can a diet of almost exclusively meat actually support world-record athletic performance while raising serious questions about conventional cardiovascular risk? Shawn Baker (MD) traces his path from professional rugby and military trauma surgery to pioneering the carnivore movement, makes the case for carnivore as a powerful elimination diet for autoimmune and inflammatory disease, and engages Dave in a nuanced debate on LDL, plaque imaging data, gut microbiome myths, and the politics of nutrition research.
summerizer
Background and health path
- Shawn Baker came from orthopedic surgery, military trauma work, rugby, powerlifting, Highland Games, and rowing, so nutrition connects to performance, recovery, and capacity.
- Low-fat calorie restriction made him lighter but hungry, irritable, and hard to live with; paleo was easier, and low carb/keto improved appetite control.
- Shawn Baker moved from paleo and keto toward carnivore after seeing long-term zero-carb people avoid the expected scurvy, fiber, and deficiency problems, then testing it in 2016.
- He never liked vegetables, and carnivore became the first version of low-carb eating where he felt good without forcing unwanted foods.
Carnivore as an elimination tool
- Carnivore works as radical simplification: remove plants, processed foods, seed oils, starches, sugars, and most variables, then track what improves.
- The strongest pattern is not just weight loss or diabetes control; the surprising pattern is mental health, autoimmune disease, gut disease, skin disease, and inflammatory symptoms improving after keto with plants was not enough.
- Rivero/MeetRx grew from collected stories into a clinician-and-coach network focused on cardiometabolic, inflammatory, autoimmune, neurologic, and gut conditions.
- The practical sequence is strict removal first, then broadening later when possible; carnivore is a tool, not a purity system or religion.
Keto, glucose, and lab interpretation
- Keto and carnivore can create lab patterns that look strange under standard high-carbohydrate assumptions.
- A keto-adapted person can have low insulin, stable CGM readings, and a higher fasting glucose or A1C without the same meaning as progressive diabetes.
- Oral glucose tolerance tests can mislead in low-carb adaptation unless carbohydrate intake is raised for several days before the test.
- Testosterone numbers, glucose numbers, cholesterol numbers, and single lab snapshots all need context from symptoms, physiology, performance, and longitudinal change.
Performance, aging, and capacity
- Carnivore did not make Shawn Baker an athlete from nowhere; years of training did that, and carnivore did not hold him back.
- He broke multiple Concept2 sprint and masters records while eating carnivore, and older carnivore athletes also show that age-class performance can remain high.
- Aging should be judged partly by retained capacity to sprint, run, jump, lift, and do hard work, not only by disease names or paper markers.
- Diet opens the door by reducing pain, inflammation, fatigue, and metabolic drag; the patient still has to train, move, and change behavior.
Cholesterol, imaging, and LDL uncertainty
- High LDL should not be ignored, but the first question is what the diet is doing for the whole person: disease remission, blood pressure, inflammation, triglycerides, HDL, glucose, insulin, and imaging.
- CAC and CCTA can add useful context, especially when a metabolically healthy low-carb person has very high LDL but no plaque signal.
- The KETO-CTA data matter because they test a population that conventional LDL logic expects to show clear plaque burden or progression.
- The Cleerly reanalysis problem shows why blinding, reproducibility, and independent imaging review matter.
- Baseline plaque predicts future plaque more strongly than LDL in this exchange, and the unresolved question is whether longer follow-up reveals an LDL signal in this phenotype.
- Lipid lowering may make sense in people with poor metabolic health, existing cardiovascular disease, or very high-risk context, but the low-carb high-LDL phenotype still needs direct study.
Lean mass hyper-responders and metabolic context
- The lipid energy model connects higher LDL on carbohydrate restriction to leanness, lower triglycerides, higher HDL, and greater fat trafficking through lipoproteins.
- Moving from atherogenic dyslipidemia toward low triglycerides and high HDL can look like risk reduction even when LDL rises.
- A drug, diet, or weight-loss pathway can change many variables at once, so assigning all outcome benefit to LDL lowering is too simple.
- The real debate is whether LDL has the same meaning across metabolically sick people, familial hypercholesterolemia, standard mixed diets, and lean low-carb high-LDL people.
Plants, fiber, microbiome, and food reactivity
- Fiber is not essential in the same way protein and fatty acids are essential, and many fiber benefits may track with health-user patterns.
- A healthy microbiome should be judged by the health of the host, not by assuming that plant intake defines health.
- Carnivore microbiome data and high-fat microbiome reviews challenge the idea that the gut has only one healthy plant-heavy configuration.
