I mean what is up with this whole genre? It seems like a waste of time.

Terrible lore (an LLM could've done better) Difficulty of the sake of difficulty.

Hard games peaked with "I wanna be the guy" in 2007

all 33 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] 9 points 16 hours ago

I like the actual mechanics of a souls-like. Checkpoints, health recovery charges, parry mechanics are rad af. Recovering your loot from your corpse is hit or miss, if you're holding a lot of currency then it raises the tension, but if you died in an out-of-the-way place or a zone you're not really supposed to be in yet then it really sucks

I think the structure of environmental storytelling the Souls series use is neat because you can just ignore it if you want - after all the history of the world doesn't matter if you're just here to kill dudes - but if you're used to a traditional narrative then it can leave you feeling lost, especially if objectives are vague.

Your issues seem to be with the Souls franchise. Many others offer variable difficulty, and the lore is obviously subjective to whatever game you're looking at. You're obviously allowed to like what you like, but this sort of reads like someone hates action movies because they didn't like Die Hard

  • source
  • [–] 14 points 17 hours ago

    I hate souls likes

  • source
  • [–] 14 points 15 hours ago

    The simple answer is that different people like different styles of games. I've only ever played elden ring, and I didn't get very far, but the appeal is pretty clear. Some people really like getting a payoff for doing something really hard, others like the incremental process of getting better at something. Those are pretty normal feelings, I'm sure you feel that way about something. I personally sucked at Hollow Knight, but still enjoyed grinding the coliseum of fools, that was a more interesting process to me than grinding a souls boss.

    I do have to dissagree about the lore being bad though, that shit is peak.

  • source
  • [–] 14 points 15 hours ago

    Spoken like a true hollow.

  • source
  • [–] 5 points 13 hours ago (2 children)

    I felt similarly. Until I played Sekiro. Which is now my favorite game of all time.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 9 points 15 hours ago

    Getting good in these types of games is just being patient and paying attention.

    People aren’t completing no hit runs of all the games in sequence because they have some godly level of skill.

  • source
  • [–] 10 points 17 hours ago (4 children)

    I can explain this! Gaming has always been hard, at least since the NES. Games were hard because they had to be small (with the exception of, say, Final Fantasy), so most of your action/adventure games could honestly be run through in a few hours. The world record for Super Mario Bros. 1 is something like 4:54. That's minutes and seconds, and while, yes, it does utilise warp zones, it's pretty crazy. Games had to push back against the player to make you feel like you didn't waste your money.

    Super Nintendo games were a little easier as the market tried to balance. Nintendo 64 and especially PlayStation leaned into harder games — the former because Super NES games were easier, and PlayStation because it marketed itself toward more mature players.

    When Dark Souls came onto the scene, the iPhone accounted for a majority of gaming, and gaming was more like Subway Surfers, Temple Run, and Jetpack Joyride. Games that were free were only difficult enough to get you to spend money and no more. This environment is why FromSoftware decided to make their games so hard. No easy mode. Unforgiving enemies. Controls that weren't like other games, that made you learn their game as opposed to them conforming the controls, and ultimately most of the game, to what you expect. They forced you to get... er... "git gud" as the other commenter said.

    Dark Souls wasn't the first game to really be hard, though. Halo and Gears of War were offering plenty of challenge for those who asked for it. The difference was, Dark Souls only had its "hell hard" difficulty. They took away the option to play on easy, medium, or even hard. "This is our game and this is how it is meant to be played." For players who already took the highest difficulty option... well, it was still hard, because you had to learn their game system. Your reflexes from literally any other game would not help you. All that was by design.

    That said, I don't like them either. I'm not a kid with nothing to do but play video games. I work over 40 hours a week. I have other stuff to do. For most games, I put them on story mode. If they're good enough for a second go-round, I'll turn the difficulty up next time, so it's not a cake walk once I already know what to do and where to go. But it's not my default. Any game that leans Souls-like gets a pass from me. These aren't the kinds of games that interest me.

  • source
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] 8 points 16 hours ago (2 children)

    The Souls games aren’t even hard, they are challenging enough to be satisfying to me. I’ve only played DaS1-3 but they’re not nearly as time consuming as something like Path of Exile and they’re not as easy to mess up your build and necessitate a restart like PoE either.

    Fromsoft overhyped the difficulty in marketing DaS: Prepare to Die in order to appeal to a worldwide audience and that stuck around as a meme, like OP’s post imo 👀

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 15 hours ago

    That's a fair point. I never actually put that together.

    Ive played/beaten all the darksouls/demonsouls/elden ring game(s) and definitely "got good" but it was mostly just a challenge of learning each fight and preparing.

    Overall i couldnt of spent more than 1k hrs in them.

    PoE on the otherhand has several thousand hours of my time and it is by far a 'harder' game in a general sense of the word.

    You dont need quite as much reaction and control skill but do need a metric shit ton of general game knowledge unless you want to follow a guide.

