[–] [S] 4 points 2 months ago (10 children)

To have a fair comparison, you should pit an average plant meal vs an average meat meal in the world today. Then the plant meal wins because the animal eats a lot of crops during its lifetime and gets slaughtered too in the end.

Zero carb people are not average, they only need a single cow for a family for a year. That is one life. Animals should not be eating human raised crops, that is not optimal and zero carb people try to avoid it if they can afford it.

Or you should compare the ideal case scenarios for both. The vegan version will be growing plants in sterile, isolated environments without animal deaths. And the best case for carnivores is to kill a large wild animal once a year. Plants still win.

Where do the inputs of your sterile, isolated environments come from? You can't claim sustainable solutions unless you look at the cost of the entire cycle, not one element in isolation. Those inputs are not free from death. One intentional death a year still wins.

But you have compared plant agriculture as it is today to an ideal case carnivore diet to make it look good.

You can buy whole grass fed, grass finished cows today - you can get to know your local rancher, its doable, and practical.

this argument fallacious. (imo)

Right back at you buddy.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] -1 points 2 months ago

    A central proxy adds a central point of failure.

    However, if you give each service its own DNS entry, your proxy can look at the incoming DNS of the request, and use that to proxy to the service. At least for http services

    I think it'd be much cleaner, to give each VM its own DNS entry, run the service on Port 80, or 443 so you don't have to remember port numbers.

    I'm not sure the reverse proxy is buying you much ease of use for a totally internal system. If you like, you can have a central web page, that links to all your different services from one location.

  • source
  • [–] [S] 1 point 2 months ago

    Now a portable cable throughput tester! The switch bridges the vlans just like in the bench setup above, just plug in any cable in on one side, and the other side into the portable switch. Perfect for testing long cable runs, or validating a new wall drop.

  • source
  • [–] [S] 2 points 2 months ago (1 child)

    I don't see it... do you mean this?

    The meat comes from a farm about five miles away; foods such as avocados are not being flown in from the other side of the world.

    I think that parses correctly Richard isn't flying in avocados and exotic plants to fill a deficient diet with out of season non-local foods.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 3 points 2 months ago*

    the rebuttal will be that unintended deaths don't count because the motivation is pure, and but richard has already made the counter argument that once you know about the consequences intention is no longer morally superior to effect

    i.e. drink drivers don't intend to hurt anyone, but when they do hurt people they are still responsible.

    Did you intend the deaths? -> becomes -> Did you knowingly choose an action whose consequences included predictable deaths?

  • source
  • [–] 11 points 2 months ago (2 children)

    No, it's just a reflection of how our diets have changed over time. When fatty liver disease was first being categorized. It only happened in alcoholics. So fatty liver disease meant The patient was an alcoholic. However, now with high glucose-driving diets, elevated insulin levels, the vast majority of fatty liver disease patients don't drink alcohol....

    So we have this awkward naming scheme because our diets have changed faster then our language

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  •  

    Every day, patients walk into clinics with diseases that, unbeknownst to them, stem from what’s on their dinner table. Yet most doctors are ill-equipped to counsel them, not for lack of care or effort, but for lack of training....

    Today, most medical students receive fewer than 20 hours of nutrition training over four years of school

    Recommendations to “eat less fat” or “choose whole grains” overlook metabolic realities and fail to address the underlying dysfunction driving most chronic disease.

    Ketogenic and other carbohydrate-restricted diets, in particular, have been extensively studied and shown to stabilize blood sugar, improve insulin sensitivity, and, in many cases, induce remission or major improvement in chronic metabolic diseases. Yet these dietary approaches are not taught to our future physicians.

    Future physicians must understand the latest science surrounding diet and metabolic health.

    Archive snapshot

     

    brain energy dysfunction as a potential unifying mechanism across psychiatric disorders, the preserved ketone metabolism documented in work by researchers like Stephen Cunnane, the recently published Delphi consensus paper on metabolic psychiatry, why four-week randomized trials may be inadequate for nutritional interventions, and the case for future diagnostic categories like metabolic depression and metabolic bipolar disorder.

    summerizerMetabolic psychiatry and clinical translation

    • Metabolism is already part of brain health, and the urgent question is clinical translation.
    • Bret Scher’s path moved from prevention-focused cardiology into low-carb, ketogenic, and wider metabolic health work.
    • The Baszucki Group, Metabolic Mind, and the Coalition for Metabolic Health became the setting for scale through research, education, policy, and clinical implementation.

