Making Butter - 1ltr double cream - Fleur de sel
Pour cold double cream into mixer bowl - about halfway full. Use the whisk attachment and beat, starting slowly and then increasing to a medium-high speed for 8–10 minutes - you might want to cling film the mixer.
First it’ll turn to whipped cream, then separate into butter and buttermilk. Once you see clumps of butter and buttermilk, stop. Strain off the buttermilk, then knead the butter under cold ice water with your hands until the water runs clear. Dry well on a clean kitchen cloth. Season butter - 500g butter to 6g fleur de sel.
summerizer
Core question
- Butter making at Trinity has been done for 20 years, and this batch tests whether better taste also saves money.
- The test uses excellent double cream, because butter quality depends on cream quality.
- Good double cream for this purpose is 47% fat, heavy, rich, and worth paying for.
Method
- The double cream goes into the mixer with a whisk attachment, though the same job can be done by hand.
- The cream first becomes whipped cream, then overwhips, splits, and separates into butter and buttermilk.
- Cling film around the mixer matters because the separation stage throws wet buttermilk and butter around the kitchen.
- Once the cream splits, the mixer keeps running until the butter pulls away and the buttermilk becomes clearly separate.
- The butter is squeezed by hand, collected into clumps, and moved into ice water.
- The butter is broken and squeezed until the liquid coming out is no longer white.
- Removing buttermilk is necessary for storage because leftover buttermilk turns sour quickly.
Yield and cost
- The cream costs the restaurant £9.75.
- The batch yields about 1 kg of butter.
- The rough cooking-butter benchmark is first £2 per 250 g, then the final comparison uses £2.29 per 250 g.
- The homemade butter is listed at £2.25 per 250 g in the final comparison.
- On ingredient cost alone, the homemade batch is more expensive than the first cooking-butter benchmark and close to the final cooking-butter comparison.
- Premium salted French table butter costs about £4 per 250 g, or £16 per kg.
- Against that premium table butter, the homemade butter is cheaper.
- The remaining justification for making it is taste, and labor still has to be counted.
Seasoning and shaping
- The butter is salted at 3 g per 250 g, so a 1 kg batch takes 12 g of French salt.
- The salt is mixed through the butter, then the butter is shaped into a cylinder, wrapped, and stored in the fridge.
- The portions are roughly 250 g each.
Taste test
- The homemade butter tastes better than expected on Trinity bread.
- The flavor is more grassy than the bought butter.
- The salt is more consistent through the homemade butter, from the start through the middle and finish.
- The bought butter tastes more mellow, with the salt arriving more at the end.
- The homemade batch wins the tasting and rivals the premium French butter used for table service.
Takeaway
- The best reason to make butter is not a dramatic saving over ordinary cooking butter.
- The reason to make it is control over the cream, salt, freshness, texture, and table-butter quality.
- Good cream, controlled whipping, splash protection, thorough buttermilk removal, 3 g salt per 250 g, wrapping, and chilling make the process work.
References
- None.
1 comment