[–] [S] 2 points 3 weeks ago*

It's really making the distinction between whole food carnivore vs processed carnivore... both are fine, but i do see processed carnivore as less effective then whole foods.

  • source
  • [–] [S] 0 points 3 weeks ago (12 children)

    ruminants eat grass, which humans cannot eat, and turn it into protein, which humans can eat... grass grows on land that humans can't use to grow crops... and even crops humans do grow cannot be fully eaten by humans, something like 70% of the biomass from cropland is not consumable by humans.... which we turn into human food by feeding to to animals that can eat it.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 1 point 3 weeks ago

    I don't see why we can't be friends, we align on so many things - whole foods, avoid industrial foods, avoid land exploitation, sustainable agriculture, improving people's health.....

  • source
  • [–] 5 points 3 weeks ago* (last edited 3 weeks ago) (1 child)

    don't do this - how to gain fat as fast as possible

    Only eat processed food, so for potatoes -- instant potatoes, or really blend the potatoes before you eat them in a smoothie... buy the most processed and fake bread possible (wonder bread if you got it)... processed carbs hit your blood stream faster spiking your glucose more, which drives your insulin, which will suppress your leptin and drive hunger.

    Only use seed oils - they drive inflammation and adiposity, so you want to be dosing seed oils every few hours

    Eat constantly - every 2-4 hours you want to keep your insulin high, so eat a snack (combining processed potatoes and bread and seed oil) every few hours, it doesn't have to be a big meal... but you want to graze all day

    Mix fats and carbs - this will cause the randel cycle (not a cycle) to misfire and drive inflammation, and adiposity. Every time you eat make sure your getting enough seed oil to stall the carbs your eating from the bread/potatoes

    You will be forcing your serum insulin high all day (it takes 2-4 hours to come down after a meal), so your body will be in fat storage mode (not burning) all day.


    Seriously though, there have been some great papers on the the metal disorder of anorexia and metabolic psychiatry - if you fix your metabolism, your body will recompose, and you may address your borderline anorexia...

    Symptom Impact and Safety of Ketogenic Therapy in Adults with Anorexia Nervosa

    Basically it's the Dr Ede strategy - eat your eggs and cheese, whole foods only, avoid carbs when you can...

    change your diet - change your mind

  • source
  • [–] [S] 3 points 3 weeks ago (1 child)

    not ketones, RQ is computed co2/o2 yeah ; the lipid energy model and dave propose that the body is getting good at using lipids directly and preserves ketones, the same argument made for glucose sparing in fat adapted people.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 3 weeks ago* (last edited 3 weeks ago)

    Your body knows.

    That is a great test to see if your actually hungry or just bored/addicted to sugar... If you think your hungry eat some butter, if your not hungry enough to eat butter, then your not actually hungry and its some other craving.

    There are also many cheese addicts out there, just chowing down on blocks of cheese, yet they don't need supplements.... weird right?

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 3 weeks ago* (last edited 3 weeks ago) (2 children)

    for the barrage of fat you can’t process

    Humans run on fat, you will notice humans store excess energy as fat... famously the gallbladder caches biles to process fats quickly in the stomach. We are lipovores - we absolutely can eat fat in our diet without supplements.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 3 weeks ago (4 children)

    passing untouched (fiber), and helps you not get diarrhea and constipation every week.

    fiber bulks up stools, it is linked to constipation - removing fibre resolves constipation in a RCT.

    There’s a reason that articles by dentists literally advocating for the carnivore diet, have 5-lines-long lists of symptoms, and recommend supplements both before meals, and “for bowel movements”.

    Westin Price would disagree with you, there is no need for supplements , and quite frankly if someone is selling fibre supplements and advocating for a zero carb diet they need to go back to biochemistry for their inherit contradiction.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 3 weeks ago

    none of that changes the money spent is not thrown away in my kitchen.

    fundamental inefficiency of animal nutrition is curious - most of the land in the world is not arable, yet can support animals, that land does not produce human nutrition no matter how much industrial fossil fuel fertilizer you throw at it. Ruminants eat grass growing on land not fit for farming and convert it into human usable protein. Go ahead and grow crops on arable land, use the non-arable land for animals.... oh, but even the crops grown on arable land are mostly not consumable by humans, we can't ferment cellulose after all, so what do we do with this "waste", we either throw it away... or feed it to something that can process cellulose (a animal).

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  •  

    The Sanskrit phrase "jīvo jīvasya jīvanam" (जीवो जीवस्य जीवनम्)1 can be translated as “one living being is the sustenance of another.” While the dating is uncertain (Sanskrit traditions were transmitted orally long before their final written compilation 1,000 years ago), the idea itself — that living beings subsist upon other living beings — is deeply embedded throughout ancient Indian thought. A suitable interpretive translation is “life eats life.”

     

    What if most of our modern diseases are really just symptoms of the same problem? The Magic Pill follows doctors, patients, scientists, chefs, farmers and journalists from around the globe who are combating illness through a paradigm shift in eating. And this simple change - embracing fat as our main fuel - is showing profound promise in improving the health of people, animals and the planet.

    generated summary

    Core dietary model

    • Human weight regulation and chronic health worsen when ancestral whole foods are displaced by industrial carbohydrates, grains, sugar, refined oils, and food-like products.
    • Standard low-fat guidance removed traditional animal fats and increased dependence on starches, grains, and industrial seed oils.
    • Real food consists of meat, seafood, eggs, vegetables, fruit, nuts, seeds, and natural fats such as olive oil, coconut oil, ghee, lard, tallow, and avocado.
    • The body can use glucose or ketone bodies for energy, and carbohydrate restriction shifts metabolism toward fat and ketones.
    • Repeated high-carbohydrate intake produces repeated insulin secretion, hyperinsulinemia, insulin resistance, weight gain, type 2 diabetes, vascular disease, and related chronic illness.