    Why Scher left conventional prevention thinking

    • Scher did not shift because of one patient; he saw repeated cardiology patients fail lifestyle plans that were hard to sustain and poorly supported in short visits.
    • Scher came to see the prevention message itself as part of the problem, not the patients’ willpower.
    • Scher also saw a revolving-door pattern in cath labs, hospital units, and cardiac care, with too little upstream prevention.
    • Scher had to unlearn the low-fat default and the belief that one healthy diet must be low-fat, grain-centered, and fearful of dietary fat.
    • A low-carb, ketogenic, higher-fat, adequate-protein diet can be a healthy option, not an unhealthy diet by definition.

    Professional risk and skepticism

    • Guideline pressure kept low-fat advice safer professionally, while low-carb care required longer documentation and shared decision-making.
    • High LDL in low-carb patients created tension with colleagues, especially when Scher managed those cases conservatively.
    • The shift required a different mindset: guidelines matter, but individual metabolic context also matters.

    Why the Baszucki work mattered

    • The first metabolic psychiatry conference in 2022 gave Scher the clearest view of the people, research, clinical cases, lived experience, and urgency behind the field.
    • Jan, Dave, and Matt Baszucki brought urgency from family experience, while clinicians and researchers showed that lives were changing now and that research still needed to catch up.
    • The path is to let science lead while helping appropriate patients today under experienced clinical care.

    Main barrier to wider adoption

    • The largest barrier is still bias and misunderstanding around keto and ketogenic diets.
    • Many clinicians still reduce keto to a fad weight-loss diet with bacon and butter, missing its century-long use in epilepsy and its role as a physiologic metabolic intervention.
    • Medical training often teaches only ketoacidosis, not nutritional ketosis as a therapeutic condition.
    • This creates a double standard in which ketosis is asked to prove long-term safety while the modern high-carbohydrate, ultra-processed, always-fed environment is rarely challenged.
    • Better education can move clinicians from reflexive fear toward seeing ketogenic therapy as one metabolic tool.

    Ten-year success

    • Success would mean metabolic medicine becomes central enough that a dedicated advocacy group is no longer necessary.
    • Metabolic psychiatry would sit inside a wider metabolic medicine model alongside cardiometabolic disease, PCOS, diabetes, epilepsy, and cancer-related metabolic work.
    • A large collaborative model paper for metabolic psychiatry could mirror the 49-author glioblastoma ketogenic metabolic therapy model.
    • Current psychiatric care can reduce episodes for some people, but often does not restore full energy, vitality, and life function.
    • Ketogenic and metabolic therapies may add value by helping people regain function, not merely by lowering episode counts.

    Medication management and safety

    • A major mistake is starting keto, feeling better, and abruptly stopping psychiatric medications.
    • Some people have shared strong recovery stories after stopping medications, but others have ended up hospitalized with mania, psychosis, or major depression returning.
    • Medication tapering during ketogenic therapy needs research and careful prescriber management.
    • Reducing medication burden may matter because antipsychotics and related drugs can carry neurologic, psychiatric, insulin-resistance, weight-gain, and wider metabolic harms.
    • Another mistake is entering ketosis too quickly; a slower transition can reduce distress and make adherence easier.

    Brain energy and mechanisms

    • Brain energy metabolism is underestimated across psychiatry and neurology.
    • Severe depression, major depressive disorder, cognitive impairment, and dementia are linked in the conversation to lower brain glucose metabolism.
    • Ketone metabolism may remain available when glucose metabolism is impaired, which is why Stephen Cunnane’s work matters here.
    • Shifting brain energy first may also influence neurotransmitters, making metabolic care upstream of some neurotransmitter effects.

    Clinical use and first-line questions

    • Ketogenic therapy should not become a universal first-line psychiatric intervention today.
    • Individual patients may use it early when an experienced clinician, patient goals, diagnosis, medication status, safety risks, and monitoring all fit.
    • Mild depressive symptoms are one possible scenario where diet quality and a low-carb or ketogenic approach may be reviewed before medication escalation.
    • For psychiatric effects, the key markers are glucose and ketones; for overall metabolic health, triglycerides, HDL, fasting insulin, HOMA-IR, body composition, blood pressure, and hsCRP matter.
    • Physical capacity can function like a practical biomarker because better energy and ketosis may make later exercise adoption more successful.

