until their maker gets an exemption
Ah, yes, how to ask for a bribe 101.
until their maker gets an exemption
Ah, yes, how to ask for a bribe 101.
Let me guess, Don Jr. conveniently started a router company yesterday?
Here's a list of all the commercially available US made routers below
<null>
Good hunting !
Everyone who is even remotely technically able and even slightly concerned about privacy needs to learn how to BYO router
Sounds... like a bit of a pain in the ass.
So, I imagine we're talking about a linux micro-pc with perhaps 1 or 2 additional pcix networking cards?
If you want a dedicated device, sure. Image it with OPNSense and it'll basically just work.
You can also take any desktop you already have, fire up an OPNSense VM, pcie passthrough your WAN NIC + WiFi card, bridge to a separate LAN NIC, go through the setup, and there's your router.
Alright, well I appreciate the direction there, that's really helpful.
You can also take any desktop you already have, fire up an OPNSense VM, pcie passthrough your WAN NIC + WiFi card, bridge to a separate LAN NIC, go through the setup, and there's your router.
Although, I gotta be honest, for someone who doesn't regularly use Linux, that does sound like a lot of potential issues getting this working.
That's fair. Once you understand some basics though it's not too bad. There's a UI just like any router you might already be used to. The most confusing part for someone who is new to this would probably be setting up the VM hardware plumbing, and understanding that a passthrough means that hardware is unavailable to the host.
It is possible (and now probably encouraged) to run router software on an old PC. You can also slot in a PCIE nic or connect it too a hardware switch and AP for more flexibility and control.
This won't stop your ISP from spying on you, but it will stop your American router manufacturer from spying on you.
Many people will soon find joy in slapping a 4-port NIC into an old PC and learning nftables, BIND9 and kea.
I will find joy in learning about all of these things now.
Thank you!
You don't even need all that, if you're just doing wifi routing, one wired nic and one wifi card will do, if you want wired routing too, just one more nic will do, then use a dumb switch to get the multiple ports.
The covered list notes they use the National Security Determination definition of router which is as follows:
Routers: For the purpose of this determination, the term “Routers” is defined by National Institute of Science and Technology’s Internal Report 8425A to include consumer-grade networking devices that are primarily intended for residential use and can be installed by the customer. Routers forward data packets, most commonly Internet Protocol (IP) packets, between networked systems
So enterprise devices (which is where an attacker would focus their attention if they were looking for large payouts or political leverage) don't count, nor do APs or switches. That really just seems like an excuse to have a platform for the Feds to spy on their citizens.
Also, since when does the FCC have jurisdiction over wired routers? Like the post text explicitly says they will not authorize radios, which wired routers don't have...
We'll see what happens after the inevitable wave if lawsuits grinds its way through the courts.
How many strictly wired routers are there anymore? (Somewhat rhetorical question, but I am a little curious)
Enterprise grade routers are different from the typical consumer wifi router. In large companies, wired only routers are it. Youll have differnt ports and different media, but wifi is usually a different set of equipment.
Yeah but I think this legislation is targeting consumer grade equipment, professional tends to be more expensive than consumers are willing to spend, so I wasn't really considering it part of the equation.
It's always projection. This means the dark empire is weaponizing commercial drones and wifi routers and everything else. They don't want anyone to do to them, what they will now do to you.
That was exactly my thought. "Oh, this means thar the US has Spyware on the routers produced inside the USA, and any US drone has killswitches built in."
Wait, it talks about FCC radio authorization. However that doesn’t make it a router, just an access point. Quite a few routers (thinking the Pro-sumer Uniquiti UXG models) don’t even have radios and aren’t wireless so there’s no radio they can withhold certification on. This could affect AIOs but all you’d have to do is separate your router from your AP.
Definitely sounds like a quickly thrown out, half baked shakedown (bribe) measure with something they could control (radio authorization) and just targeted routers since that’s a common place they are.
So... can I still flash custom firmware like OPNsense and Openwrt on them? Cause I literally just posted about hardware decision a few days ago 😭
Edit: It seems the article and actual FCC document will leave previous router models alone, but anything newer is cooked... Even the US brands like Cisco aren't actually manufactured here because we fucking outsource evrything. I hate this government.
You can just buy one of those SBCs with two RJ45 ports that can be used as routers, i doubt that those will be banned.
Or just a PCIe nic in an old desktop
Yeah this is where I'm at. Even an old thin client with like 4 cores and 8GBs of RAM is more than enough for the majority of home users. Find one with two NICs or a small pcie slot, slap in a 4 port and you're smooth sailing.
I plan on building exactly this soon and throw opnsense on it
They COULD just regulate these things...
looks dubious
I mean, I don't disagree that there are security risks posed by random consumer broadband routers. It is definitely the case that unmaintained
not intentionally shipped with malware
routers have been a real security problem in the past. My own view is that the current set of conventions, which often has very poor or no security on devices on the LAN and thus relies on the router to keep bad stuff out, is a very real part of that problem, but sure, having a secure router is part of that.
However.
I'd say that the majority of the threats that a router poses are also posed by any device on the LAN that can call out to the Internet. Like, you aren't doing a lot to secure devices on the LAN if you ban routers and then I can still go buy random gadget from wherever that can get on the WiFi or wired Ethernet network and phone home, take instructions from home, and can talk to other devices on the LAN. I mean, are you also going to ban, say, smart televisions? Ethernet-connected security cameras? I mean, poorly-secured network-connected cameras have posed very real threats in places like Ukraine, where military intelligence has actively exploited them to get information about an area come conflict.
And I just don't think that we're going to commit to locking that down.
The idea is to stamp some that install doge palantir vibe coded back door to the propaganda control machine then they're "made in the us" and then you just have to come up with a good excuse. But the excuse department is kind of busy, so wysiwyg
They did a first pass on banning security cameras many years ago. It was maybe the test bed, I can definitely see that one getting revisited. They only banned two major manufacturers that had kinda already been caught as a major security concern.
It's why you don't see hikvision or dahua anymore where they used to be major players.
The router ban was literally adding to the same list.
At least this bans isreali routers
They will get an exemption, if they don't have it already.
Ah yes, more security holes incoming. Gotta love maglomania (not sure if that is the correct word?)
Well, I tried to get y'all to stock up on drones a year ago
Unrelated: drones make a great Christmas gift for that recently laid off, benefits denied, recently diagnosed with a disease caused by known carcinogens in their everything, injured at work, under paid and exploited person you know.
Get em before they’re deemed a safety hazard and pulled from shelves.
For some reason the above comment gives an error of Error when viewed outside my comments.
https://lemmy.ca/post/34476205/13234882
Maybe I made them ban drones:
I may have suggested some things.
You may have to copy and paste that link - voyager refuses to open it.
I was hoping to hold off on upgrading my modem and router until at least one of them died. Considering the nature of the Regime, I should just bite the bullet and spend some of my savings. That money will lose value anyways.
Costco is selling an BE19000 router for about $240. That is a bit cheaper than the same thing on Amazon.
top 76 comments