat in the first year.
    • Human brain growth continues long after birth and weaning, with childhood and adolescent pruning phases, high energy needs, myelination, and long dependence on caregivers.
    • Human body fat and baby fat are tied in the conversation to brain energy, neuroplasticity, social dependence, parental investment, and tribe-like cooperation.
    • Postpartum tissue repair, efferocytosis, immune activity, insulin, and energy demand are part of the reason rapid return to pre-pregnancy body composition can be unrealistic.

    Zero-carb discovery, carnivore trial, and mood

    • In 2008, Amber found zero-carb forums where low-carb people with stalled weight loss often lost weight after removing plants.
    • The term zero carb was inaccurate because some animal foods contain carbohydrate and some plant foods contain none; carnivore later became her preferred term despite its own problems.
    • Her low-carb diet was vegetable-heavy, with salads and cruciferous vegetables, so a plant-free trial felt psychologically extreme.
    • She set a three-week animal-food trial for weight loss, lost about a pound every other day, felt unusually well, and stayed with the diet past the planned birthday break.
    • Her depression history began before low carb, included long Prozac use, a later bipolar type-two diagnosis, hypomanic periods, and medications that caused word retrieval problems, brain zaps, sedation, and severe anxiety.
    • On carnivore she had sustained mood remission long enough that the bipolar diagnosis no longer matched her lived condition.
    • The depression had included suicidal despair, and the diet change gave her life back in a way cognitive behavioral therapy had not achieved.
    • She stopped medication during pregnancy, later returned to carnivore soon after birth, kept nursing, and never needed to resume antidepressants, while still warning against abrupt medication withdrawal.
    • Dave’s carb-swap mood crash gave him a one-day glimpse of sudden biochemical mood collapse and changed his view of people with severe mood problems.

    Carnivore writing, naming, and community growth

    • Amber began writing on ketogenic diets and created a separate domain for carnivorous diet writing because plant-free eating sounded too radical to attach to her broader keto work.
    • In 2012 her ketogenic writing was unusually prominent online, while carnivore remained a tiny subculture with zero-carb forums and older animal-food traditions.
    • She used carnivorous or carnivore to avoid the confusion around zero carb, while still acknowledging that she did not invent the diet.
    • By 2016 she was speaking more openly, and in 2017 she gave carnivore talks at the Low Carb Cruise, KetoFest, and KetoCon after repeated vegetable-necessity questions at ketogenic events.
    • In 2018, rising interest led her to create the March 2019 Boulder carnivore conference before Low Carb Denver; the first venue sold out and the event became a marker of wider carnivore interest.
    • A larger 2020 follow-up conference was first delayed and then put off indefinitely because of COVID uncertainty and because many interested attendees had immune problems. Plants, immune burden, and anti-nutrients
    • Carnivore may help some people by removing plant anti-nutrients, lowering damage at weak intestinal barriers, and freeing immune energy for repair.
    • Autoimmune and inflammatory anecdotes included Crohn’s disease, asthma inhaler reduction, joint-pain relapse with vegetables, skin issues, and mood changes.
    • Georgia Ede’s plant-defense material made vegetables a possible problem source because plants use thorns, reproductive-part chemicals, protease inhibitors, oxalates, and other defenses.
    • Protease inhibitors can interfere with protein digestion; oxalates and other compounds may have disease mechanisms that differ person to person.
    • Plant foods bring endogenous-like substances, vitamins, and xenobiotic toxins in the same package; the body can block absorption, route compounds through the liver, or convert them for excretion.
    • Low-level plant toxins may produce hormetic antioxidant activity in some contexts, but that stress may be harmful when immune burden or cancer is already high.

    Protein, balanced diet, and animal-food fit

    • A whole-food plant-based experiment became hard to design because protein powders felt like cheating and plant amino-acid profiles require careful planning.
    • Plant and animal tissues use different amino-acid patterns, so a plant-only diet creates a cartridge-balancing problem for essential amino acids such as leucine.
    • Dave’s steak calculation found that about nine ounces of steak could cover adult essential amino-acid requirements, while plant combinations needed more complex matching.
    • The idea of a balanced diet mostly comes from plant-based eating, because plants vary widely in amino-acid and nutrient patterns.
    • Animal flesh already resembles human tissue closely enough that amino-acid and nutrient arithmetic is simpler than the plant-combination problem.