    Responders, duration, and phenotyping

    • Future research needs to understand both responders and non-responders.
    • Possible future categories include metabolic depression, metabolic schizophrenia, metabolic bipolar disorder, and metabolic anxiety.
    • The challenge is that brain metabolic dysfunction is hard to measure clinically even when peripheral markers look normal.
    • For individuals with hard-to-shift depression or bipolar disorder, the practical clinical question can become whether there is a good reason not to try a monitored metabolic therapy.
    • The Delphi consensus placed a fair trial around at least three months, while some nutrition trials are too short at four weeks.

    Precision metabolic care

    • Precision care may include genetics, metabolomics, organic acid testing, B12, omega-3 status, thyroid status, medication effects, and other non-keto drivers of psychiatric symptoms.
    • More data can help when patients are not responding, are struggling with nutrition therapy, or want deeper personalization.
    • The balance is avoiding overwhelming data that is not actionable.
    • The message is not that everyone needs keto; the message is to widen the clinical lens around metabolic and non-metabolic causes.

    Research growth and field-building

    • The Baszucki Group does not need to control every research direction because outside researchers are already pursuing grants and new disease areas.
    • Near-term success would mean research happening broadly, with NIMH and other funding sources reducing dependence on philanthropy.
    • ClinicalTrials.gov activity across bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, depression, anorexia, PTSD, Alzheimer’s disease, and related areas is creating momentum.
    • Long-term clinical infrastructure could include metabolic psychiatry fellowships and better nutrition education in medical training.
    • The Coalition for Metabolic Health aims at the wider education and policy layer of metabolic medicine.

    References

     

    Most of what people are told about health is wrong.

    I’m a medical doctor with over a decade of clinical experience and more than 20 years immersed in research and education. I’ve worked with patients, studied the literature, and tested these principles in the real world. What I’ve found is that the biggest drivers of health aren’t found in prescriptions or procedures, but in a handful of powerful, practical changes you can make yourself.

    In this video, I break down the exact strategies I use personally and recommend to patients to dramatically improve metabolic health, reduce inflammation, and lower the risk of chronic disease. These are simple, evidence-based interventions you can start at home, often with profound results.

    summerizerMedical direction

    • Medication load is used as a simple signal: needing more medication means health is worsening, and coming off medication means health is improving.
    • The point is not the number of prescriptions by itself; the point is that more things are going wrong when more drugs are needed.
    • Food is medicine because food is body fuel, and the wrong fuel produces wrong performance: sickness and disease.
    • Harmful food components can injure the body directly, anti-nutrients can block essential building blocks, and nutrient shortage can starve the system of materials for life.
    • Correcting nutrition can improve most chronic disease, and metabolic health gives the rest of the body a better chance to recover.

    Sunlight

    • Sunlight is a nutrient, because light exposure increases brain-derived neurotrophic factor, which supports brain growth, repair, and neuron regrowth.
    • Sunlight also stimulates nitric oxide, improves cardiometabolic health, lowers blood pressure, and supports cardiovascular function.
    • Sunlight helps the body make vitamin D, which functions as a hormone with more than a thousand effects in the body.
    • Vitamin D supports development, mitochondrial function, hormonal regulation, sleep, and many other processes.
    • Optimizing light exposure helps optimize the systems tied to those effects.

    Sleep

    • Sleep is one of the best interventions for the body and brain.
    • Averaging six hours or less each night can increase Alzheimer’s risk by more than sixfold.
    • Less than five hours per night for seven nights can push the body into a pre-diabetic state.
    • One or two weekend catch-up nights are not enough; full recovery requires about seven nights of proper sleep.
    • Seven to eight hours of sleep should be protected as a core health requirement.

    Movement

    • Exercise increases BDNF and helps regulate hormones such as growth hormone and IGF-1.
    • Movement helps tissues rebuild and repair, which supports more youthful aging.
    • Exercise improves testosterone, estrogen balance, and insulin function.
    • Maintaining muscle protects against atrophy and sarcopenia, and muscle mass ties directly to longevity and cognitive function.
    • Staying active reduces the need for doctors outside accidents and emergencies.

