Low Carb Denver 2023, Health & Nutrition Conference. Watch this entire presentation as Dr. Shawn Baker discusses: Demystifying the Carnivore Diet.

summerizerOpening and scope

  • The talk covers the future of food, with the main task being demystifying carnivore diet mythology.
  • The speaker discloses his role at Revero Health, his carnivore book, and his long-running meat-heavy diet.
  • The audience poll matters because many people increased meat, improved health, cut ultra-processed junk, and some cut fruits and vegetables.

Carnivore weight loss and calories

  • Carnivore does not make unlimited food intake automatically produce weight loss.
  • Calories still matter inside a carnivore context: five ribeyes per day builds a different body size than two.
  • Food type still changes the result through protein intake, macronutrient mix, microbiome effects, absorption, and satiety.
  • Powdered and ultra-processed foods may be absorbed differently because surface area and microbial access change.
  • A donut calorie and a steak calorie are not equivalent in practical effects, but more food still tends to mean more weight once food type is fixed.

Vegetables and gut tolerance

  • The speaker does not eat vegetables and has not eaten them since 2016, but that does not mean all vegetables are poison for everyone.
  • Some people improve only after removing vegetables, even from a ketogenic diet.
  • Billions of people eat vegetables and do reasonably well, so the stronger universal anti-vegetable line does not hold.
  • Modern diet damage may leave some guts so compromised that even fruit such as strawberries can create problems.

Organs, grass-finished meat, and organic meat

  • Organ meats, grass-finished meat, and organic meat are not required for success on carnivore.
  • The speaker's 12,000-person dataset and the Harvard carnivore survey did not show better outcomes from organs, organic meat, or grass-fed meat.
  • The measured outcomes included nutritional deficiencies, health outcomes, and medication discontinuation.
  • Some people may feel better with liver or grass-finished beef, but affordability and adherence matter more than purity rules.

Symptom changes seen in practice

  • Weight loss is common, and metabolic syndrome, diabetes, and hypertension often improve.
  • Inflammatory bowel disease, Crohn's disease, ulcerative colitis, IBS, psoriasis, and rheumatoid arthritis are major areas of observed improvement.
  • Rheumatoid arthritis improvement is striking because some people regain hand function after early deformity.
  • Mental health changes include depression, anxiety, bipolar disorder, PTSD, and even Tourette syndrome improvements.

Red-meat evidence fight

  • The standard message says red meat causes colorectal cancer and heart disease, and that message has been repeated for generations.
  • The nutrition literature is hard to interpret because human diets contain many variables and high-control human feeding experiments are limited.
  • Gordon Guyatt's evidence-based medicine background matters because he was senior author on the 2019 NutriRECS red-meat guideline.
  • NutriRECS said adults could continue current intake of unprocessed and processed red meat because evidence for cutting back was weak and uncertain.
  • Activist pressure followed, including PCRM pressure on the FTC and pressure aimed at Annals of Internal Medicine.
  • WHO/IARC put red meat in Group 2 for colorectal cancer in 2015, and the speaker objects to the undisclosed dietary and ethical commitments on that panel.
  • The absolute-risk issue matters: a 17% relative risk was cast as roughly a 1% absolute increase while obesity and chronic inflammation were left in the background.

Carnivore literature and case literature

  • The Harvard carnivore survey included 2,029 adults, with durations from 6 months to 28 years, and many participants were healthy or improved.
  • Among type 2 diabetics using insulin in that survey, 92% got off insulin, while survivorship bias and non-interventional design remain limits.
  • A zero-carbohydrate carnivore SIBO case series had six patients and all improved.
  • Case literature also included hidradenitis suppurativa, cervical disease, glioblastoma, rectal cancer, epilepsy, and Crohn's disease.
  • A zero-carb survey from Frédéric Leroy and colleagues also had positive results.
  • Future carnivore interventional trials were being developed for rheumatoid arthritis, ulcerative colitis, and psoriasis.

Cholesterol and cardiovascular risk

  • Cholesterol can rise on carnivore, can stay stable, and does not have one universal meaning.
  • The key heart-attack question remains uncertain and depends on the rest of the risk picture.
  • The CAC/LDL study separated people with zero and nonzero coronary artery calcium scores.
  • With CAC at zero, LDL did not change progression in that study; with nonzero CAC, LDL had an effect.
  • Diabetes, smoking, and low HDL still mattered even with CAC at zero.
  • Metabolic syndrome, inflammation, chronic stress, sedentary behavior, poor gut health, and poor sleep all belong in the cardiovascular-risk picture.
  • High cholesterol should not be ignored; better information, metabolic repair, imaging, and diet adjustments are part of the response.

Fiber

  • Fiber advice usually targets 25 to 30 grams per day and promises satiety, weight loss, lower cholesterol, glycemic benefits, and microbiome benefits.
  • The fiber weight-loss meta-analysis found only about 0.33 kg independent weight loss and no real body-fat change.
  • The fiber cholesterol meta-analysis gave about 0.13 mmol/L, or roughly 5 mg/dL, which is small in this talk.
  • People with gut disease or autoimmune disease sometimes improve after excluding fiber.
  • Fiber studies often compare against a standard American diet, so fiber may be a marker of overall diet quality.
  • A high-fiber diet synergized with Prevotella copri and worsened rheumatoid arthritis in the cited paper.

Future protein and livestock

  • Pat Brown of Impossible Foods wanted cows, chickens, pigs, sheep, and animal agriculture gone by 2035.
  • The speaker rejects soy-protein and pea-protein ultra-processed meat products as the future of food.
  • Cultured meat depends on protein inputs, glucose inputs, clean rooms, transfers between bioreactors, contamination control, and heating and cooling.
  • Cell cultures lack the immune system of a cow, so contamination risk pushes the system toward chemical and antibiotic inputs.
  • Cows produce food without ultra-processing, run on sunlight, self-replicate, and upcycle grass and forage that humans cannot eat.
  • Cows turn 0.6 grams of human-usable protein into 1 gram of high-quality protein, mostly use rainwater, and contribute a small share of U.S. greenhouse gases.

References

no comments (yet)

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
there doesn't seem to be anything here