    Human evolution, carnivory, and fat dependence

    • The expensive-tissue idea links smaller human guts, larger brains, and energy-dense diets; Amber adds that animal foods helped support brain energy demands.
    • Homo erectus and later humans are placed in a long hypercarnivorous period with at least 70% animal-source intake in the conversation.
    • Humans had limited year-round carbohydrate access, limited ability to turn protein into energy, little usable fiber energy, and therefore a strong need for animal fat.
    • Human carnivory differs from cats and canids because humans cannot run on very lean meat and protein-derived glucose at the same level.
    • Scavenging marrow and brain from bones may have helped humans enter carnivory through high-fat animal resources left after large predators finished a kill.
    • The show Alone gave a practical example of people starving despite meat access because wild small game and lean big game do not supply enough fat.

    Stefansson, Andersen, and all-meat history

    • Stefansson’s Arctic experience changed his view of meat-heavy Indigenous diets because he eventually ate the same foods and felt good.
    • The Bellevue all-meat experiment with Stefansson and Karsten Andersen found no major deficiencies, but it did find negative calcium balance.
    • Andersen became sick on lean meat, and added fat corrected the problem, reinforcing the point that human carnivory needs fatty meat.
    • Older zero-carb practice carried lessons from Stefansson and from the Bear that routine liver was unnecessary or even avoidable.

    Vitamin C, RDAs, carnitine, and liver

    • Meat has small amounts of vitamin C even when databases infer zero, and fresh meat had older scurvy-cure observations before vitamin C knowledge narrowed the story.
    • The antiscorbutic vitamin C threshold is much lower than the RDA, and the RDA also includes chronic-disease and antioxidant reasoning derived from broader population contexts.
    • The pyromaniac analogy means higher need in a damaged metabolic context does not automatically apply to a metabolically healthy plant-free context.
    • Vitamin C after weightlifting may interfere with the inflammatory repair sequence that drives muscle adaptation, so more antioxidant intake is not always free benefit.
    • Vitamin C is required to rebuild collagen after dietary collagen is digested, but dietary carnitine can pass through and may spare vitamin C need on high-meat diets.
    • Early scurvy symptoms include fatigue, and carnitine synthesis matters because carnitine shuttles fat into mitochondria for oxidation.
    • A muscle-meat carnivore diet may function as vitamin-A depletion for people with chronic excess from fortification or supplementation.
    • Liver is rich in vitamin A, and regular liver intake became tied to a later nose-to-tail split in which many prominent users added fruit, honey, or plants after carnivore felt bad.

    Carnivore boundaries, coffee, and identity

    • Carnivore originally meant a practical animal-food protocol, not a literal rule that every plant-derived drug, coffee, spice, or nonfood exposure must be absent.
    • The name creates confusion because wild carnivores, cats eating macaroni, and lion-diet imagery do not define the human protocol Amber entered.
    • Coffee was often kept because it was viewed as a drug or habit outside nutrition, but a person who keeps coffee and misses the desired result may need a coffee-free trial.
    • Coffee can raise fasting triglycerides in some keto or carnivore people independent of caffeine, with decaf and regular coffee producing the same pattern in one guest-post self-test.
    • Histamine issues, shellfish allergy, lactose intolerance, fish, fermented meats, dark chocolate, coffee, spices, honey, fruit, and liver can all alter a carnivore experiment in different ways.
    • Strict carnivore can be easier than modern keto because categorical rules avoid net-carb games, keto bread, resistance starch, peanuts, and incremental portion creep.

    Salt, fluids, and electrolytes

    • Dave needs very high salt on deep keto, especially during low-calorie keto phases, and blood work once showed sodium and chloride just below range after cramps.
    • Amber almost never adds salt, and some strict carnivore people do better after dropping added salt and electrolyte balancing.
    • Plant potassium, higher fluid intake, coffee, sweetened drinks, drinking beyond thirst, and non-carnivore foods can increase sodium needs.
    • Herbivores seek salt licks while carnivores often seek the herbivores, which supports the idea that plant-heavy intake can change sodium balance.
    • Some people still need extra salt even on carnivore, and Dave’s fructose malabsorption may reduce mineral delivery or absorption.