    Health design and reversal

    • Humans are designed to be healthy and to thrive, so illness usually means something is impairing the body from the environment or from personal inputs.
    • Most members of a species should be healthy by default, with only some individuals limited by serious genetic problems.
    • Even people with serious genetic diseases can improve when they apply nutrition, sunlight, sleep, movement, and metabolic health principles.
    • Clinical experience includes conditions reversing that modern medicine calls incurable.
    • Diabetes, cardiovascular disease, heart failure, autoimmunity, cognitive issues, weight problems, body composition issues, and many other problems can improve or remit.

    Multiple sclerosis example

    • One patient with multiple sclerosis used a ketogenic carnivore diet and the same health principles for eight months.
    • She improved symptoms dramatically and shrank MRI lesions by more than 40% without medication.
    • Her neurologist had never seen or heard of that happening and could not explain it from the existing literature.
    • A case series is being prepared on ten people with multiple sclerosis who reversed symptoms, reduced lesions, or stayed stable for years without medication.
    • These outcomes keep reinforcing the old medical rules: fix nutrition, repair metabolic health, get sun, stay active, protect sleep, and let food be medicine.

    Lab ranges

    • A major change that could revolutionize medicine tomorrow is moving lab ranges from arbitrary averages to objective optimal ranges.
    • Different labs use different ranges, even in the same town, so the same B12 or thyroid value can be normal in one place and abnormal in another.
    • Doctors make objective and prescriptive decisions from lab ranges that can be arbitrary.
    • Many labs build ranges from the first few thousand people who walk in the door, not from carefully selected healthy people.
    • A normal BMI sample is not enough, because a person can have normal BMI while still having diabetes, malnutrition, or cancer.

    Animal-source nutrients and B12

    • Western diets are already hyper-vegetarian by calories, with roughly 70 to 80% of calories coming from plants.
    • A Big Mac meal can be more than 90% plant calories once buns, seed-oil sauces, fries, and sugary drink are counted.
    • Blaming meat misses that most calories in the standard Western diet come from plants.
    • B12, vitamin D, vitamin A, choline, creatine, carnitine, DHA, and EPA come solely or predominantly from animal-source foods.
    • Taking the average of a deficient hyper-vegetarian population hides deficiency inside the average.

    B12 ranges and brain health

    • B12 lab ranges are often too low because they are built from populations that are already low in B12.
    • Patients with fatigue and brain fog can be told their B12 is fine even when their level can still be low enough for neurological harm.
    • B12 below 500 pmol/L can be associated with demyelination of white-matter tracts in the brain and spinal cord.
    • An Oxford paper from 2008 found that people below those B12 brackets had brain shrinkage of about 2.5% to 5.2% every five years.
    • Japan uses B12 levels above 500 as normal, and some optimal ranges put B12 above 800 or even 800 to 1,200 pmol/L.

    Clinical workflow

    • Objective health decisions should use objective measures, not arbitrary averages from sick populations.
    • The average person is already sick, and the people sent for blood tests are often sicker than the average.
    • Functional-style optimal ranges reveal patterns that standard ranges can hide.
    • When the lab panel is read through an optimal lens, clinicians gain more direction for nutrition, lifestyle, and medication choices.
    • The fastest medical upgrade is changing lab ranges from random averages to objective optimal ranges for patients and clinicians.

    References

     

    At least once, everyone should see how their body operates with as few confounding variables as possible. Your baseline performance, feeling, mood, energy - is very valuable to know.

    Elimination Diet - Remove as many variables from your total intake as possible. Ideally choose a single bioavailable food prepared very cleanly for 30 days. 

    This is important because lots of people don't know what they have normalized as "getting older", or "I've always had that", or "I'm just inflamed". Skin conditions, hair issues, attention, clarity, are often reported to resolve on these type of protocols.

    The most famous elimination diet demonstration was with Celiac disease during WWII, wheat/bread shortages created a accidental elimination diet in Denmark and established the link between wheat protein and Celiac.

    Metabolism touches every part of the body, including the brain. Metabolism is driven by diet. Food literarily affects every part of our lives.

    I think people should be aware this is a very useful tool, and if there is some persistent or difficult to nail down issue - why not try it?

    elimination optionsOmnivore options - eggs, red meat are good options. Ground meat has higher histamine levels, so it would confound the results.

