If the court was doing their job they would have ruled this unconstitutional in the first place. A tariff is a tax, the executive explicitly does not get that power
post
Take away his ability to implement tariffs at all. That should be up to Congress along with things like declaring war.
Think about how mentally ill this entire scenario is for a second... Congress voted to deny king fascist from doing something he never possessed the ability to do in the first place. Like, his executive orders about tariffs are supposed to be completely ignored, yet businesses and the government have been illegally collecting tariffs anyway, because a pathological liar lied and declared a "national emergency".
The USA is a lawless, failed state ass, corporate klepto dictatorship masquerading as "democracy"...
The MAGA party that swallowed the Republican party
A lot of people are going to need deprogramming. Make it easy on them
I really hope we get to that point. But we are trending the wrong fucking way for that right now.
The whole democratic world is sliding right.
No America is the Republican party is a symptom of the rot. And so are the Democrats they never undo all the republicans do so it is a slide to the right always.
Not to distract from the importance of your point, but due to the layout of your message I spent an embarrassingly long time trying to figure out how you made letters extra thin.
America is what America does, not what America conveniently claims to be.
So what's going to happen when Trump vetoes this?
Kicked back. Overruled by 2/3 supermajority in house+senate.
Given that the EO exceeded branch powers in the first place, that there is now blood in the water, and considering how unpopular this additional sales tax is becoming among both consumers and business owners, it’s not impossible that votes would flip to overturn.
In that case, however, expect another EO to preempt the result by yet again reversing tariffs for specific cases.
All of this back and forth takes time. We won’t be completely rid of tariffs until the 2026 midterms, at the earliest, and that is only if a supermajority of “Demoncrats” and “RINOs” are elected, unfortunately.
Businesses could revolt and stop collecting tariffs in anticipation of this, but it’s a risk they probably won’t take, because they’re all afraid of Trump.
First Brazil, now Canada. DO THE REST!
While the resolutions won’t ultimately take effect, they have proven to be an effective way for Democrats to expose cracks between the president’s trade policy and Republican senators who have traditionally supported free trade arguments.
... However, House Republicans have passed new rules that allow leaders to prevent such resolutions from getting a vote in that chamber, and Trump could veto the legislation even if it did clear Congress.
Fuck yes!
But this is not forgotten and Trump is definitely not going to let this stand.
Also people should face consequences for unconstitutionally doing this.
ELI5: How can they vote on shit when the government is shut down? Help me out here.
Iirc, only the House is shut down. Someone said this is symbolic, with the House shut down this would never reach the President, who would certainly veto it anyway.
Republicans don't cross the aisle when it would mean anything. They just want to say they voted for something good, even though everyone can tell it won't pass
Only the house is down. The only reason the house is down is so they can avoid swearing in Adelita Grijalva and having to vote on Epstein stuff. House GOP are huge sore losing cowards.
The government shutdown doesn't interfere with either house or senate doing business.
Does this also need to pass in the house? (where they are not meeting because of the funding vote?)
That’s really close.
Kaine, joined by other Democrats and Paul, has forced the votes under a decades-old law that allows Congress to block a president’s emergency powers. However, House Republicans have passed new rules that allow leaders to prevent such resolutions from getting a vote in that chamber, and Trump could veto the legislation even if it did clear Congress.
So basically, nothing is going to change.
You can't put the fart back into the bottle after popping the cork and inhaling deeply.
I'm not going to promise change or anything, but
US is currently in shutdown. On Nov 1st, there will be tangible reactions to specific health insurance premium increases that should have many people with up $1000/month, and some $2000/month quotes. There is a possibility of a reopening deal that would include the tariff overturn vote. Trump may come up with a brand new national emergency declaration to reimpose tariffs.
Supreme court is also reviewing these tariffs soon, and Constitutional Congressional oversight power, backed up by this vote against them, could influence their decision.
Oh so they can change the rules any time they want? (They've always been able to do this).
Ask yourself, why don't they change the rules to allow them to bypass Dems and open the government?
Something something they want it closed.
But Bourbon Mitch and the others can say “see we tried” (knowing full well that this doesn’t matter)!
I was wondering if the 10% additional tariff due to the political ad would have any affect, since it doesn't even pass the "emergency drug crisis" test.
Well shit.
I don't want negotiation with the US to go our way, I want it to go away. Permanently.
So it does nothing. Awesome.
Requires a presidential signature, like most legislation. It could only do anything if it had super majority votes, thus making it veto proof.
Showing that there's more senate support against this policy isn't nothing, but I do take your point.
So Trump really can do what ever the fuck he wants.
If he vetos it, in a sane world you would assume that there were some senators that agreed with it but refused to break party lines. The president could exercise political calculus and sign it to cover for them. But instead it would get sent back to the senate, where senators may rationally choose breaking from Trump over shooting themselves (and everyone else) in the economic foot.
Thats in a sane world though, and we live in this shit instead
No. He can't do tariffs without legislative approval. This is where the house would impeach him due to his blatant disregard of the constitution and the breaking of his path of office. Or the Supreme Court would step in to strip him of his illegal power.
... except the legislature and courts are captured by his party. The founding fathers were fucking idiots for thinking that "each branch competes against the others" without considering what would happen if allies captured all the branches. All of the safeguards against "hasty action" have become the cuffs that bind us against stopping this. They really did just make a king with a troublesome government in his way. And now the government is stepping out of the way.
Four. AKA .... The first crack
it could either mean a. They want to pretend to be bipartisan and know it will die in house of reps. Or B, there's a lot more more hidden(pathetic) anti trumpers enough that 4 repubs felt comfortable breaking in this political climate.
Vote is symbolic only. Of course it would take 17 Republicans senators breaking with Trump to override his veto, and then there's the impossibility of getting 2/3rds of the House to do the same.
But hopefully you're right and it's only the first crack.
Nice gesture but Mr. Johnson and the House of Representative Republicans voted not to talk about tariffs and also to tie their hands behind their back.
all 35 comments