    Restriction, adherence, reintroduction, and non-tribal diet use

    • Any diet far from one’s childhood food culture can feel restrictive when medical consequences require adherence.
    • Epilepsy and ulcerative colitis create strong adherence incentives because symptoms return quickly when the diet fails.
    • Some people can later add foods back after a recovery period; others lose benefits and need stricter rules again.
    • Carnivore can be a temporary multi-removal experiment that identifies a problem food class without becoming a permanent identity.
    • If someone has high LDL after keto or carnivore and no medical reason for the diet, adding carbohydrate back may reduce stress if carbohydrate is tolerated well.
    • A diet tool is not a gold star or tribe membership badge, and needless restriction has no value when the result is worse health or needless stress.

    Amber’s later illness and diet experiments

    • After about eight years of strong carnivore health, Amber tried high-dose vitamin D, developed rosacea-like flares, then added high-dose vitamin A for several weeks to balance fat-soluble vitamins.
    • She later had a severe sinus infection, antibiotics, campylobacter, more antibiotics, then a severe Salmonella hospitalization with pain, opioids, nightmares, and persistent gut damage.
    • Long fat malabsorption led to vitamin deficiencies, rapid weight gain, blurry vision, chronic fatigue, and a long period without full recovery.
    • The crash may involve vitamin A excess, infection, antibiotics, another exposure, malabsorption, or multiple causes; no single cause is proven.
    • Since 2021 she has tried potato experiments, vitamin-A elimination, low carb, meat-centric low carb, dry fasting, and other approaches.
    • She is not married to carnivore, but carnivore and low-plant eating still help her mood, and stricter diet still seems useful when symptoms require it.

    Lipid energy, LMHR, glucose, and ketones

    • Lean-mass hyper-responders have a defined pattern of high LDL, high HDL, low triglycerides, leanness, and low insulin markers on carbohydrate restriction.
    • Dave values the LMHR definition because clear cut points helped create a stable research target and avoid naming confusion.
    • Prospective LMHR data, five-year follow-up, coronary scans, and participant data matter more than dueling anecdotes from supporters and critics.
    • The lipid energy model links low glycogen and low adiposity to higher VLDL export, triglyceride delivery, LDL turnover, high LDL, low triglycerides, and high HDL.
    • Amber’s partition idea adds that liver fat can route toward ketones or toward triglyceride export; small differences in flux can create large blood concentration differences.
    • When ketones are low, glucose must rise to supply the brain; when ketones are high, glucose does not need to rise as much.
    • Serum ketones depend on liver production, blood concentration gradients, tissue clearance, muscle use, training status, and whether fat is traveling as ketone bodies or triglyceride-rich lipoproteins.
    • Fat adaptation can lower GLUT4 expression, slow glucose uptake, and raise fasting glucose or A1C without looking like diabetic dysregulation when CGM is flat and fasting insulin is very low.
    • Stable glucose plus low insulin shows homeostasis, but tracer studies are needed to separate glucose production from glucose residence time and uptake.

    Thyroid, supplements, and homeostasis

    • Free T3 can be lower on low-carb or carnivore diets because lower glucose use reduces the need for T3-driven glucose supply.
    • Adding T3 when glucose demand is already low may drive lean-mass catabolism because the body harvests substrate to make more glucose.
    • Methionine-glycine balance, creatine, methylation, and omega-3/omega-6 balancing were expensive dead ends for Amber, even though they may help some people.
    • The body often adapts to added or removed inputs, which Amber connects to the limits of simple chemical-imbalance stories for depression and serotonin drugs. Good-faith debate and social media
    • Bad-faith online debate often begins with personal attacks, wording traps, false summaries, goalpost movement, and time-wasting tactics.
    • Good-faith debate starts by proving that the other person has been understood, then steelmans the strongest version before disagreement.
    • Misunderstanding is especially frustrating when subtle distinctions are central to the point, because the real issue can be X versus Y, not the simplified version.
    • The Bailey trap draws a person into correcting an obviously false criticism, then shifts to a more defensible criticism while keeping the social win from the first accusation.
    • A better answer is to keep returning to the first criticism until the shift is acknowledged.
    • Long in-person conversation reduces some internet failure modes because both people commit to staying in the room, following up, and unpacking ideas directly.