    Pescatarian - fish are ok, but they are not biocomplete, but that shouldn't be a problem for 30 days. The "sardine fast" is a type of elimination diet protocol.

    Plant Based - low fodmap diets probably eliminate the most variables, but I'm not very well read on the options

    Fasting - DO NOT DO LONG FASTS WITHOUT MEDICAL SUPERVISION. Probably the the most extreme option, total elimination, not exactly your base line, but if something was bothering you in your food you would at least notice it. REFEEDING SYNDROME is a real thing, and needs to be planned for when ending the fast.

    Regardless, be aware of confounders - cooking oils and fats can change also be triggers, so be deliberate in your choice. Spices, seasonings, rubs, "electrolyte mixes", marinades introduce more variables.

    My BiasesI run the ketogenic and zero carb carnivore (Which is just a elimination diet I decided to live with) communities, I'm all in on that metabolic lifestyle. However, elimination protocols don't have to aligned with my biases to be effective. Even doing something as simple as 30 days without processed foods can be helpful to know for someone.

    Judy Cho wrote a great eliminate diet protocol book The Carnivore Cure Which is just eating red meat for 30 days and mapping out symptoms, mood, feelings. Plus guidance on starting, and reintroducing foods to nail down triggers. But, there are many different protocols out there, you can find one that fits your requirements.

     

    The protein requirements of a human don't change based on diet. For someone following the most common omnivore eating pattern they are already eating 15% of their energy from animal sources (i.e. the meat)... Carnivore means taking the other 75% and replacing it with fat.

    Carnivore shouldn't be scary - you are already eating the meat, its just swapping the plants with natural unprocessed sources of fat.

    The total muscle meat consumed stays about the same... however, the people who try it tend to get more healthy and energetic and as they become more active their protein requirements scale up a bit... but that is a happy side effect.

    Effectively - switch to more fatty cuts of meat, more butter, cooking fats from animal fat instead of oil. And.... let's be honest, most people have a few extra kg they want to lose, so the body will naturally use that fat source too!

     

    Yes, its generative, but it illustrates the idea

    I was going to post on !fedimemes@feddit.uk but that instance has a no generative content policy.

    I think a major limiter on lemmy growth are the instances that encourage talk of violence, crime, being abusive to others, and are just generally super combative...bad neighbors - maybe not written into the instance rules, but as demonstrated by what instance admins don't enforce on their own users.

    I know a schism is scary for a small society like lemmy, but I'm starting to think its necessary

    if not a defederation, some protocol level whitelisting of users or comms that demonstrate the bare minimum of being able to play nicely with others (realizing this would take some novel work - like adding a user level whitelist to federation rather then the current banlist, and while were at it some eventual consistency in meta-state in bans)

    Basically, the toxicity needs to be partitioned off, gated, or some level of meta-moderation for instances that wont police themselves to minimum levels of behavior. It's embarrassing to share lemmy with people I know now, given how off the wall it quickly gets.

     

    TLDR: Keto avoids liver disease

    Background and Aims: - Metabolic dysfunction–associated steatotic liver disease (MASLD) and its progressive form, metabolic dysfunction–associated steatohepatitis (MASH), can lead to significant morbidity and mortality in adults with type 2 diabetes (T2D) and obesity. This study evaluated whether participation in an individualized, nutrition-focused telemedicine care model emphasizing carbohydrate reduction (Virta Individualized Nutrition Therapy, VINT) was associated with reduced onset of MASLD, MASH, and advanced liver disease.

    Approach and Results: - Adults with T2D, prediabetes, overweight,or obesity who enrolled in VINT (2015–2024) were identified in the Komodo Healthcare Map and matched 1:1 to usual care (UC) controls (n=5031 per group). Using 3 complementary analytic approaches, incidence and time-to-event analyses were performed for new-onset liver disease. Across all strategies, VINT participants consistently showed a lower incidence of any liver-related diagnosis (27.3 vs. 42.8 per 1000 person-years; HR=0.61, p<0.001), MASH-and-beyond (4.2 vs. 10.7; HR=0.38, p<0.001), advanced liver disease (2.8 vs. 8.7; HR=0.33, p<0.001), and any liver complications (2.0 vs. 7.7; HR=0.25, p<0.001). VINT participants who lost ≥15% body weight were at lower risk of new-onset liver disease (21.2 vs. 31.8 per 1000 person-years; HR=0.66, p=0.02) compared with VINT participants who lost less weight.

