I enjoyed the first season, though it did stumble in a number of places. I gave up on the show in the second season. F

Enjoyed season 1. Kind of feels like they didn’t expect to get more than one season and have lost the plot. I will likely finish it off, but it is very much going down the Lost route.

I gave up in season 1. I'm not a big fan of non-linear story telling. Same reason I could never get into Lost. I enjoyed the parts around the plane crash and survival stuff, but the present day parts felt like a slog. I gave up on the episode where they went looking for a guy and found him dead. That whole part just drug on and on for like half the episode's runtime, and I knew he was going to be dead in like the first 5 minutes. I didn't hate it, just didn't feel like it was worth my time. I might give it another chance one day.

Chaotic misty just cracks me up in either timeline! I enjoyed the whole show but prefer the survival aspects. I'm very skeptical of the supernatural elements though I think it focused more on other areas and did a good job of not making that the only story. It has supernatural undertones but the other wild human behavior was the draw for me.

I don't know what's scarier: misty, or a bunch of lost people on mushrooms!

I agree the adult timeline got better near the end. Shaunas husband ended up a surprise too...I didn't like her story at first but that family plot grew on me by s3

I only enjoyed season 1, don't plan on watching the final season