    References

     

    https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38354868/

    TLDR - Meat has been unfairly blamed by bad (possibly biased) statistical analysis.

    some investigators may test many alternative analytic specifications and selectively report results for the analysis that yields the most interesting findings.

    when investigators analyze data from observational studies, there are often hundreds of equally justifiable ways of analyzing the data, each of which may produce results that vary in direction, magnitude, and statistical significance

    Evidence shows that investigators’ prior beliefs and expectations influence their results [5]. In the presence of strong opinions, investigators’ beliefs and expectations may shape the literature to the detriment of empirical evidence

    Basically given a all the possible variable permutations they took a very large sampling of inputs to outcomes and looked at the resultant hazard ratio, demonstrating that you can cherry pick to get the results you want (good or bad). This is the core weakness of observational studies.

    Curve analysis demonstrates itself as a valuable too in iterating through many of the combinations of observational data to show stronger trends.

    The left/blue side of the graph are outcomes that show meat decreased all cause mortality, the right/red side of the graph are outcomes that show meat increases all cause mortality. If you were a hungry researcher, you could publish unending papers indicating either way from this same observational data pool! - Hence the constant news cycle driven by dietary agendas - not based on hard science RCTs.

     

    A great talk between two quite intelligent professionals, just fun to have on in the background.

    summerizerCore diet shift

    • Paul Mason began in conventional sports and exercise medicine, found low-carbohydrate science after metabolic syndrome, and moved through low carbohydrate, ketogenic, Paleolithic, and mostly plant-free eating.
    • The carnivore direction came from food tolerance and nutrient confidence: animal foods supplied the essentials, while many low-carb plant staples caused gastrointestinal problems.

    Seed oils, LDL, and plant sterols

    • The seed-oil problem is not that omega-6 fats are inherently harmful; harm comes from oxidation products and plant sterols.
    • Oxidized oils can move through chylomicrons and LDL, making LDL a carrier of oxidation through the circulation.
    • Plant sterols mimic cholesterol, enter the body in small amounts, and interfere with cholesterol-dependent functions when absorbed.
    • Sitosterolemia is the extreme case: unusually high plant-sterol absorption is linked with severe premature atherosclerosis.
    • The saturated-fat LDL story fails mechanistically, and the coconut-oil trial matters because coconut oil lowered LDL despite more saturated fat than butter.

    Fiber, bowel residue, and diverticulosis

    • Fiber increases stool bulk and can speed transit, but patient-centered constipation symptoms are pain, bloating, bleeding, and actual bowel difficulty.
    • The zero-fiber constipation trial is central: low fiber improved symptoms and zero fiber eliminated them in the cohort.
    • Low-residue clinical practice fits the same pattern: after diverticulitis, bowel surgery, appendicitis, or ostomy care, less fiber rests the bowel and lowers waste.
    • Meat is highly digested and absorbed, while plant residue and fiber drive fermentation, bulk, and colostomy output.
    • The diverticulosis study connects higher fiber and more bowel motions with higher diverticulosis prevalence, not lower prevalence.

    Gut signaling and the microbiome

    • Intestinal health is tied to HDL synthesis, fructose handling, inflammatory bowel disease, incretin signaling, bile-acid signaling, and metabolic markers.
    • GLP-1 drugs imitate a pathway that a well-formulated ketogenic diet can activate through distal intestinal signaling.
    • The microbiome mainly follows diet, with rapid diet-driven shifts and overinterpretation of causal microbiome stories.
    • Trehalose is a food-additive example where a new substrate favored Clostridium difficile strains.
    • Probiotic effects depend on supplying the organism repeatedly and feeding it with the matching substrate; the synbiotic example joins a microbe with its food.

    Medical evidence, statins, and consent

    • Scientific evidence can be distorted by advisory chains, industry studies, publication pressure, and unpublished null results.
    • Clinical decisions require informed consent: the patient sees the benefit data, harm data, and uncertainty, then makes the decision.
    • The statin analysis separates first-event prevention from post-event prevention and centers triglyceride-to-HDL ratio as the marker that changes expected benefit.
    • On low-carbohydrate diets, lower triglycerides and higher HDL can make statin mortality benefit insubstantial even after a cardiac event in the cited analysis.