    Conclusions: - Participation in individualized nutrition-focused telemedicine care was associated with significantly lower incidence and risk of new-onset MASLD, MASH, and advanced liver disease. These findings support lifestyle-first interventions that are potentially scalable to reduce liver disease burden in adults with T2D and obesity.

    Full Paper - https://doi.org/10.1097/HEP.0000000000001713

     

    Fatty liver disease (MASLD) is a major cause of liver disease and even liver failure. But many are surprised to learn it’s not primarily a liver problem. Growing evidence suggests the root issue may be metabolic dysfunction affecting the entire body, and that perspective can drastically change how we approach treating and preventing it.

    In this interview, Dr. Bret Scher sits down with Dr. Adam Wolfberg to discuss a newly published study in Hepatology examining how a ketogenic intervention may help prevent metabolic liver disease before it progresses.

    summerizer

    Metabolic dysfunction as one body-wide process

    • MAFLD/MASLD is common, preventable liver disease linked to metabolic dysfunction rather than alcohol or infection.
    • Metabolic dysfunction affects the brain, liver, blood sugar, heart, kidneys, and the body as an interconnected system.
    • Medicine is often too siloed, while liver disease, type 2 diabetes, obesity, cardiovascular disease, kidney disease, and behavioral conditions belong in the same metabolic map.

    Terminology and scale

    • NAFLD was the older term for fatty liver not caused by alcohol, and MASLD/MAFLD is the metabolic-dysfunction version.
    • MASH is the more advanced inflammatory form, previously NASH, and it raises risk for cirrhosis and related hazards.
    • The prevalence figures are 25% at the opening, then 25% to 34% for NAFLD/MASLD, around 80 to 90 million Americans, with NASH at 15 to 20 million.

    Why Virta studied liver outcomes

    • Virta began with a type 2 diabetes nutritional program built around low-carbohydrate/keto eating, coaching, clinician oversight, digital tools, and content.
    • The earlier diabetes trial found disease reversal in a significant majority and later showed better liver tests without a liver-focused program.
    • The original prospective work showed ALT down 3% and AST down 21%, so liver outcomes became a natural next question.

    Hepatology/Komodo study design

    • The new Hepatology paper used Komodo payer-record data and compared just over 5,000 Virta patients with an identically sized matched usual-care group.
    • Matching used age, diagnoses, geography, and medications, while patient identities stayed hidden from the researchers.
    • The study was not randomized; the major limitation was that the usual-care group was out in the wild, with unknown diet, exercise, or health behavior.
    • The selection-bias issue matters, and the intervention still represents the kind of health behavior clinicians want patients to choose.

    Main liver outcomes

    • Any liver-related diagnosis was lower with Virta: about 27 versus almost 43 per 1,000 person-years.
    • MASH-and-beyond or more advanced liver disease was also lower: 4.2 versus about 10 per 1,000 person-years.
    • The NNT was 65 people per year to prevent any liver-related diagnosis, which was low for prevention.
    • This was a prevention result, because the cohort was not mainly a liver-disease care cohort.

    Cost and payer incentives

    • The cost analysis was not at hand, but the Virta-side total cost of care was said to fall dramatically relative to matched controls, including the price of Virta.
    • The American payment structure makes prevention hard because employers and health plans may hold financial responsibility for only two or three years.
    • Virta therefore has to show economic value within one or two years, not only long-term health value.

    What drove the benefit

    • The study does not isolate coaching, keto, weight loss, cleaner eating, or the whole Virta system as the exact driver.
    • More weight loss lined up with greater liver benefit.
    • Beta-hydroxybutyrate levels did not separate higher-benefit from lower-benefit groups, so deeper nutritional ketosis was not required for the liver signal.
    • For brain-focused metabolic work, higher ketones matter more; for general metabolic health, liver prevention, weight loss, and type 2 diabetes, lower ketone levels can still be enough.