    Yolngu health transition

    • Yolngu communities moved from robust health and little chronic disease to widespread diabetes, heart disease, hypertension, kidney disease, liver disease, and asthma after traditional foods were displaced by flour, sugar, soft drinks, and other imported foods.[1]
    • The Hope for Health retreat restored meat, vegetables, whole foods, movement, and traditional knowledge while removing sugar, flour, refined grains, and processed products.
    • Within days, participants had lower blood glucose and blood pressure, greater mobility and wellbeing, and less asthma burden; Yuranydjil felt flexible, refreshed, and free of asthma symptoms.

    Household dietary intervention

    • Debbie began with obesity, headaches, depression, cognitive difficulty, thyroid medication, cholesterol medication, pain drugs, and fear of following her mother into dementia.
    • After the family adopted whole foods and higher natural fat, Debbie lost her headaches, gained energy and mental clarity, and felt engaged with life again.
    • Michelle began with obesity, asthma requiring daily inhalers, recurrent respiratory infections, thyroid disease, fibroids, anxiety, ADD, and numerous medications.
    • After five months, Michelle had clearer skin, voice, and thinking, no respiratory infections or antibiotics, and no inhaler use for roughly three months.
    • Abigail began as a nonverbal autistic child with epilepsy, central sleep apnea, constipation, digestive problems, about 50 seizures daily, and dependence on processed snack foods.
    • After five weeks without grains and processed foods, Abigail was calmer, less bloated, off daily laxatives, having fewer seizures, beginning anticonvulsant withdrawal, using a fork, saying "no," and following simple requests.
    • Aaron entered a ketogenic-autism clinical trial after years on the Specific Carbohydrate Diet; after three months his ADOS score fell from 16 to 8, with greater social interaction, independence, self-care, and less repetitive movement.[2]

    Diabetes, insulin, and cancer

    • Pati began with type 2 diabetes, peripheral neuropathy, gastroparesis, early kidney disease, coronary disease, a 99% carotid blockage, and 50 units of long-acting insulin nightly.
    • After roughly six weeks to two months, Pati had lost 17 pounds, stopped short-acting insulin, and reduced long-acting insulin from 50 to 20 units; she later lost 45 pounds and stopped insulin completely.
    • Cancer cells share a strong dependence on glucose fermentation, so lowering glucose and insulin can attack a common metabolic vulnerability while ketogenic diets can support conventional cancer care.
    • Sara used a very-low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet after an invasive HER2-amplified breast-cancer diagnosis, declined surgery, chemotherapy, and radiation, and said serial MRI scans showed tumor shrinkage and later no visible lesion.
    • Eugene Fine's pilot work used carbohydrate restriction to reduce insulin in ten people with advanced cancer and evaluated safety, feasibility, and metabolic response.[7]

    Diet-heart history and institutional resistance

    • Ancel Keys linked saturated fat and cholesterol to heart disease, influenced the American Heart Association's 1961 advice, and used the Seven Countries Study of nearly 13,000 men to support the diet-heart hypothesis.[3]
    • Large controlled feeding experiments in Finnish mental hospitals and a Los Angeles veterans hospital replaced saturated fats with unsaturated oils but did not establish the broad mortality benefit promised by the diet-heart model.[4][5]
    • The Women's Health Initiative assigned about 48,000 postmenopausal women to a low-fat pattern or usual diet for about eight years; the intervention did not significantly reduce coronary heart disease, stroke, or cardiovascular disease.[6]
    • Americans reduced animal fats, red meat, eggs, and whole milk while increasing grains, vegetable oils, fruit, and vegetables, yet obesity and metabolic disease continued to rise.
    • Timothy Noakes defended low-carbohydrate, high-fat advice before South Africa's professional regulator and was found not guilty of unprofessional conduct.
    • Food, pharmaceutical, weight-loss, commodity-crop, and professional institutions benefit from carbohydrate-centered guidance and can shape funding, conferences, public messaging, and accepted practice.
    • A randomized metabolic-syndrome trial associated with Stephen Phinney found greater reductions in body mass, abdominal fat, triglycerides, and blood saturated fatty acids, plus higher HDL, on a carbohydrate-restricted ketogenic diet than on a low-fat diet.[8]

    Food systems and land

    • Industrial grain production removes perennial ecosystems, depends on fertilizer and pesticides, erodes soil, damages waterways, and supplies feedlots that fatten cattle on an unnatural diet.
    • Managed grazing copies herd movement, gives pasture time to recover, builds soil, hydrates landscapes, converts grass into nutrient-dense food, and stores carbon.
    • Ethical food production cannot remove animal life and death from soil fertility; gardens, cropland, pest control, and fertilizers also depend on animals and ecological killing.
    • Local whole-food systems, grass-fed livestock, whole-animal purchasing, and regenerative farming reconnect human nutrition with functioning ecosystems.

    Final principle

    • The human body is complex, but fueling it with species-appropriate whole food is simple: remove industrial food, reduce carbohydrate exposure, restore natural fats, and allow metabolism to regulate itself.

