I obviously can't speak for audiences as a whole, but I feel like superhero movies need to go away for a while. You've been milking that cow as hard as possible for at least 20 years and I am sick and tired of milk at this point. It's not sexism because the main character is female, it's not that lesser known characters don't draw interest, it's not that you needed a more well known lead, it's not that movies are too expensive. Yes, all of those things probably contribute to this outcome in one way or another, but for me personally I just don't want to see the same movie for the 50th time.
post
I went in questioning whether a movie about a lesser known character set entirely on alien planets with pretty much just alien characters this early in a franchise could work. But then I experienced the poor story telling... They really did a shit job turning that story into a movie. What a let down.
Maybe, just maybe… you can have a non-ultimate character having their story and it doesn’t have to be the end all be all of gods and monsters… which also means maybe it’s not a billion dollar movie either.
And (hear me out) that’s okay.
You can be hurt, you can be upset, you can lose it all…
And that’s okay…? Not a crisis event?
Let's take a break from super hero movies for awhile. Pick another genre to run into the ground and we'll come back to these after a few years.
I think next up is westerns again or zombie movies again, it's all on a big carousel
Fallout is Western AND Zombies. So, yeah, that tracks.
And it's based on a video game, which seems to be the current trend.
New and fresh doesn't sell. The most brilliant body horror scifi work I'd seen in years, Scavenger's Reign, didn't even muster a second season.
I think the zombie theme is too fresh. I feel like it was only yesterday that everyone was talking about Walking Dead, so I guess it's time to remake the old spaghetti westerns. Hell, I'm surprised nobody already has remade The Good, The Bad, The Oxford Comma, and The Ugly.
I'm up for Firefly again and open to more space westerns.
Well they ARE doing Firefly again, but in animation form
I find that recent superhero movies expect you to understand the world context from the kajillion movies and books that came before it. So much time is spent showing something or someone on screen with ominous music that makes it clear that you should already know what this means or who it is. I don’t have 700 hours of superhero world research to do before watching a movie, and I have started to hate this genre because the movies are becoming barely comprehensible on their own.
It's not a loss. It's a tax writeoff.
That we want MORE superheroes, obviously
I'm actually OK with the Lego movies. My kids love them, and I find them quite entertaining.
Imo it helps that the Lego movies are pretty self-aware. Like they know they're Lego people and their entire existence is made up of Lego bricks that can be rebuilt and rearranged to make crazy cool stuff.
Is the movie any good though?
I think people are just tired of Superhero movies.
Obsession was a smash hit and that was a very female focused story 😀
Also, in October, Laika will release their newest stopmotiin film, Wildwood which will be a story about a girl, trying to save her baby brother from a weird fantasy world. I still haven't been able to sit through that trailer without bawling my eyes out. It fucks me up, dude. It's so beautiful. Please put a pin in this one for October! I genuinely think you won't regret this one.
Having seen it, I thought it was generic and the main plot very villain of the week. Backstory/flashbacks were decent. Based on what they were going for in the trailer... They needed to mix it up, my pitch: An R rating, let her crush some skulls. Let her not be Superman. Think Brightburn. Let her have an arc. Break some spines, accidentally and on purpose. show her having trouble controlling her new found powers on yellow star systems, laser people in half, not having to grow up on earth like Clark slowly learning to control his powers. Let her vent and pick fights in rough cesspools across the galaxy while binge drinking! :::spoiler That makes these Brigand folk, not just villains of the week, they're tougher, they can take a punch, they hurt Krypto::: and they're just what the doctor ordered, theyre cathartic... 😌💀🩸🩹
Yeah no, we don't need to turn every superhero movie into a gritty nolanverse-like
We need space for fun, for whimsy, for brightness
There aren't really any superhero movies like that outside of maybe Joker. I'd probably go watch something like The Boys or Invincible in theaters. Superman/woman/girl not so much. They're like the plain white bread of superheroes
Maybe don't spend over $100M on a movie?
I stopped watching MCU like 10 years ago; DC is whatever too. It's just formulated crap. What happened to art?
