post
Welp, that's the end of it then. Goodbye lastfm. Glad that I found listenbrainz a while ago.
Does listenbrain have a way to scrobble from apple music?
This likely won't affect the listenbrainz syncing from last.fm so you can still scrobbled to last FM and then to LB.
Do you realize the pro account is required only for the app developer, not the user? Users don't need API keys unless they have developed their own app for scrobbling.
Some players like Foobar work fine without an API, but music servers like Navidrome need it to scrobble. Maybe that can change? Announcing it with just 10 days’ notice isn’t great though.
Fair point. Plex doesn't ask for an API key, I wasn't aware that other services asked for a user-provided key. It'll be interesting to see how it shakes out with the services that ask for a user-provided API key.
And yeah, I agree that 10 days notice is not good.
Personally, I scrobble both to last.fm and to listenbrainz, but I get most of my stats from last.fm because of the easy drilldown features. If listenbrainz ever gets that worked out, I'll switch... especially because listenbrainz can capture individual artists in tracks with more than one artist.
Bah. I've been scrobbling to last.fm for 20 years. It's going to be weird not scrobbling and keeping track of what I've been listening to anymore but I'm not paying for access or starting over somewhere else.
You could import your data to Listenbrainz and switch to that.
Does Listenbrainz only work with stuff already catalogued on the Musicbrainz database?
If it aint in the DB it will just log the play without any additional information.
I assume if the name fits enough it will link it later on if someone adds an entry for it.
It can scrobble listens that aren't on musicbrainz, idk about importing
Same. I guess Libre.FM is still a thing. Everyone seems to be mentioning Listenbrainz
about the same here https://www.last.fm/user/desmosthenes
Their post on the issue is surprisingly levelheaded, even if I’m not sure that this is the best way to address abuse.
We're also reaching out directly to a handful of free tools that give a lot back to the community.
Do they want people to scrobble their listening or not?
https://lastfm.ghan.nl/export/
For those who want to grab a copy of their LastFM scrobbles.
I don't know... It says I only have 685 scrobbles instead of 25,000.
Works great!
I think that's pages or similar. Mine said 214, but returned my 42,000 fine.
My lower count but higher tracks seems to conflict with what you said, but I think the gist still holds.
Glad I ditched last fm for a self hosted instance of Maloja
for me it's time to ditch last.fm entirely. I already self host Koito, I was only using last.fm as a fallback, but now I'm convinced it's gonna get enshittified.
Don't both of you use the public network effect of finding new artists, though?
for me, it was the 1st platform I used to keep track of my listening habits and never bothered to use something else. I rarely use it for music discovery. I find bandcamp and internet radios like NTS or WorldwideFM better for that purpose.
Not exactly. When I was a teen I used Last fm to find artists. And as I got older I did start finding artists at shows. My music taste isn't exactly "mainstream.'
For perspective, I only remember one price increase for Last.fm Pro ($3 to $5). I think that's a fair cost for a service I've used since 2005 based on price alone.
That said, making this announcement two weeks before implementation sucks. And I agreed with commenters who feel there are more robust options to limit bad actors from abusing API keys.
The owners need to make a good faith argument about why users need a Pro account. If they need more money then let's talk about it. But this feels like looking at the problem (uncontrolled API traffic) and throwing up your hands.
ListenBrainz go
This shit pisses me off to no end now I gotta spend my weekend getting Koito up and running on everything I use, including Plex, which I don't know if it supports it or not.
Check multi-scrobbler. It can scrobble from almost everything to almost everything. The idea is that you'll have (Plex, streaming service A, streaming service B...) -> multi-scrobble -> koito (for example).
Edit: https://docs.multi-scrobbler.app/configuration/sources/plex/
I was worried for a second, but beets doesn't use the API to get genres. I use Musicbrainz for everything else.
The only reason I use last.fm is for the recommendations. Is there a self hosted service that can do that?
Listenbrainz does, but they're not as good.
They started okay for the first few weeks, but now it's trapped in a loop of recommending the same 90s pop songs.
That's why more people need to join. Recommendations will get better if people scrobble more there.
For sure!
I'm just saying that the top 5 artists scrobbled this week are BTS/their members and then followed by Linkin park, BTS again, Radiohead, BTS, then Taylor Swift and Olivia Rodrigo.
BTS has like 10x more listens than Taylor swift while on Spotify Taylor Swift has 3x more than BTS
That is very different than what I would imagine the average American listens to.
I donate my data, but I don't think it has reached critical mass to be a good replacement for Spotify/last fms algorithm. That being said, I have enjoyed being a little more intentional with finding new music, but it is a lot more time consuming than what last FM or Spotify provide.
Keep using Spotify (if you must) but make sure to connect it to listenbrainz!
BTS fans are heavily botting listens on Listenbrainz, I guess they can't handle their favourite band not being on the top of the listening stats.
If you don't believe me just open any BTS album page and go to the profile of some of the users with most listens (they have hundreds of thousands listens each for any given album). You can see their listens flying by in real time. They have well over a thousand listens every day for months, some even have over 5k listens every day. It's impossible for it to be natural listens. If you listen to just 1 minute of 1000 songs that's over 16.5 hours of continuous music, every day.
I think it's very dependent on what you scrobble, I have never been recommended a 90's pop song in my 2+ years of using them.
I've never used Last.fm though so I can't compare how good their algorithm is
Need to export Last.FM, import to Libre.FM, run them in parallel, then let go of Last.FM
Whatever, I'm tired of scrobbling tracks for no reason. IDK why I've been giving my listen history to some faceless company for several decades now, for them to do god know what with, anyway... I only do it because it's what you do. It's what I've always done. I have no idea why.
wtf? i remember hearing they're now independent somewhat recently. turns out that was the beginning of enshittification..
Lol, just in time when I redid my Navidrome docker project with an added last.fm key yesterday 🤣
Anyone recommend an Android music player that supports Last.FM and Libre.FM?
I don't know one that has that integration built in but you can use pano scrobbler to scrobble music to any platform. it supports last.fm, listenbrainz, and libre.fm
Love lastfm. People don't understand this is what's needed since they're funded independently now.
all 64 comments