    References

    1. [11:39] Nutrition and Health (1948) of Aborigines in Settlements in Arnhem Land, Northern Australia — https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1440-6047.2000.00199.x
    2. [30:56] A Modified Ketogenic Gluten-Free Diet with MCT Improves Behavior in Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder — https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physbeh.2018.02.006
    3. [38:57] Seven Countries: A Multivariate Analysis of Death and Coronary Heart Disease — https://doi.org/10.4159/harvard.9780674497887
    4. [40:16] Dietary Prevention of Coronary Heart Disease: The Finnish Mental Hospital Study — https://doi.org/10.1093/ije/8.2.99
    5. [40:16] A Controlled Clinical Trial of a Diet High in Unsaturated Fat in Preventing Complications of Atherosclerosis — https://doi.org/10.1161/01.CIR.40.1S2.II-1
    6. [42:54] Low-Fat Dietary Pattern and Risk of Cardiovascular Disease: The Women's Health Initiative Randomized Controlled Dietary Modification Trial — https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.295.6.655
    7. [52:36] Targeting Insulin Inhibition as a Metabolic Therapy in Advanced Cancer: A Pilot Safety and Feasibility Dietary Trial in 10 Patients — https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nut.2012.05.001
    8. [63:11] Carbohydrate Restriction Has a More Favorable Impact on the Metabolic Syndrome than a Low Fat Diet — https://doi.org/10.1007/s11745-008-3274-2

    GPT-5.6 Thinking - high effort - July 12, 2026 - July 12, 2026

     

    Zoë has a PhD in public health nutrition. She struggles to find anything that is being taught in 'conventional' nutritional worlds that is true or evidence based. Hence why she spent 2008-10 writing The Obesity Epidemic - 135,000 words blowing apart: the misapplication of thermodynamics to dieting; the notion that 1lb = 3,500 calories, let alone that a deficit of 3,500 calories will lead to a weight loss of 1lb; the Seven Countries Study and the subsequent change in our diet advice, which has caused the obesity epidemic; the role of exercise in obesity and much more.

    generated summary

    Definitions and question

    • Veganism excludes meat, fish, eggs, and dairy, leaving grains, legumes, nuts, seeds, vegetables, fruits, and plant oils.[1]
    • Plant-based language is softer than vegan language, while some research definitions include people who occasionally eat meat or fish within vegetarian categories.[2][3][4]
    • About 20 years as a vegetarian, including a vegan period, ended with rejection of the nutritional, animal, and planetary cases for veganism.

    Nutrition and evidence

    • Randomized trials, systematic reviews, and meta-analyses are at the top of the evidence hierarchy.[5][6]
    • A PubMed search for vegan-diet meta-analyses produced 28 results, with three remaining after removal of mismatched designs, diets, and surrogate-marker analyses.[7]
    • The mental-health meta-analysis linked vegetarian or vegan diets with higher depression risk and lower anxiety scores, which is not an endorsement of the diets.[8]
    • The bone meta-analysis found lower femoral-neck and lumbar-spine bone mineral density in vegetarians and vegans, with higher fracture rates in vegans.[9]
    • The type 2 diabetes meta-analysis found better glycemic control with low-carbohydrate, low-glycemic-index, Mediterranean, and high-protein diets, not vegetarian, vegan, or high-fiber diets.[10]
    • The Ornish trial combined a low-fat vegetarian diet with smoking cessation, stress management, aerobic exercise, and psychosocial support, so its coronary improvement cannot be assigned to the diet.[11]
    • The Game Changers erection experiment used three men over two nights, comparing a meat burrito with a plant burrito.[12]
    • The Daily Dozen calculation supplied about 1,364 calories, nearly 70% carbohydrate, 16% fat, and 17% protein, with multiple vitamins, minerals, and animal-form nutrients absent or below the selected targets.[14]
    • A healthy diet supplies essential nutrients without supplementation; a vegan diet requires supplementation and is therefore not healthy.[13][14]

    Animals and food production

    • Cattle, pigs, sheep, hens, and domestic cats would not exist in a vegan food system because livestock and carnivorous pets depend on animal agriculture.
    • The Vegetarian Myth links crop production to unavoidable animal deaths: even protecting a lettuce requires excluding or killing slugs.[15]
    • One cow was calculated to provide more than 600,000 calories and feed one person for a year, while the same calories would require about 228 chickens.[16][17][18]
    • Fischer and Lamey's field-death paper is used with an estimate of seven billion animal deaths annually on harvested U.S. cropland, alongside about 40 million cattle and nine billion chickens killed for food.[19]
    • Confining chickens and cattle in sheds or concrete systems is wrong, and removing grazing ruminants is also wrong because they belong on grassland.

    Soil and climate

    • Grazing ruminants host microflora, return material to the land, and rejuvenate topsoil; soil-free greenhouse production removes that relationship and requires added carbon dioxide.[20]
    • Rotational systems such as Polyface Farm alternate animals, crops, and rest, while plant-only cultivation continually takes from soil without returning animal fertility.
    • Local food comes from the surrounding land and water: cattle, sheep, dairy, fish, eggs, and seasonal vegetables, not distant imported produce.
    • Humans also generate methane, including methane measured in flatus, so methane production is not unique to cattle.[21]
    • Atmospheric methane is about 1.8 parts per million; the calculations reduce agriculture's share to about 0.44 and enteric fermentation to about 0.3 parts per million.[22][23][24]

    Institutions and conclusion

    • The EAT-Lancet diet permits zero animal food while allocating roughly 110 to 120 calories to table sugar.[25]
    • FReSH includes agribusiness, chemical, technology, consultancy, processed-food, retail, pharmaceutical, insect-production, and other large corporate interests.[26]
    • Veganism is rejected because removing livestock threatens topsoil and local food production, then transfers control of food to corporations whose incentive is commercial, not health.