- Red meat is useful in elimination because it is often less reactive than eggs, dairy, nuts, grains, or many plant foods.
- Coffee, dairy, eggs, and organ meats are optional variables: some people improve with them, some improve without them, and muscle meat alone can work for long periods.
Organ meats, deficiencies, and practical carnivore
- Organ meats are not mandatory in Shawn Baker's experience; most of his last decade has been muscle meat, with negligible organ intake.
- A large carnivore survey did not show better outcomes for organ-meat eaters compared with non-organ-meat eaters.
- Deficiency fears should be checked against actual clinical signs, blood markers, and function, not only food-list theory.
- Dairy can help people gain weight and muscle, but it can also stall fat loss or cause skin, sinus, or subjective problems.
Carb experiment and sustainability
- A month of fruit, dairy, honey, and whole-food carbohydrate brought more hunger, noisier digestion, tendon irritation, and about ten pounds of weight gain.
- The experiment was not catastrophic, but it made Shawn Baker feel worse than carnivore.
- Ex-carnivores do not disprove the tool; a diet can put disease in remission and still be hard to sustain forever.
- The goal is not permanent restriction for everyone; the goal is recovery first, then the broadest diet that maintains health.
Ethics, public debate, and patient priority
- Vegan debates often move into animal deaths, crop deaths, cows versus chickens, and moral accounting, but Shawn Baker's priority is sick humans.
- Patients with Crohn's disease, ulcerative colitis, rheumatoid arthritis, psoriasis, depression, metabolic syndrome, obesity, diabetes, hypertension, MS, myasthenia gravis, and Hashimoto's need options that can change their trajectory.
- Many of these conditions need randomized trials, but funding is difficult because a meat-based elimination diet is not a patentable drug.
- Informed consent should include both sides that matter to patients: possible remission of severe disease and unknown long-term cardiovascular risk in high-LDL responders.
What is known and what still needs testing
- The known pattern is that many people with serious chronic symptoms become healthier on carnivore or very meat-heavy diets.
- The exact response rate by disease, the relapse rate after food reintroduction, and the long-term cardiovascular risk in low-carb high-LDL people remain unmeasured.
- The next useful work is direct imaging follow-up, better stratification, disease-specific trials, and markers that separate rapid progressors from stable or regressing people.
- The practical clinical stance is to watch the whole person, use imaging and labs intelligently, and keep the door open for food-based recovery when standard care is only managing decline.
References
- [48:21] Muscle Androgen Receptor Content but Not Systemic Hormones Is Associated With Resistance Training-Induced Skeletal Muscle Hypertrophy in Healthy, Young Men — https://doi.org/10.3389/fphys.2018.01373
- [82:15] Carbohydrate Restriction-Induced Elevations in LDL-Cholesterol and Atherosclerosis: The KETO Trial — https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jacadv.2024.101109
- [85:41] Influence of Low High-Density Lipoprotein Cholesterol and Elevated Triglyceride on Coronary Heart Disease Events and Response to Simvastatin Therapy in 4S — https://doi.org/10.1161/hc5001.100624
- [147:13] The gut microbiome without any plant food? A case study on the gut microbiome of a healthy carnivore — https://doi.org/10.1530/MAH-24-0006
- [147:48] Reframing Nutritional Microbiota Studies To Reflect an Inherent Metabolic Flexibility of the Human Gut: a Narrative Review Focusing on High-Fat Diets — https://doi.org/10.1128/mBio.00579-21
- [159:39] Low-density lipoproteins cause atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease. 1. Evidence from genetic, epidemiologic, and clinical studies. A consensus statement from the European Atherosclerosis Society Consensus Panel — https://doi.org/10.1093/eurheartj/ehx144
- [168:28] Intensive Lifestyle Changes for Reversal of Coronary Heart Disease — https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.280.23.2001
Fun quotes
- [00:30] “I’m going to do this all-meat diet. I’m sure I’m going to die… I’m going to get scurvy. My colon’s going to fall out… And of course, none of that happened.”
- [00:30] “Keto was like, ‘Hey, I’m not hungry. That’s weird.’ Now I’m like, ‘Wow, I feel really good and I’m not eating vegetables. That’s really weird.’”
- [00:37] “My goal really as a physician is just try to help sick people.”
- [00:45] “Blood work can change a lot… cholesterol changes 100 points in three days… and this is people making lifelong decisions on a single stupid blood test.”
- [01:25] “Nothing ruins positive results like long-term results.”
- [02:17] “We’re not signing people up for religion or purity cult.”
all 3 comments