DC tends to be stronger on the TV side, like with Peacemaker, Young Justice, or (so I hear) My Adventures with Superman.
I didn’t see the supergirl movie because I knew she couldn’t possibly live up to DCAU supergirl.
…It’s still relative though. There’s a lot of DC TV junk (or junk food).
Why would I watch a DC movie only to have it reboot 5 years later and re-hash the same story again
DC flopped during Marvel's prime era because thew threw away what made DC media unique and tried to copy paste Marvel's style like an ad.
After MCU hit endgame, there really was no plan forward so Disney did what Disney does best and started chuking money at new movie ideas expecting it to rake in the same amount as before.
DC meanwhile did another reboot and ended up back at square one trying to copy any superhero genre film that succeded which led them nowhere.
This genre is effectively dead for the foreseeable future because neither studio tried to experiment with the formula outside of single hits which doesn't bring in enough money to satisfy the corporate overlords at Disney and WB.
They demand an output of several projects a year which is too high for creating something genuinely new.
Rest of Hollywood probably won't greenlight anything because of oversaturation, and the two comic book giants will continue to pump out slop in an a poor effort to maximize profits like they already did with every other franchise.
Lesson - do not adapt a loved story only to make it worse in every way. Why adapt on of the most beautiful colorful comics and make it only brown and gray?
For me, the main stream super hero genre ended with Logan.
I will still see the occasional Spiderman film as a treat. (Skipping this years Tom Holland one. Waiting for beyond the spiderverse.)
Good. I have had Superhero fatigue since 2010 and was not a fan when the MCU became a thing. Like goddammit, we JUST went through the 2000s super hero craze and now you're telling me we are going to suffer through a decade and a half MORE of cape-shit?? Wth
I hope marvel/Disney and DC and every other comic company that tries to milk this genre, keeps losing money on super hero movies. Just let that genre die and move on. The horse is pulverized at this point, but you keep beating it.
Please just listen to Christopher Nolan and Stephen Spielberg they know what they're talking about I assure you, they made some pretty decent movies I hear
Spielberg's latest is a massive pile of shite
I didn't see it, I just read several articles where I've heard him speak about the importance of imagination and wonder and I fully agree with all of it and putting the same schlock out year after fucking year is not imagination or wonder
I saw Disclosure Day.
I thought it was awful.
I freaking love complex, weird sci fi. I’m usually pretty optimistic about critically mixed movies, or “simple” ones like the He Man movie. He Man was fun!
But DD was so unoriginal and… boring. It was actively unfun, implausible on many levels yet taking itself so seriously. I could feel the writers’ massive egos from my seat; imagination and wonder have nothing to do with it.
I literally could not believe it got generally positive reviews.
I didn't either but the Pitch Meeting on it was pretty good.
I thought it was pretty good.
Disclosure Day Spoilers Below
Why, ok, why.... right, just one question, why.... I really can't work out... WHY. IF YOU HAVE A FUCKING. LIVE. ALIEN. WHY. DO YOU NEED ALL THE FUCKING VIDEOS?
WHAT WAS THE POINT OF ALL THE RUNNING AROUND? WHY? YOU HAVE A LIVE FUCKING ALIEN!!! JUST PUT THAT ON TELLY?!
Sorry. It was so mind numbingly dumb from start to finish.
more spoilers
The reveal wasn't just that aliens existed, it was also meant to show the government's abuse and mistreatment of the aliens.
And you may not necessarily want to livestream your only living specimen from an easily identifiable location while the entirely of the human race is processing the reveal. Religious extremists might not feel the same way about alien life as our sweet old nun did.
yet more spoilers
Eeeh, I mean, the main mission was definitely proving the existence of alien life.
Would you really ask these people to put their lives on the line just to prove that there was torture too? If they failed and Wardex took back all the footage they could still just roll ET out and get it to testify about the torture.
Nolanverse-like is what was fucking DC already though, trying to force squares into round holes.
Making superman edgy AF cost them millions, cause that's not what he is, he's a bright beacon of hope, he's a boy scout
all 10 comments