    References

    1. [01:24] Food Groups — https://www.zoeharcombe.com/2015/05/food-groups/
    2. [02:49] Plant based diet propaganda — https://www.zoeharcombe.com/2019/08/plant-based-diet-propaganda/
    3. [02:49] Plant based diet propaganda – Part 2 — https://www.zoeharcombe.com/2019/09/plant-based-diet-propaganda-part-2/
    4. [03:20] Vegetarian diets: what do we know of their effects on common chronic diseases? — https://doi.org/10.3945/ajcn.2009.26736K
    5. [05:50] The Levels of Evidence and Their Role in Evidence-Based Medicine — https://doi.org/10.1097/PRS.0b013e318219c171
    6. [06:09] Primary, Secondary, and Meta-Analysis of Research — https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X005010003
    7. [06:53] PubMed search: vegan diet, meta-analysis filter — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=vegan+diet&filter=pubt.meta-analysis&size=50
    8. [07:31] Vegetarianism and veganism compared with mental health and cognitive outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis — https://doi.org/10.1093/nutrit/nuaa030
    9. [07:58] Veganism, vegetarianism, bone mineral density, and fracture risk: a systematic review and meta-analysis — https://doi.org/10.1093/nutrit/nuy045
    10. [08:33] Systematic review and meta-analysis of different dietary approaches to the management of type 2 diabetes — https://doi.org/10.3945/ajcn.112.042457
    11. [09:45] Intensive Lifestyle Changes for Reversal of Coronary Heart Disease — https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.280.23.2001
    12. [10:53] The Game Changers — https://www.netflix.com/title/81157840
    13. [11:59] National Food Strategy – call for evidence — https://www.zoeharcombe.com/2019/10/national-food-strategy-call-for-evidence/
    14. [13:17] Food to help you live longer — https://www.zoeharcombe.com/2018/01/food-to-help-you-live-longer/
    15. [17:29] The Vegetarian Myth – Lierre Keith — https://www.zoeharcombe.com/2011/08/the-vegetarian-myth-lierre-keith/
    16. [19:12] How Many Pounds of Meat Can We Expect From a Beef Animal? — https://beef.unl.edu/beefwatch/2020/how-many-pounds-meat-can-we-expect-beef-animal
    17. [19:18] Beef nutrition data used for the calorie calculation — https://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/beef-products/3669/2
    18. [19:42] Raw Whole Chicken nutrition data — https://www.nutritionix.com/food/raw-whole-chicken
    19. [20:05] Field Deaths in Plant Agriculture — https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-018-9733-8
    20. [22:49] Thanet Earth — https://www.thanetearth.com/
    21. [25:34] Investigation of normal flatus production in healthy volunteers — https://doi.org/10.1136/gut.32.6.665
    22. [26:50] Climate Change Indicators: Atmospheric Concentrations of Greenhouse Gases — https://www.epa.gov/climate-indicators/climate-change-indicators-atmospheric-concentrations-greenhouse-gases
    23. [26:55] Methane Tracker 2020 — https://www.iea.org/reports/methane-tracker-2020
    24. [27:03] FAOSTAT Emissions Totals — https://www.fao.org/faostat/en/#data/GT/visualize
    25. [28:42] Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT-Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems — https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(18)31788-4
    26. [29:01] Food Reform for Sustainability and Health — https://eatforum.org/initiatives/fresh/

    GPT-5.6 Thinking - high - 2026-07-12 - 2026-07-12

     

    Dr. Jessica Turton is the Director of Ellipse Health and holds a PhD in nutrition awarded by the Faculty of Medicine and Health at the University of Sydney. Her thesis investigated the use and efficacy of low-carbohydrate diets for diabetes management, with a specific focus on type 1 diabetes. Dr. Turton conducted a clinical trial in collaboration with the CSIRO using a fully online delivery model which enabled Australia-wide participation. The aim of the study was to assess the safety and effect(s) of a nutritionally adequate low-carbohydrate diet on type 1 diabetes management outcomes.

    Jessica has also co-authored several research articles in leading scientific journals, including "An Evidence-based Approach to Developing Low-carbohydrate Diets in Type 2 Diabetes: A Systematic Review" in Diabetes, Obesity and Metabolism. Jessica was invited to speak at the American Diabetes Associated Conference in June 2020 to present the evidence for low-carbohydrate diets and nutritional ketosis in the treatment of diabetes and obesity.

    Jessica has a passion for working with individuals to identify the primary nutritional problems affecting their health and preventing them from reaching their goals. She was the recipient of the Charles Perkins Centre Summer Research Scholarship in 2016/17 where she was part of a team that conducted analyses to investigate the association of industry-funding and results in published studies examining the effect of whole-grain intake for cardiovascular disease prevention.

    generated summary

    Calories and metabolic adaptation

    • Food supplies energy and nutrients; calories support movement, digestion, and vital organ function.
    • "Eat less and move more" can produce initial weight loss, but continued progress can demand progressively lower intake.
    • Most daily energy expenditure comes from basal or resting metabolism rather than deliberate exercise.
    • Excessive calorie restriction activates homeostatic energy conservation and can reduce energy, health, and metabolic rate.