    Mediterranean diet comparison

    • Search results and clinical guidance often point people toward the Mediterranean diet for fatty liver or MASLD.
    • The Mediterranean-diet literature was mixed, with some studies showing reduced liver-disease risk and others not showing it.
    • One cited Mediterranean-diet study was criticized as clinic-based adherence measurement with healthy-user and selection bias.
    • The keto/Virta prevention study warrants comparable attention when Mediterranean observational work is used as diet evidence.

    Clinician takeaway

    • The expensive medication pathway now includes Wegovy/semaglutide for obesity plus liver disease at approximately F2/F3 disease.
    • The goal is to keep patients from reaching that stage by using accessible low-carbohydrate nutrition earlier.
    • A well-formulated ketogenic diet is low carb, not zero carb, and people can move into it gradually.
    • Doctors do not need to personally deliver every diet detail, because content, coaching programs, and employer or health-plan access can carry much of that burden.

    Closing synthesis

    • The notable result was the NNT of 65 to prevent one serious liver complication.
    • The health signal matters more than the cost signal because liver disease is serious yet preventable.
    • The study grew from type 2 diabetes care, liver-test improvements, and then a larger prevention question.
    • Metabolic health touches the brain and body together, so improving it can affect many organ systems at once.

    References

     

    TLDR: People with a higher healthy eating score (plant based) had higher rates of cancer. Authors flabbergasted and are looking for confounders other then the diet (pesticides) because it can't be the diet.

    Following peak tobacco incidence in the mid-1980’s there has been a large reduction in lung cancer incidence among men that has not been seen among women. Lung cancer at a young age is now more common among women than men, reversing a decades long pattern. We sought to characterize environmental exposures among young lung cancer patients to understand potential drivers of this change in the epidemiologic profile of young lung cancer patients. We analyzed 187 patients (157 females, 84%) from the Epidemiology of Young Lung Cancer (YLC) study (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT04640259) using mutation-based grouping by shared biological mechanisms: EGFR Pathway (EGFR+ERBB2), Fusion Positive (ALK+ROS1+RET+NTRK), and Other/Mixed Mutations (including MET exon 14 skipping, TP53, KRAS, BRAF, and additional alterations). Of these, 166 patients (138 females, 83.1%) completed validated food frequency questionnaires. Dietary quality was assessed using the Healthy Eating Index-2015 (HEI-2015) and compared to U.S. reference values from NHANES. Dietary categories with elevated contaminant residue potential were identified using published literature. Statistical comparisons employed one-sample t-tests against reference means and chi-square tests for categorical variables. The EGFR groups and ALK groups had tobacco use history in 32.8% and 13.4% of patients respectively. All groups had similarly high levels of oral contraceptive exposure among women (75-100%). Dietary analysis revealed that EGFR Pathway, Fusion Positive, and Other/Mixed Mutations patients demonstrated HEI-2015 scores (out of 100) of 64.9 ± 10.7, 65.5 ± 9.8, and 63.5 ± 9.5 respectively, compared with the US reference of 58. YLC women demonstrated higher dietary quality scores than men (65.6 ± 9.7 vs. 61.8 ± 11.3), both exceeded U.S. reference values of 60 for females and 56 for males. These YLC patients also consumed more foods from dietary categories associated with elevated contaminant exposure potential, as reflected by higher HEI-2015 component scores (out of 5) for total vegetables (4.2 vs. 3.5), fruits (3.3 vs. 2.5), and whole grains (3.9 vs. 2.6). YLC patients have a diet pattern of higher diet quality, with higher exposure to whole fruits, vegetables and whole grains. While these food groups are presumed to have good health benefits, there is an emerging, under-appreciated literature that produce based whole foods often contain high pesticide/herbicide contaminants. Further investigation of the role of pesticide contaminated fruits/vegetables/whole grains is timely to assess its role, if any, in the changing lung cancer prevalence over the last 4 decades

    This has yet to be peer reviewed and published, but it is already in the news cycle, so here we are.

    Abstract: https://www.abstractsonline.com/pp8/#!/21436/presentation/1647

     

    That puts us at 0.006% of the global population. How did I arrive at 500k? I kinda made it up based on carnivore study populations, but its super duper tiny. I looked everywhere, I can't really find a solid estimate. But we are totally in the dozens of us category.

    I NEVER meet another zero carb carnivore anywhere organically. Plus there is huge stigma for being a carnivore. EVERYONE thinks I'm crazy.