    Mood, inflammation, and brain fuel

    • Depression and anxiety are linked to inflammation, impaired neurotransmitter synthesis, and nutrient cofactors such as iron, B12, and zinc.
    • Antidepressants slow neurotransmitter removal, while the dietary pathway aims at production and inflammation.
    • Nutritional immunity explains why infection and inflammation lower circulating iron, raise ferritin, and create functional iron deficiency.
    • Chronic autoimmune inflammation can thereby lower mood, energy production, and reward-pathway stability.
    • Ketogenic and carnivore diets can improve mood and food control through lower inflammation, better nutrients, dopamine availability, and ketone brain fuel.
    • Dementia and brain insulin resistance are connected to low glucose uptake, while ketones can cross the blood-brain barrier and fuel brain regions with impaired glucose use.

    Carnivore troubleshooting and dairy

    • Carnivore is not ideology: animal foods can still be inflammatory for specific people.
    • Eosinophilic esophagitis is the model for elimination work because biopsies and blood markers can track food-triggered inflammation.
    • The strict elimination pattern removes likely triggers together, then reintroduces one food at a time; single-food removal can miss multi-food reactivity.
    • Dairy is the most common practical problem, especially for weak ketogenic outcomes, autoimmune disease, constipation, and cravings.
    • The Maasai/Kikuyu comparison separates meat benefits from possible dairy-linked autoimmune arthritis signals.
    • Casein-gliadin cross-reactivity and caseomorphine opioid activity are mechanisms for dairy-driven immune and motility problems.

    Athletes, cholesterol, and clotting

    • Elite athletic performance is compatible with very-low-carbohydrate and carnivore patterns.
    • LDL alone is not a sufficient risk guide; triglycerides, HDL, oxidation, B12, folate, inflammation, hemochromatosis genes, and red-cell biology add context.
    • Atherosclerosis is explained through microcoagulation: plaque resembles matured blood clots, and acute heart attacks come from sudden clot occlusion.
    • Diabetes, blood-sugar swings, oxidative stress, smoking, pollution, seed oils, and phytosterols fit the clotting and oxidation model.

    HbA1c, red cells, vitamin D, and sunlight

    • Plant sterols can enter red-cell membranes, increase fragility, shorten red-cell life, and lower HbA1c artificially.
    • Removing plant sterols can lengthen red-cell survival, lower reticulocytes, and raise HbA1c even when continuous glucose monitoring is flat.
    • Vitamin D is a marker of metabolic health and adiposity as much as a health driver.
    • Animal fat supplied vitamin D historically, and sunlight-induced vitamin D is mainly a UVB sunscreen made from skin cholesterol.
    • Higher cholesterol and lower plant-sterol interference are linked to stronger vitamin-D sunscreen capacity and less burning.
    • Sun exposure remains useful through UVA and nitric oxide pathways, but the target is sun without sunburn.
    • The Danish non-melanoma skin cancer study separates sun-linked lifestyle signals from the idea that skin cancer itself is beneficial.

    References

     

    TLDR: Keto is good for you, and not bad for you. Despite what some agenda based people say the evidence is in favor of keto as good for you, yes even you.

    As the prevalence of chronic diseases persists at epidemic proportions, health practitioners face ongoing challenges in providing effective lifestyle treatments for their patients. Even for those patients on GLP-1 agonists, nutrition counseling remains a crucial strategy for managing these conditions over the long term. This paper aims to address the concerns of patients and practitioners who are interested in a low-carbohydrate or ketogenic diet, but who have concerns about its efficacy, safety, and long-term viability. The authors of this paper are practitioners who have used this approach and researchers engaged in its study. The paper reflects our opinion and is not meant to review low-carbohydrate diets systematically. In addressing common concerns, we hope to show that this approach has been well researched and can no longer be seen as a “fad diet” with adverse health effects such as impaired renal function or increased risk of heart disease. We also address persistent questions about patient adherence, affordability, and environmental sustainability. This paper reflects our perspective as clinicians and researchers engaged in the study and application of low-carbohydrate dietary interventions. While the paper is not a systematic review, all factual claims are substantiated with citations from the peer-reviewed literature and the most rigorous and recent science. To our knowledge, this paper is the first to address potential misconceptions about low-carbohydrate and ketogenic diets comprehensively.

    Full Paper: https://doi.org/10.3390/nu17061047

    view more: ‹ prev next ›