    Semi-starvation and extreme weight loss

    • The Minnesota experiment placed 36 healthy men on about 1,570 kcal/day for six months, producing about 25% weight loss. [1]
    • The men lost strength, stamina, libido, and concentration and developed depression, anxiety, food obsession, and disordered eating. [1]
    • Rehabilitation included three months of increasing calories and two months of unrestricted eating; some men ate up to 10,000 kcal/day with distressing symptoms. [1]
    • Resting metabolic rate fell during semi-starvation and remained suppressed after calories and body weight returned toward baseline. [1]
    • Biggest Loser contestants fell from about 148.9 kg to 90.6 kg, then returned to 131.5 kg six years later. [2]
    • Their average resting metabolic rate fell from about 2,600 to 1,996 kcal/day and remained about 1,903 kcal/day six years later despite weight regain. [2]
    • Persistent metabolic adaptation makes long-term weight loss a continuing struggle against reduced energy expenditure. [2]

    Three foundations for eating more

    • Higher protein intake can raise resting energy expenditure by about 200 kcal/day, increase diet-induced thermogenesis two- to threefold, and support muscle mass.
    • Greater muscle mass supports insulin sensitivity, lower circulating insulin, and greater fat oxidation.
    • In a randomized trial of 162 adults, isocaloric diets supplied 60%, 40%, or 20% of energy from carbohydrate while protein stayed constant. [3]
    • The 20%-carbohydrate diet increased total energy expenditure by 209 kcal/day compared with the 60%-carbohydrate diet. [3]
    • Real, nutrient-dense foods supply micronutrients such as B vitamins, iron, and magnesium that support energy metabolism.
    • A systematic search of the Australian Food Composition Database identified top low-carbohydrate food sources for essential micronutrients and produced food lists and a sample meal plan. [4]

    Clinical program outcomes

    • Ellipse Health instructed patients to eat listed foods to satiety, meet minimum protein and fat targets, prioritize real foods, and use individualized nutrition support.
    • Ten completers, averaging 62 years of age and 61 weeks of follow-up, increased mean intake from 1,411 to 2,190 kcal/day.
    • Mean body weight fell from 108 to 98 kg, while high energy levels rose from 0% to 50% and no participant had low energy at follow-up.
    • Two participants had not yet lost weight; one had consumed about 800 kcal/day for more than 50 years and required a longer restoration period.
    • Weight loss became a side effect of nourishment, while gains in energy, physiological function, cognition, and mental health became the larger benefits.

    Who may benefit

    • The approach targets people with long histories of low-calorie dieting, low energy, disordered eating, mental-health concerns, or worsening health despite dieting.
    • A low-carbohydrate or real-food diet can still be inadequate when total food intake is too low.

    References

    1. [04:33] They Starved So That Others Be Better Fed: Remembering Ancel Keys and the Minnesota Experiment — https://doi.org/10.1093/jn/135.6.1347
    2. [08:14] Persistent metabolic adaptation 6 years after "The Biggest Loser" competition — https://doi.org/10.1002/oby.21538
    3. [11:52] Effects of a low carbohydrate diet on energy expenditure during weight loss maintenance: randomized trial — https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.k4583
    4. [13:44] Formulating Nutritionally Adequate Low-Carbohydrate Diets: An Analysis of the Australian Food Composition Database — https://doi.org/10.26717/BJSTR.2022.44.006991

    GPT-5.6 Thinking - high - 2026-07-12 - 2026-07-12

     

    All General Practitioners should know the real fundamentals of nutrition to combat obesity - and the known risks of GLP-1s.

    summerizerPurpose and thesis

    • Metabolic dysfunction and obesity are modifiable upstream drivers of chronic disease, and dietary therapy is the first-line response.
    • Calorie-restricted low-fat advice is predictably ineffective, and willpower is not an adequate explanation for obesity.

    Insulin and carbohydrate model

    • Insulin is the dominant hormonal driver of fat storage because it promotes substrate entry into adipocytes and suppresses stored-fat release.
    • Lipohypertrophy, weight gain after insulin initiation, insulin omission for weight control, and an eight-year youth cohort show the fat-storing effect of high insulin.
    • High-carbohydrate diets raise glucose and insulin, enable de novo lipogenesis after glycogen capacity is filled, activate lipoprotein lipase and GLUT4, and inhibit hormone-sensitive lipase.
    • A controlled feeding trial found roughly 300 kcal per day higher energy expenditure on the low-carbohydrate diet during weight-loss maintenance.

    Low-carbohydrate evidence and common objections

    • Seventy-one randomized low-carbohydrate versus low-fat weight-loss trials ran from 2003 to 2023, with all 39 statistically significant results favoring low carbohydrate.
    • Twenty meta-analyses and umbrella reviews are further evidence that carbohydrate restriction outperforms low-fat diets for weight loss.
    • A dietary requirement for 130 g of carbohydrate is unnecessary because ketones can fuel the brain and Cahill's fasted subjects tolerated profound insulin-induced hypoglycemia without symptoms.
    • Nutritional ketosis differs from diabetic ketoacidosis, and SGLT2-associated euglycemic acidosis involves insulin deficiency and renal acid handling, not ketones alone.
    • Routine protein restriction is unnecessary for healthy kidneys; MDRD follow-up and meta-analyses found no renal harm from higher protein intake in people without proteinuria.

    Saturated fat and LDL

    • A simple saturated-fat-to-LDL rule is invalid because a butter, olive-oil, and coconut-oil trial did not produce the predicted LDL response.
    • LDL participates in innate immunity, and hypothyroidism, vitamin B12 deficiency, and folate deficiency can elevate LDL independently of dietary saturated fat.
    • The corn-oil trial, Sydney Diet Heart Study, Minnesota Coronary Experiment, and Women's Health Initiative failed to show cardiovascular benefit from reducing saturated fat and produced adverse signals.
    • Delayed publication, incomplete publication, and selective placement of statistically significant results distorted the saturated-fat evidence base.
    • Reviews of the evidence available before the 1977 guidelines and later meta-analyses provide no mortality justification for reducing saturated fat.

