i enjoyed it at a 9/10 level.
I can see how you're thinking on the lack of brevity but i disagree. With the depth of history and emotion it's trying to convey it could easily have had even more time.
i enjoyed it at a 9/10 level.
I can see how you're thinking on the lack of brevity but i disagree. With the depth of history and emotion it's trying to convey it could easily have had even more time.
I was a big fan, Jax's story and their very non-traditional trans story pulled it together for me.
Tap for spoiler
I think of it as 7/10. The pacing of the episode was alright and did not make me impatient to get to the end; in fact, I'd argue it should've been longer to elaborate on Caine's perspective in the second half of the story. I believe the ending could've been better but it's still a good compromise the way it finished on a positive note.
My biggest concern is how the revival of Caine made the impact of his death in the last episode meaningless.
As a tragedy enjoyer, I loved that the circus and abstractions weren't solved, just coped with and the characters grew from them.
It was alright. Not bad, not great. But your post reads as unusually condescending in a way that prevents open discussion, so I'll have to downvote
This is a really mean thing to say out of the blue. You've assumed malintent when there wasn't any. I just wanted to give a measured spoiler-free review.
Why did you say something? Like, what was your objective by leaving this comment alongside the downvote instead of just downvoting? I want to understand your perspective but I'm a bit wounded since I've been so misinterpreted
It was fine. I cried a bit. I'm used to finales being a full letdown, so this was actually a pleasant surprise.
spoiler
I wish that there had been more elaboration on the blue AI, its nature, and the impact their merger had on Caine.
I called the "they're 'just' scans and can't leave" realization from the first episode, but also harbored the incorrect theory that Pomni was somehow a manifestation of the blue AI, so you win some, lose some.
I really disliked it because Jax is insufferable and the episode being fully focused on him only made him more so. The reduced pomni to coddling an abuser while giving him a lackluster backstory. Everybody else got sidelined and the lore just got practically ignored. Huge disappointment to me.
I don't think the lore dump was necessarily bad. But I think that stories should try to not meander.
TADC finale spoilers ahead
The way I see Jax, you can really do only a few things in the finale as it is currently structured:
Mostly the same, but she de-abstracts/is on the path to doing so after spending half the runtime on emotionally saving her.
Have the major flashback, then abstract her, putting her in the current "nigh unsaveable state"
In the former case, Jax (alongside Caine), would have to actively earn back the group's trust, because you're right, she's been quite hurtful. But in essence, beyond the moral implications, the narrative structure itself leaves something to be desired in this regard.
She wasnβt βcoddling an abuser.β Jax was complicated. He was scared and lashed out all the time. That makes him an asshole, sure, but there is a reason his abstraction was a tragedy.
all 13 comments