    • Omnivore - 73% - 6,000M
    • Flexitarian - 14% - 1,100M
    • Vegetarian - 5% - 400M
    • Pescatarian - 3% - 250M
    • Vegan - 3% - 250M
    • Zero Carb Carnivore - 0.006% - 0.5M

    Using ipsos (broad strokes good enough) for the other eating pattern data

    It's fine to be a minority group. Live and let live.

    There are some people who simply cannot suffer us in our little corner of the internet at all. My poor little community script runs every day and bans many accounts for just downvoting all the posts in the community. https://discuss.online/modlog/696952

    I've dug into the many of the non-obvious-sockpuppet accounts, and it seems most of the hate directed at us comes from our nearest neighbor at 3% total population. A group 500x more popular.

    I really wish we could just be friends, let's agree that whole foods, totally unprocessed is good, and leave each other alone as allies in improving everyone's health. I'd like that. This childish animosity doesn't help anyone.

    Perhaps this is just the cost of being a small fringe eating pattern, easy target for other less small groups to hate.

    Eyeballing daily active users on the fediverse it looks like we have about 7,000 unique users every day. There are about 3 carnivores - which puts us at 0.04% of the lemmy population.

     

    TLDR: Seed oils (vegetable oils) ARE NOT food. They are a modern invention of the industrial petrochemical complex (1915), humans are not suited to long term consumption of these food substitutes.

    Conclusion - The consumption of the omega-6 polyunsaturated fat linoleic acid has dramatically increased in the western world primarily in the form of vegetable oils. OxLDL is thought to play an important role in atherosclerosis formation; however, it is the oxidised linoleic acid contained in LDL that leads to harmful OXLAMs, which induces atherosclerosis and CHD. Thus, reducing the amount of dietary linoleic acid, mainly from industrial vegetable/seed oils, will reduce the amount of linoleic acid in LDL and likely reduce oxLDL as well as the risk for CHDcoronary heart disease.

    In summary, numerous lines of evidence show that the omega-6 polyunsaturated fat linoleic acid promotes oxidative stress, oxidised LDL, chronic low-grade inflammation and atherosclerosis, and is likely a major dietary culprit for causing CHD, especially when consumed in the form of industrial seed oils commonly referred to as ‘vegetable oils’.

    Full Opinion https://doi.org/10.1136/openhrt-2018-000898

     

    Objective: To examine the relation between the consumption or avoidance of meat and psychological health and well-being.

    Methods: A systematic search of online databases (PubMed, PsycINFO, CINAHL Plus, Medline, and Cochrane Library) was conducted for primary research examining psychological health in meat-consumers and meat-abstainers. Inclusion criteria were the provision of a clear distinction between meat-consumers and meat-abstainers, and data on factors related to psychological health. Studies examining meat consumption as a continuous or multi-level variable were excluded. Summary data were compiled, and qualitative analyses of methodologic rigor were conducted. The main outcome was the disparity in the prevalence of depression, anxiety, and related conditions in meat-consumers versus meat-abstainers. Secondary outcomes included mood and self-harm behaviors.

    Results: Eighteen studies met the inclusion/exclusion criteria; representing 160,257 participants (85,843 females and 73,232 males) with 149,559 meat-consumers and 8584 meat-abstainers (11 to 96 years) from multiple geographic regions. Analysis of methodologic rigor revealed that the studies ranged from low to severe risk of bias with high to very low confidence in results. Eleven of the 18 studies demonstrated that meat-abstention was associated with poorer psychological health, four studies were equivocal, and three showed that meat-abstainers had better outcomes. The most rigorous studies demonstrated that the prevalence or risk of depression and/or anxiety were significantly greater in participants who avoided meat consumption.

    Conclusion: Studies examining the relation between the consumption or avoidance of meat and psychological health varied substantially in methodologic rigor, validity of interpretation, and confidence in results. The majority of studies, and especially the higher quality studies, showed that those who avoided meat consumption had significantly higher rates or risk of depression, anxiety, and/or self-harm behaviors. There was mixed evidence for temporal relations, but study designs and a lack of rigor precluded inferences of causal relations. Our study does not support meat avoidance as a strategy to benefit psychological health.

    Full Paper - https://doi.org/10.1080/10408398.2020.1741505

    view more: ‹ prev next ›