Best math meme so far.
post
I understand why this is wrong (order of operations dictates the division happens first, so it's really 25 - 1 = 24), but why is it funny? I don't mean "This isn't funny," I think I'm just missing the joke.
Unexpected expected factorial
This is quite possibly the best maths joke I've ever seen.
[edit] I guess it still can't beat the 'be rational' / 'get real' one.
Clever! lol
Comment section full of people looking for an opportunity to argue
No it isn't
Yes it is
Wait, will this be the 5-minute or the half hour?
ASCII hack failure of language. Even in mathematics, ! has multiple meanings like with Boolean NOT. We need a science, math, and language reformation to remove non intuitive narcissistic names, and implied contextual meanings.
You might find Lojban interesting if you are not already aware. (I haven't tried to learn it myself, I just know it exists)
If someone wants to start a Lojban pun community, I would definitely subscribe just to learn about Lojban.
Although, if no one posted in the community, I wouldn't be sure if it was a perfectly logical language or the community was just dead.
.i la lojban cu mutce lo ka smuske tinsa .i ku'i ly. na logji prane pe'i .i loi jbopre cu piso'iroi da'asnu lo ka prane nitcu .i ru'a lo klamburi cu na'e lojbo ka'u .i jy. xebni lo malgli .iseju lo nu lojbo klamburi zbasu cu nandu ba'a jeku'i cumki
Lojban is very semantically rigid, but not perfectly logical IMO. Lojbanists often argue about the necessity of logical perfection. I suspect that puns might not be seen as culturally Lojbanic. Lojbanists hate Anglicisms or bits of English leaking into the way they speak Lojban. Regardless, making Lojbanic puns might be difficult but it's possible.
I've never seen ! used for boolean NOT in maths, just ¬. I think ! is something programming languages went for because it's easier to type. That said, screw (a, b). Is that a (coordinate) pair, an interval, an inner product, some secret fourth thing? Who knows!
Promptly Evacuate Manure Drain And Septic
The answer in the comic is correct. It's just written in a way to make you as the reader think he's got it wrong for a second.
The ! operator in mathematics indicates a function called a factorial. Four factorial, or 4! = 4 × 3 × 2 × 1 = 24. Which is the correct answer if you follow the proper order of operations.
Can someone explain to me why this is funny?
So with people who do order of operations incorrectly, you have 25-5 =20 and then divide it by 5 and you get 4.
However the correct answer is 24 since you do the division first.
Where the joke comes in is he states “4!”, which sounds like he is emphatic about the wrong answer. However an exclamation mark is “factorial” which translates to 4x3x2x1… which happens to equal the correct answer of 24.
25 - ⁵/₅ = 25 - 1 = 24
If you wrote it vertically:
25 - 5
————— = 4
5
But once you lay it out on one line, you have to use prins to prioritize addition / subtraction:
(25 - 5) / 5 = 20 / 5 = 4
Some YouTube mathematicians deep-dive into this.
ETA: Nothing goes over my head! My reflexes are too fast, I would catch it.
The joke is 4! (Factorial) Is 24 so it looks right even if you do order of operations incorrectly.
5-5/5 != 4
I’m only going to say this once but if I’m doing a sum and you want me to do it in a specific order, use brackets. That’s what brackets are for. Don’t expect me to do things in a predetermined order because I literally can’t be bothered and I will never care enough to do that. I’m already doing a sum so don’t push it, okay bud
But that's a bit like saying "If you're going to talk to me, put the adjectives before the nouns," even in Spanish where they come after. Mathematical notation is a language and it has a syntax. Sure, you can decide to ignore that syntax, or insist that people modify their use of it for you, but it's not really a reasonable expectation.
I think this is very stupid for a number of reasons. Why is there an order of operations that supersedes the direction the operations are written in? That’s at best dim witted and at worst deliberately misleading. Grog write left to right. Grog read left to right. Grog do sum left to right.
There is absolutely no reason in the world why anybody should have to know that division comes before subtraction. That’s fucking insane, man. What is the point of writing things down if you’re only going to do them in a set order anyway? May as well have a big jumble of letters and numbers and symbols on the page at that point, like who cares. The whole point of writing things down is to express concepts. Can’t do that with any kind of nuance if you’re going to read it one way anyway, no matter how you write it down. That would be like saying you always pronounce certain letters at the start of words even if they’re in the middle. Completely nuts.
If all people did was simple equations like the one in the OP, you'd probably be right, but math syntax has to deal with all kinds of equations. Your way, I can't write 3x^2–4x+5. Instead, I'd have to write ((((3x)^2)−4)x)+5. That's WAY more obnoxious. It's better to have an unambiguous syntax that covers all the cases and lets me write equations in an more simple form.
Grog write left to right.
Gorg is from another country and writes right to left.
Grog read left to right.
Gorg reads right to left
Grog do sum left to right
Gorg does sums right to left
well then you should stop doing math cuz you're doing it wrong

top 88 comments