    Semaglutide and GLP-1 drugs

    • STEP 1 produced an average 16.86 kg loss over 68 weeks in more than 1,300 participants, but DXA data from 95 participants attributed 39% of total loss to lean tissue.
    • Trial participants received exercise counseling, yet the pivotal publications did not quantify resistance training well enough to determine its protective effect.
    • SELECT regulatory data showed about a fivefold hip-fracture signal in females, and a 52-week Danish trial found lower spine and hip bone density, thinner tibial cortical bone, and rising bone resorption.
    • Recent epidemiology linked GLP-1 receptor agonists with an 11% higher fragility-fracture risk in older adults, while AAOS data linked use with higher five-year osteoporosis and osteomalacia risk.
    • STEP 1 follow-up participants regained about two-thirds of lost weight within 12 months after withdrawal, while STEP 2 supplied no body-composition data on regained weight.
    • Blundell's mechanistic trial found semaglutide reduced unrestricted energy intake by roughly one-quarter to one-third without improving food composition.
    • The gaunt facial change called "Ozempic face" is chiefly lean-tissue loss and malnutrition produced by appetite suppression.

    Nutrient adequacy and tissue preservation

    • A 1975 intravenous overfeeding study found that withholding nitrogen, phosphate, potassium, or sodium blocked muscle or bone formation and diverted most or all gained weight into fat.
    • Bone is mineralized protein, so calcium alone is inadequate; an older-adult calcium and vitamin D trial linked the highest protein intake with increased bone mineral density.
    • A 2015 phosphate trial reduced weight and waist circumference, while magnesium and potassium experiments linked mineral repletion with improved glucose regulation.
    • Plant antinutrients and conversion limits reduce usable phosphorus, iron, zinc, retinol, EPA, and DHA despite their nominal presence in foods.
    • Animal foods supply highly bioavailable micronutrients and higher-scoring protein, making protein quality important during drug-induced appetite suppression.

    Clinical conclusion

    • A low-carbohydrate, nutrient-dense, mostly animal-based diet with adequate protein is the preferred route to lower insulin, preserve lean tissue, and stimulate natural satiety.
    • Resistance training and sufficient protein can mitigate muscle and bone loss, but adopting them may also remove the need for indefinite injectable therapy.
    • Semaglutide can produce substantial weight loss, but patients should receive full informed consent about lean-tissue loss, skeletal risks, nutritional shortfalls, indefinite use, and weight regain after withdrawal.

    References

     

    “The salt of the earth.” “Worth one’s salt.” “Salt away” savings. These age-old expressions illustrate the value humans have placed on salt for eons.

    More recently, however, salt has gone from something treasured to something feared. Health authorities have been encouraging us for decades to cut back on this once-prized substance, especially for lowering blood pressure and decreasing heart disease risk.

    But are low-sodium diets necessary — or even safe — for everyone? Read on to learn more about salt and how much of it we should be eating, based on the best current evidence.

     

    Want to start cooking? Just start. Where should you start? With THIS. Let's talk about the perfect cooking vessel, egg grades & anatomy, chat about steam and a quick rant about MSG

    summerizerEgg structure and cooking goal

    • A chicken egg is a self-contained cooking vessel suited to simple, precise hard cooking.
    • The calcium-carbonate shell, cuticle, and two membranes protect the albumen from contamination.
    • Fresh eggs peel poorly; aging releases carbon dioxide, raises albumen pH, and weakens membrane adhesion.
    • Albumen proteins form the white gel, while the yolk supplies fat, protein, nutrients, and lecithin.

    Choosing eggs

    • Grade A large eggs are sufficient; a large carton averages 24 ounces, or about 57 grams per egg.
    • The carton's Julian packing date identifies eggs aged 20–25 days for easier peeling.
    • Side storage for 24 hours before cooking keeps the yolks near the center.
    • Washed U.S. eggs require refrigeration because commercial washing removes the protective cuticle.

    Steam-cooking, chilling, and peeling

    • A folding steamer sits in a large pot above roughly half an inch of rapidly boiling water.
    • Refrigerator-cold eggs enter the hot steamer and cook under a lid for 13 minutes.
    • Condensing steam transfers latent heat quickly, sets the outer white, and reduces membrane adhesion.
    • The eggs chill for about 13 minutes in 3 quarts of cold water, 2 pounds of ice, and pumped circulation.
    • One test egg reached about 180–181°F after cooking and 42°F after roughly 12 minutes of chilling.
    • Cracking and peeling occur in the cold bath, beginning opposite the air cell with water under the membrane.
    • Peeled eggs keep for about seven days in an airtight box between moist paper towels.

    Pepper deviled eggs

    • The eggs are halved, the yolks removed, the intact whites arranged, and the yolks mashed until lump-free.
    • The filling uses green-peppercorn brine, chopped green peppercorns, Dijon mustard, and white pepper.
    • Soft butter and mild olive oil produce the creamy emulsion; mayonnaise and strongly flavored oil stay out.
    • The cool filling is piped into the whites and finished with pink peppercorns, black pepper, and salt.

    MSG and umami

    • Robert Ho Man Kwok's 1968 letter linked a post-meal symptom cluster with several possible causes.
    • The "Chinese Restaurant Syndrome" heading spread through the press and helped drive "no MSG" signs.
    • A later Australian double-blind study found no rigorous evidence linking the syndrome to MSG.
    • MSG is generally recognized as safe by the FDA for its specified food uses.
    • Protein-bound glutamate has little direct taste, while free glutamate activates savory umami receptors.
    • Kikunae Ikeda isolated glutamic acid from kombu and named its savory taste umami.
    • Modern MSG production ferments carbohydrates with organisms such as Corynebacterium glutamicum.

