You dont understand, my centralized power structure is based on giving. It could never be commandeered by power hungry psychopaths and used for their own gain like the rest of the power structures around the globe.
post
Well, if they were persecuted by this giant surveillance and oppression apparatus, they must've been bourgeoisie.
I feel Engels with his text "On Authority" is the OG of this kind of activity. Here is a text that goes into more detail
May I interest you in a meme?
The whole point is that truth=group acceptance.
I swear to fuck nothing has set back Marxism as much as the ussr
The USSR clearly must have been an CIA insider job /s
Nothing makes me more skeptical of anarchism than being told I'd have to rely on my local community.
Sounds like you need to work on improving your local community.
Where I am in Melbourne, we're a large and diverse group of people, there are constant events and community acitivities, a large co-op garden is just down the hill from me, at the park nearby there's frequently food trucks helping the poor/homeless.
It's not perfect, but give me more of that over Albanese and his genocidal enabling, Trump buddy-ness any day. I'd rather see my taxes/work go towards building this up than subsiding a mining company.
Mmm maybe i should work on it, perhaps through a hierarchical structure that works to organise people, bring out their best and simplify interactions with other communities?
Or instead of trying to have someone be above the others and dictate to them, you could just work together with them for the betterment of your community 🤷
And would elevating the most capable in the community help with that?
No.
Empowering everyone to work together would help with that.
Giving everyone a voice and a chance to meet and talk together to work out the how they would like a better community to look would help with that.
Ordering people around will only give you exactly what you already have as I assume you live in a LGA, with a hierarchical structure already, no?
@Deceptichum At least your hand/nick makes sensem Decept being the first part of Deception, and Chum being the first part of Chump... Ok that was a cheap shot, but I tire of people working on emotion instead of logic, projection instead of history, and the bad outcomes that inevitably result.
@Deceptichum Anytime you decide that having no formal power structure is a good idea, someone will fill the gap and odds are pretty good it will be much worse than formalizing the structure and making a conscious choice would have been. History proves this.
You have literally been given examples of societies existing with no formal power structure. Instead of arguing against reality, educate yourself please.
@Deceptichum You ignore all the negatives and you present untruths. The Bolsheviks weren't voted in by a majority and the result was some six million starved to death. And of those great societies how many still exist?
The Bolsheviks suck shit, as do all other Marxists.
Of the two I listed, they both still exist and are both still armed and defending themselves.
@Deceptichum Armed conflict is not my idea of a blissful existence. It's something I hope the human race can move away from over time. We waste great deal of resources, lose limbs and life, and for what? Instead of fighting over the pie better to make it bigger. That of course takes effort but it's worth while.
Armed conflict is happening all over the world, mostly perpetuated by states. People in the communities I listed, generally live happy peaceful lives, it's not everyday is a literal battle-zone.
It would be great if the human race could move beyond it, and that's why I agitate for anarchism as a means of us achieving that.
We waste resources because there are people who are antagonistic to self-governance, they think they have an authority to control people. Self-defence is a necessity until they are defeated.
@Deceptichum Making excuses for something doesn't change it. Not learning from history destines one to repeat it.
@Deceptichum Anarchists fail to recognize a most basic trait of nature. Nature abhors a vacuum and this is particularly true of a power vacuum. Create a structure without leadership, someone will step in and fill that role, usually the least desirable of the options available.
Cool, so we'll shoot them.
It is not complicated, and we already see it in action today so your 'natural law' theory is bullshit like every other time chuds try to bring it up as an argument.
@Deceptichum Obviously you have no knowledge of history. Those who won't learn history are destined to repeat it.
I really think there is no way of fixing this world. Carl Sagan foreseen it many years ago and said that we are fuked
all 51 comments