    Learning enemy movesets is far easier than understanding wardloop for example. Or even just maintaining memory of the entire passive tree. Having the reaction time to execute on your memory is more challenging than being able to recall several build defining uniques and making a shell for a build when you see a new skill gem.

    Also i think people get defensive and prideful of dying and seeing it as losing. The only way you lose in a game with unlimited lives is by giving up, or deciding it's not worth your time. (And if you decide its not worth your time, then its not really losing since youre freeing yourself of it)

    Anyway uhhhh. the new league is fun

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 3 points 13 hours ago

    I like them and find them fun, but everyone has different tastes

  • source
  • [–] 5 points 12 hours ago

    Fromsoft couldn't tell a good story if the world depended on it

    Soulslike games are just metroidvania games but with somehow jankier combat.

    I enjoy some of them. Just so far nothing from Fromsoft.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 11 hours ago (1 child)

    I will try to explain from my own personal experience. As a disclaimer, nothing here should be taken as any attempt to be superior in any way. Hating on roguelikes and souls-style games is a-okay in my book - they're not for everyone.

    I look at these games as 'fun' in the same way as assembling a puzzle, building a gunpla model, or beating your best jogging time are also 'fun'.

    There are different gamer archetypes and I'm pretty clearly in the 'achiever' bracket. I like a tough challenge and the feeling of completion that comes from that. Meanwhile, I'm getting absolutely savaged by a piece of software that tests the limits of my patience, anger, and mental endurance. In fact, these games have actually helped me with controlling anger and frustration under duress; once I noticed I was playing consistently worse while flustered, everything started to change.

    At the same time, I absolutely see what FromSoftware is about. These games, going all the way back to Demon's Souls, have been messy, disjointed, cobbled-together affairs. Each game ships with experimental game mechanics, some that we still use today and some that never get revisited in future games. The art and regions are kinda smashed together into a kitbash world of wildly different zones, many with unfair platforming and environmental hazards. There are skill cliffs (e.g. "vigor checks") that are only surmountable with grinding or locating super-secret items. Then there's the "invasion" mechanics. Story-telling is at times brilliant, and other times "it do be like that" with hardly an explanation. And so on. Overall, it's less about a carefully balanced and cohesive world, and more about having just enough stuff in the game for the player to not consistently die on all the rough edges.

    The only thing that renders "fairness" is the almost complete lack of RNG in monster attacks, movements, and placement, yielding a predictability that can be learned and planned against. At the same time, it's cold comfort at best.

    So, these things are a absurdly challenging hot mess to play and I feel like I beat the odds whenever I eke out a victory. It's a little fucked up, but I kinda like it.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 9 points 16 hours ago (9 children)

    I despise the pretentious gatekeeping inherent with the design philosophy of "repeatedly banging your head against a brick wall is 'fun'".

    I have zero desire to "git gud", and anyone who offers such advice should be shot into the sun. Or grow up. One of the two. I'm an adult with a full time job and family. Games are to escape reality and have fun, and most of us adults already spend our days grinding through tedious repetitive tasks such that being asked to do so further as a form of entertainment is, to me, wildly aloof and the offer of prestige associated with completing it is disingenuous and repulsively predatory.

    At the very minimum, no game that excludes a portion of the gaming audience via an intentionally gross lack of accessibility should ever win any awards, with the possible exception of "biggest dev wankjob", least of all Game of the Year.

    Souls-like games and their respective developers can fuck right off.

    Other than that I have no strong feelings on the matter.

  • source
  • hideshow 9 child comments
  • [–] 7 points 13 hours ago

    I do not agree with your opinion because a good souls - like (Dark Souls being my personal favorite, the first one only) is, while being difficult, inherently fair and rewarding.

    Sure, when playing, I sometimes felt frustrated, but not with the game, but with myself. At each step, with each death, I could pinpoint my mistakes exactly, there was no denying where I messed up and what to improve, be it my timing, dodge roll, or parry - that made me pick the controller right up after growling and almost throwing it around.

    The game offers progression to me, the player, not only my character. My character can die from a mob in one of the early starting zones when I'm not careful, even in late game. This progression is felt and immensely rewarding.

    I absolutely understand that that's an investment, but that doesn't mean the game's concept and mechanics are shit. It just means it isn't for you right now - maybe never, and that's okay.

    Some of us had fun playing it though.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 11 points 14 hours ago (3 children)

    What an absolutely appalling take.

    It's perfectly fine and valid to not like this genre of game. But why would we ever want to discourage games based on "lack of accessibility", especially when there's clearly some audience that enjoys them?

    The industry already broadly tailors towards the lowest common denominator in pursuit of maximum profit. Why should we encourage it even more? Variety is a good thing, even if it means that not all games are for everyone.

    Do you hold the same accessibility standards for other forms of media?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 4 points 12 hours ago (2 children)

    How does adding easier difficulty levels (a broad norm for the medium) detract from the enjoyment of those who prefer the challenge?

