The Texas farmers....."How can Biden do this to us?"
post
This is the ultimate Texan dog-that-caught-the-car moment. I remember talking about this in school in Texas 25 years ago when Republicans were complaining about immigration. Several students brought up that the farms are all tended by "seasonal workers," which meant immigrant labor, so what was the Republican answer to that? They didn't have one, of course, not a realistic one. It was the same talking points then as now of "American workers" filling the gap, and even then those jobs didn't pay a living wage, so no American would take them. I bet they pay worse now.
They had 25 years to figure this out, but of course they had no intention of figuring it out.
They're gonna arrest the immigrant farm workers and then lease them right back to the same farms as slaves.
They didn’t have one, of course, not a realistic one.
When I try to have discussions around this I often take elements of their language and point out that market forces make it unattractive for citizens to work there, but it can be good for immigrants. Sometimes they get it, but often too indoctrinated into the republican party to act differently.
Have the day you voted for, Texas.
a corporation that cannot pay labor what it requires (ie the market) should choose: shut down or shut down. profit is stolen wage, too. So… yeah.
Remember kids: corporations are not people. Unlike babies, corporations can be thrown out with the bath water.
Pay labor a living wage or get fucked.
Totally get it, super on board, but uh, to circle back to the here and now for a second, we kinda need food? So the situation as it is right now really blows.
Some people are joking about $70 salads, but also there is a point in there. Farming sucks ass a job and if you paid people enough to incentivise folks to do it, that's something not a lot of farmers can do, especially small ones.
So what would an ideal solution be with the technology we have now?
Syndicalism. Farmers co-ops. Food from your lawn.
Have you talked to the average American about agriculture? They would starve themselves in a few months.
Also, you would have to come up with rules on who grows what and how seed savings would work. You need to keep things that can cross pollinate away from each other.
Now you know the point of Leviticus 19:19 and Deuteronomy 22:9.
Not really elaborating on that much... Not everyone can afford to drive out to the country to work on a farm for food, and a lot of people don't have lawns.
I’m not saying a post reply on lemmy will cover what I mean or fix everything ; but my examples are things we can start with and they don’t hurt. Recovery from capitalism will take a long time.
Look, I'm all for dismantling capitalism, but you do your cause disservice if you criticize something, act like you have the answers, and then don't deliver. If you don't have the answers just say so up front.
is it a disservice to the slave to leave his chains or even discuss it, even if he has nowhere to go after?
"Complaining about a problem without posing a solution is called whining." Teddy Roosevelt
I'm not saying to not discuss it. I'm not saying to stay a slave.
When were talking about people needing to eat, though, you're gonna need some solutions if you want to enact change. No one can do a revolution on an empty stomach, and if you're going to hand wave basic survival, you're not going to get anyone to follow you.
i don’t understand. i mentioned some starter solutions. Do you want a logistical breakdown soup to nuts? You can confer with greater minds than mine for that.
Personally I do what I can. I help my neighbors and my community at large, as best as I can. And I support where I can, too.
Those weren't feasible solutions at all.
80% or so of America lives in cities. So they aren't going to be able to use a coop farm and a lot of them don't have land to grow anything on.
Also farming isn't something anyone can pick up. Sure, harvesting is pretty easy to learn, but for massive scale farming that we need to survive, you need specialized equipment, training and tools. Things most people just don't have.
Your "solutions" are hand waving ideas that haven't been thought through in the slightest.
They won't work.
Again, just to make sure I'm crystal here, I'm so for dismantling the insane capitalistic system we have, stopping the exploitation of farm workers, reforming our food industry, etc. I really super am on your side here. But if we want those changes you're gonna have to actually think through the solutions you're giving people and not just give some nothing burgers like these.
what stops coop farms from bringing goods to cities?
also people have created solutions. they exist in the writings of folks like engels, etc.
Not having all the solutions should not stop people from recognizing things are shit.
Don’t gatekeep the emotional connection and instead ask leading questions.
There's a big difference between recognizing things are shit and pretending you know the answer.
where did I pretend? you’re hanging on to an idea that is irrelevant - that I’m in some sort of conflict with you. sheesh.
If you think other people's ideas or their feelings when they interact with you are irrelevant, then you're kind of a dick.
Your whole vibe this whole conversation was giving the impression that you had a solution, and you admittedly don't. I asked for one to give you a platform to present a solution, but you clearly just pulled something out of your ass and then passed the buck to someone more knowledgeable when pressed.
If you haven't thought about what the solutions to basic problems like these are, and haven't done the research so you could tell me what those more learned people have come up with, you're nothing more than a parrot.
You wanna be a socialist? Do some research and come back to us with some solid solutions, not just "uh grow your own food in the lawn you probably don't have in an area that might not even grow everything or enough, peasant".
sigh. you think lemmy is a good forum for expounding ideas? your entire reply “vibe” seemed like you just wanted to hear an idea and shoot it down. just to shoot it down. i’m not falling into that rabbit hole. if you opened a little softer things may have been different.
meet me at the pub over a few guinness and I’ll be happy do spitball ideas. Like I already do in real life.
Dude I opened with kid gloves and threw you a soft slow ball.
Do is a favor and stop pretending to be part of our movement you're making us look bad.
show me an example of what a hit reply would have looked like to you? co-ops, farms, syndicalism… not hit enough? Did you need me to explain how toothbrushes would work?
basically i never claimed to have cogent large scale answers. you seem like that offended you or you are poking in bad faith. I feel instead you should be asking “leading” questions meant to inspire constructive thoughts on the matter.
i’m done with this thread. Enjoy your day.
It didn't hit enough, definitely said so, and if you bothered to read anything I told you exactly why those wouldn't work.