    Egg salad

    • Damaged but edible peeled eggs become egg salad rather than waste.
    • The yolks are mashed with mayonnaise, Dijon, salt, onion powder, white pepper, and MSG.
    • The whites are coarsely chopped, folded into the yolks, and chilled for 30–60 minutes.
    • Japanese-style milk bread provides the final sandwich format.

    References

    Carnist is a slur (hackertalks.com)
     

    Carnist / Carnism is a slur, it is a question begging phrase that presupposes vegan ethical claims and projects a psychological motivation for non-vegan behavior in the word itself.

    by definition (per joy) carnism is a psychological model that pre-supposes that animal foods are optional, and ethical deficiency is being demonstrated. the entire point of the model - language framing - is to push a vegan philosophy. If someone who eats no meat is a carnist because they use leather or own a pet - the better term is non-vegan rather then making up a marketing word to emotionally trigger people. Carnist is a term that projects a assumed thought process onto someone rather then describing behavior. Carnist is an de facto slur used to label ideologically inconvenient people and stigmatize or shame them. By design it is highly polemical

    non-vegan/omnivore/carnivore (for the 4 of us here) are better terms when having discussions that are not ment to be insulting.

     

    What really happens behind the doors of a modern hospital ICU? In this thought-provoking interview, an intensive care nurse with more than 25 years of frontline experience shares a perspective rarely heard outside the hospital walls. Drawing on decades of caring for critically ill patients, she discusses the realities of intensive care and how corporate financial interests can influence the care of you and your loved ones.

    Whether you agree with her perspective or not, this conversation offers a rare glimpse into the world of critical care and raises important questions about patient advocacy, informed decision-making, and what every family should understand before a medical emergency occurs.

    summerizerScope and purpose

    • Jennifer has worked as a nurse for nearly 25 years and in lung transplantation for a little over five years at an unnamed major U.S. academic center.
    • Lung transplantation can restore quality of life, and candidates and families need a realistic understanding of complications and decision-making before surgery.

    Potential post-transplant course

    • Younger recipients sometimes recover, leave rehabilitation, and return to work; many patients in Jennifer's unit have prolonged ICU courses.
    • In Jennifer's unit experience, prompt extubation is less common than progression to tracheostomy, tube feeding, decompensation, delirium, restraints, and antipsychotic medication.
    • Bleeding can leave the chest open for drainage, followed by washout and closure, deep sedation, bronchoscopy, invasive lines, dialysis, and ECMO.
    • Lifelong anti-rejection medication carries major side effects, and some recipients move from lung failure to permanent kidney failure requiring dialysis.
    • Confusion, sedation, or unconsciousness can remove the patient's decision-making capacity and leave the family to make high-stakes choices.

    Outcome metrics and local experience

    • The one-year survival statistic counts survival through day 365, including patients on a ventilator, ECMO, dialysis, or without communication.
    • A transplant can meet this survival endpoint without discharge, wakefulness, independence from devices, family communication, or acceptable quality of life.
    • Across Jennifer's five years in transplant, fewer than 10 patients went home completely back to normal life; the total number under her care is unknown.
    • Jennifer's 10-bed unit can keep transplant recipients for more than a year, and patients transferred out commonly return with respiratory failure.
    • Lung-transplant outcomes are worse than outcomes for some other transplanted organs; Jennifer's direct knowledge is limited to her own center.
    • Jennifer's department stopped lung transplants for about six months; no public information was found about the pause, and later procedural changes did not clearly improve outcomes.

    Donor and procedural uncertainty

    • Donor lungs can come from deaths involving suicide, hanging, fire, or infection; clinically relevant infection such as hepatitis C is disclosed, while the wider donor story may not be.
    • A call announcing available lungs does not guarantee viability, fit, or use of both lungs; the final decision can occur in the operating room. Consent, ethics, and incentives
    • Long consent forms may list risks, but families often expect dialysis, delirium, ventilation, or ECMO to be temporary when these can become the new reality.
    • Families can also feel obligated to continue care because the lungs came from a donor and could have gone to another recipient.
    • Transplant admissions and each added procedure generate substantial revenue, while hospitals and physicians receive payment through surgical volume and procedures.
    • Survival data should include discharge home, device dependence, cognition, communication, readmission, and quality of life, not merely a pulse at one year.

    Patient preparation

    • Candidates should seek former recipients, families, ICU nurses, and physicians who can explain the center's actual experience beyond online success figures.
    • Direct questions should cover how many recipients are home, bleeding rates, failure to leave the ventilator by day 60, dialysis, ECMO, tracheostomy, readmission, and clinician payment.
    • Families should decide before surgery how long to continue dialysis, ventilation, or ECMO, who will act as surrogate, and what outcome would justify stopping care.
    • The decision is individual: lung transplantation can improve life, but significant complications are more likely than not in Jennifer's experience.
    • The purpose is patient autonomy through specific outcome data, advance planning, and informed family decisions, without discouraging transplantation.

    References

     

    can a practicing family physician's personal health crisis reshape the dietary advice he gives to thousands of patients? Ken Berry (MD) makes the case for low-carbohydrate approaches in managing metabolic conditions, shares his path from rural Tennessee to family medicine, discusses founding the American Diabetes Society as an alternative institution, explores the debate around long-term ketosis and fasting insulin, and joins Dave and audience members in examining how to rebuild trust in medical and scientific institutions.

    summerizerDiabetes, weight, and the medical training gap

    • Berry began as a board-certified family physician with nearly 23 years in practice, and his path into medicine ran through rural X-ray work, emergency rooms, and a childhood ideal of the local doctor who solved practical problems.
    • Berry's own health broke the script he had learned: he reached 297 pounds, had an A1C of 6.1, achy knees, reflux, rosacea, joint pain, and a nurse who told him, "Doc, you're getting fat."
    • Medical school gave Berry very little useful nutrition education, and the nutrition teaching he remembered centered on hospital feeding and advice such as whole-wheat pasta for type 1 diabetes.

