Fucking hell. Why have a website anymore? Can we get a separate Internet where AI doesn’t exist?
post
Crawlers are a big fucking problem and we really didn't build the internet to accomodate them. Maybe if we said in 1990 "hey what if datacenters with Tbps connections will mass query all websites" we'd have a solution by now, but obviously that wasn't really an issue back then. Anubis seems great but proof of work to prove you are a human seems to have it's issues.
The solution is smarter secure mirroring for any static public content, stuff like Jekyll + Git or Atproto based sites. For dynamic content there's no universal solution against misbehaving data centers other than blocking them
Wait, can you expand more sbout Jekyll + git? Seems interessing but i can't find anything, also, why AT protocol instead of ActivityPub?
Activitypub suffer from virality, it doesn't offload. The original hosting server always gets pinged for every interaction. Meanwhile AT protocol is capable of simply acting like a series of pure mirrors so a self hosted PDS (account host) doesn't get tanked if you get flooded with replies and reposts and more, as the appviews does the job of indexing those responses and your client only need to look at the index (threads, like count, etc) it produced for you.
Jekyll simply creates and updates static HTML files. Git for version control. Multiple sites (including github pages) can natively publish that format of static files as a website.
Yeah, search engines used to enable us to look up stuff online.
You're gonna hate when you find HOW they generated their search data for your searching.
I liked it. I regularly have lots of niche problems and back in the day I'd just put it into Google and find someone on Reddit or whatever who already tackled it 2 years ago. Now I don't.
Also used to occasionally watch the web server logs and see how the search engines check for updates on the organization I'm volunteering at. Or index my employer's website. Or the Fediverse apps I run. And tweak my visibility according to my liking. Now that changed quite dramatically as well.
Or archive some of the stuff online for people with an attention span > 30s. Nowadays that constitutes "suspicious activity". While when I'm at the giving end, I get hammered by stupid AI crawlers. It's a shame.
(But I found a very good solution to the Cloudflare issue, if you're running web servers yourself: Don't use Cloudflare. It's as simple as that.)
Dear Tim Berners-Lee, Did you have a backup internet that the rest of us could use?
The Internet is not the World Wide Web. The Internet was over 20 years old when Tim invented Hypertext.
I mean, there's the Yiggdrasil network that IMO deserves much more attention than it gets, but it's not ai-proof, just obscure enough
all 27 comments