    As regards other media, I don't see it as anything other than an apples and oranges situation. Games are by definition an interactive medium and bluntly telling people they're not allowed to experience it because they're simply not skilled enough is, in my eyes, disgusting. Books have audiobooks and braille offerings. TV and film have subtitles. But, crucially, those cater specifically to disabilities and their absence would not be considered a defiant middle finger to disabled people so much as a lack of resources to produce them. The same cannot be said for including difficulty levels in a triple A video game.

    Lack of difficulty levels is a deliberate design choice, not a byproduct of time and resource constraints. And I find it to be a conflaguratory looking down one's nose at people for nothing more than the sake of masturbatory false prestige.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 9 hours ago (1 child)

    As regards other media, I don’t see it as anything other than an apples and oranges situation.

    How do you feel about widely acclaimed books like Ulysses or Blood Meridian which are written in an intentionally unconventional and difficult format, where the difficulty of the prose is considered a defining feature of each piece?

    Lack of difficulty levels is a deliberate design choice

    Agreed. "Intentionally difficult" seems to be a valid design choice for other media. Why is it not so for games?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 3 points 12 hours ago* (last edited 7 hours ago)

    I have zero desire to "git gud", and anyone who offers such advice should be shot into the sun. Or grow up. One of the two. I'm an adult with a full time job and family. Games are to escape reality and have fun, and most of us adults already spend our days grinding through tedious repetitive tasks such that being asked to do so further as a form of entertainment is, to me, wildly aloof and the offer of prestige associated with completing it is disingenuous and repulsively predatory.

    I relate to most of this, a lot. I know someone who I used to enjoy playing games with. I stopped playing games much and got very casual when I do play. They shifted into a mode where if the game isn't comparable to an intense stressful full-time job, they're not interested. So it is now impossible to play anything we both like. They literally only like a game if it's hard/very time consuming AND they are good at it. If they lose one time they hate the game and quit. To me, the spirit of gaming should be the exact opposite of that. If you're angry and demanding of yourself to be a pro at all times, how the fuck is that fun? Like the whole thing is an exercise in self abuse imo. I just wanna play a game for an hour or two and be entertained. I never want to think I'm shitty at games for hours at a time. If the whole thing is about proving to yourself you don't suck, you missed the point. And yes I understand challenges being appealing. But if you've broken multiple controllers out of anger, either stop playing or shift into different games that aren't so stressful.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 3 points 13 hours ago

    Souls like games are all about timing and skill. It really is a git gud situation, even if you don't like it. There aren't really any major shortcuts to beating the games, a player just had to get in tune with the mechanics and the moves and timing of the enemies. When asking for help, I do agree if the response is 'git gud' that's dumb. There's always some level of advice that can be given, like different build options with their pros and cons, and things to watch for when learning the mechanics of a boss.

    I don't think that's any different from pretty much any competitive multiplayer games either. Rocket League, LoL, Dota, any racing game, etc. At the end of the day, it comes down to putting in the time and mastering the game.

    I personally like the challenge of should like, and on most single player game I turn the difficulty up so that it's not just a walk through. Maybe not the highest difficulty if failure is too punishing, but that's my preference.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 7 points 13 hours ago (1 child)

    You're a hypocrite. You think that games should be unavailable to everyone because you don't like to play them? You're using accessibility as a stalking horse to gatekeep people from playing games that they enjoy.

    Accessibility is about more games for more people. Some titles, by virtue of being accessible are going to exclude some players. For example games accessible to small children probably won't appeal to adults. Why should your stupid children have games that I don't like?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 2 points 12 hours ago

    I'm not quite sure how you came away with that interpretation? I'm not at all saying they shouldn't exist. I'm saying that eschewing the norm of built-in difficulty levels is pretentious and gatekeeping. Having difficulty levels makes the game accessible to a wider audience. If I'm reading you correctly, you seem to be conflating accessibility with exclusivity. I'm not making that argument.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 3 points 8 hours ago

    "Dark souls" is terrible and the name carries it so hard. "Game is so hard" no? more like the controls are dogshit and the game play and boss fights are worse than N64 games, seriously, boot up an N64 game and you will find your authentic dark souls experience (improved)

    and lore? what lore?

  • source
  • [–] [S] 1 point 13 hours ago

    To be fair to action movies, if you didn't like Die Hard, the other action movies should be entitled to tell you to F off haha.

  • source
  • [–] -1 points 17 hours ago
    [–] 1 point 6 hours ago

    Looks like you indeed, have an unpopular opinion. I agree with you, but dang look at the comments go! Well done

  • source
  • [–] -1 points 13 hours ago

    Skill issue.

  • source
  • [–] -2 points 12 hours ago

    The mechanical rigidity of Souls-like games are the appalling part as well as the appeal.

    The lore of Bloodborne is some of the best cosmic horror ever. Calling it terrible because you can't get beyond the introduction is a failing of the game and not the narrative. Be precise in your criticism because lashing out at all parts of a genre will ensure you are wrong and your perspective dismissed as angry ranting.

    Hard games are not for everyone. I have found cozy games to be my jam and look at those hard mode grinders as masochists. But they like to find pleasure in the pain. Again, what you find appalling another will find appealing. It's human nature.

  • source