    The personal diet experiment that changed the clinic

    • Berry took the diabetes handout home, followed the usual low-fat, whole-grain, fruit-and-vegetable advice, added jogging for three months, gained two or three pounds, and watched his A1C rise.
    • That failure forced a new question: his patients may have been doing what he told them, and the advice itself may have been the weak link.
    • The first books that shifted Berry's thinking were The Paleo Diet, Dr. Atkins' Diet Revolution, and The Primal Blueprint; dropping carbohydrates and eating more meat quickly gave him better weight and A1C results.
    • Keto then produced stronger results: normalized A1C, major weight loss, and relief from reflux, rosacea, knee pain, shoulder pain, thumb pain, blood pressure problems, and inflammatory symptoms.

    Patient signal and the move from clinic to public teaching

    • Patients kept bringing back the same signal: keto and then carnivore helped weight, diabetes markers, joint pain, PCOS patterns, reflux, and other problems that Berry had not expected diet to affect.
    • A man over 600 pounds with bone-on-bone knees came in on two canes, improved to one cane and then no cane, and canceled knee surgery.
    • Those results moved the diet from a short-term weight-loss hack to a proper human diet spectrum, running from carnivore and zero-carb through therapeutic keto, keto, and low-carb under 100 grams per day.
    • YouTube grew out of the same clinic logic: if Berry could help 35 people in a day, the internet could help 35,000.

    Books, institutions, and diabetes advice

    • Lies My Doctor Told Me grew from a running list of medical teachings that did not fit human biology, patient experience, or later evidence.
    • The breast-milk vitamin D chapter came from the clash between routine infant vitamin D drops and research showing that higher maternal vitamin D3 intake could make breast milk adequate.
    • The American Diabetes Society was built as a low-carbohydrate, diabetes-reversal counterweight to the American Diabetes Association, with a desired head-to-head plate-method trial.
    • The critique of the ADA plate centers on giving people with diabetes a meal structure that still reserves a quarter of the plate for carbohydrate foods.

    Low-carb physiology, testing, and measurement

    • Long-term keto and carnivore can bring higher fasting glucose or A1C without the same meaning as ordinary diabetes, especially when CGM curves are flat and fructosamine or glycated-albumin markers are normal.
    • Low insulin on a carbohydrate-restricted diet is not automatically insulin shutdown; it can be the amount needed for homeostasis in a body using fat and ketones.
    • CGMs can expose hidden carbohydrate leaks, including restaurant omelets with pancake batter and packaged keto breads that behave like ordinary starch.
    • Urine ketone strips are weak long-term tools; blood ketones are better, yet adapted people may show low blood ketones while still running largely on fat.
    • Respiratory exchange or RQ would better show whether lean mass hyper-responders are burning fat, because blood and urine ketones are only transit markers.

    Cholesterol, cardiology, and medical culture

    • The Lipid Energy Model matters because lean, low-carb people can have high LDL-C with high HDL-C and low triglycerides, a pattern that many cardiologists still answer with statins.
    • Semmelweis is the cautionary example: a clear clinical signal can be rejected by doctors for decades when it threatens the professional story.
    • Trust in older institutions is badly damaged; new groups such as the American Diabetes Society, the Society of Metabolic Health Practitioners, and Metabolic Mind are built to carry the work forward.
    • Better trials, better publications, and wider public reach are needed because low-carb studies often get distorted by definitions that still allow high carbohydrate intake.

    Practical risks, medication changes, and challenge cases

    • Low-carb diabetes reversal can require fast medication changes: insulin and sulfonylureas can drive hypoglycemia, while blood-pressure drugs can become excessive as pressure falls.
    • Metformin is less likely to cause low blood sugar by itself, psychiatric drugs and benzodiazepines require slow tapering, and statins do not need physiologic tapering.
    • Glucose challenge tests can misread a fat-adapted person; a keto-adapted athlete or lean person may fail an oral glucose test without matching the ordinary diabetes picture.
    • Occasional travel carbohydrates are a dose-and-context problem; CGM, food order, walking after meals, and vitamin C or E were raised as ways to blunt spikes.
    • For resistant family members, a fixed 30-day trial with baseline and follow-up labs can be easier than demanding a permanent diet identity change.

    Closing themes

    • Diabetes reversal is a food-first problem, with animal protein, animal fat, carbohydrate restriction, CGMs, and deprescribing support as the practical core.
    • The central lesson is that doctors should follow strong patient signals, not outdated nutrition handouts, and should be willing to rebuild institutions when existing ones fail patients.

    References

     

    Vegetable oils are routinely recommended as “heart healthy.” There is high-quality evidence demonstrating that replacing saturated fat with vegetable oils reduces LDL cholesterol levels. But at this point, there is inconsistent evidence whether this translates into fewer heart events or lower rates of cardiovascular mortality.

    Because of inconsistent evidence of health benefits, potential negative health effects, concerns about the ultra-processed and unstable nature of many of these oils and due to evolutionary considerations, we believe that the conventional recommendations about vegetable oils deserve a more detailed analysis.

     

    This guide is a reference for health care professionals and those interested specifically in the detailed evidence base for low-carb and ketogenic diets. While most of the guides on this site delve deeply into one individual topic, this page focuses more on communicating the breadth, types, and findings of studies that have examined the effects of low-carb nutrition on all aspects of health.

    view more: ‹ prev next ›