I'm not exactly keen on taking advice from you on much of anything, frankly, because you don't think things through or, you know, observe.
Done. Your salad is now $74.99
Sounds like capitalism has failed then at that point. Seize the means brother.
if that’s what means labor gets a living wage (which also assumes I get one), and the corporation makes no profit and the workers own the means of production- cool!
Cows eat salad....here's your $3900.99 double McChicken, 1/4 pounder delight with bacon bits sir! It's served over a Mexican cheese platen...oh don't eat the platen! That's just to keep the moisture in!
Funny how no part of the article mentioned hundreds of eager American workers rushing into those farm jobs. Nor the farmers/ranchers deciding they'd have to raise their prices and their pay rates.
That's probably because markets aren't going to pay more for the crops, and nobody wants to work that hard except people with no other options.
It's the same thing after brexit. I cant find the source anymore. But something like 6000 non-immigrants signed up for farm work and only like ten showed up. And none stayed longer than two days. So it's not like they didn't have a recent example of how this would turn out.
This is not a problem for big ag. That's why no regional or national ag-orgs are complaining. This is not a face eating leopard moment, sadly.
Campaneros still need to work. The pattern at the moment is they stay away for a few days after a raid, but then return. This benefits their bosses. Previously there were work stoppages to pressure bosses to raise the $/piece rate. Not now.
Plus the regime has promised to replace the workers lost to their ethnic cleansing campaign with an expanded H2a visa program - after having stripped away many of the already meager protections against wage theft.
The plantation lords know they're getting cheaper, more exploitable labor.
I was talking to a friend there and he told me people in the suburbs are having trouble getting their lawns mowed now. So glad I got out of there.
Ain't you redneck chucklefucks glad you voted red? Enjoy losing your farm.
To all those farmers, the only thing I could possibly say is,
“I hope you have the day you voted for”.
But where did the workers go?
It'd be funny if it wasn't going to affect the rest of the population that didn't vote for a psychotic nutjob.
"BAW-HA-HA-HA" - Canada.
Haha... Until you remember that we get most of our fresh produce from the States we are going to pay for this in the end.
Not true for me in PEI. We are actively NOT buying US products. It really hasn't been a problem at all for us at this point.
The only fresh produce we've had a problem getting is sweet onions and lettuce (sometimes). We can get red and white onions from mexico and other locations, just the sweet ones come from the states. I'm sure this will change over the growing season.
We're setting up a rig to grow our own lettuce and a few other things year round.
Does this mean we will see unemployment numbers go down in the coming weeks/months?
I’m not asking with any agenda, I’m just curious if it will end up measured in that way.
I don't think undocumented people are included in labor statistics.
So I don't think this will look bad on paper. No farmers are prepared to pay fair wages to staff so it's most likely good food will sit in fields and rot as the prices rise at the supermarket.
Farmers will never learn, those people are the only ones willing to do the work. White kids have been raised that that work is beneath them
That yes, but also more.
One positive aspect of social media is showing the young how the world really works, to an extent I think.
Poor immigrants are generally in a more uninformed and desperate survival situation. Many probably aren't of the mindset "fuck slaving away 14hrs a day for shit pay to make a billionaire richer". They just generally don't think that way yet.
I personally would rather die than be forced to work in those conditions. I sympathize with them and wish they didn't have to either. But they're still currently the ones more desperate and willing to suffer.
I would be willing to help with farm work however, if the pay was significantly better, 4-6hrs per day, 2-3 days per week. But normalizing this would necessitate eradicating billionaires and even hundred millionaires. Obviously not gonna happen.
I'm just sayin' it's more than just white kids are lazy. At least I hope so.
Disagree. There are plenty of people who would do the work, they're just not willing to do it for the amount farmers are willing to pay.
Also, you'd have to be insane to do outside work in both Florida and Texas, now that both states have got rid of mandated water breaks for outdoor workers.
Not to mention going there. Except for people desperate for work, who in their right mind would travel to magastan out in the country m, to shave away with no water or bathroom breaks, in the hot sun all day without even water for minimum wage? There are just so many reasons for an immediate no
It isn't beneath me. I just don't think I could physically do it as a job. Also, the pay is bad. So, it's pretty low on my job list. I'd rather work a fast food job. And I never want to work one again.
Not good lay plus that job sucks, it's beneath you.
I feel like the not being able to physically do it matters a bit more, but maybe you're right. I don't look down on people that do those jobs, because it's something that needs to get done, just like teachers, but they aren't jobs I'd recommend for anyone.
I feel like the not being able to physically do it matters a bit more,
This is what slavers said, too.
Isn't it kind of ableist to assume that when somebody says they are "not able to physically do" a job, that they're lazy or classist? For all we know, they could have mobility issues or be unable to do sustained manual labor.
I assume that if I tried my hand at farming, the bosses won't let me take enough water or breaks to maintain my health. Farm work is backbreaking, everyone should be given enough pay, healthcare, and rest to ensure their wellbeing. Unfortunately, dickheads think that fair work standards are not important.
It is time for Texas and company to learn that their stupidity has consequences.
Every job deserves a living wage and the government should be providing healthcare. Agriculture needing to be substituted by undocumented workers is a sign of deeper issues with the economic system.
Nice try, racist. Stop splitting the working class up like that. Labor should be paid a living wage and any corp what cannot do that should fail. Race of the worker is irrelevant.
Capitalists have you convinced it is different between races but only because that distraction keeps capitalists exploiting the working class folk.
Ain’t no war but class war.
The funny thing is that with Trump sabotaging the US dollar migrant labor may just stop being a thing on it's own.
I hope we see more of this and the farmers that voted red, feel the pain they voted for. I don’t care if it cause a bigger issue. At this point I’m ready to rebuild America

all 71 comments