you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

I could be wrong but I think you've misread it. In context they're saying it's crazy to exclude a microwaved caesar salad (the section about hot vs cold). I.e they think a microwaved salad SHOULD be included.

Now realistically what I assume they meant was microwaving the chicken before putting it in the caesar shouldn't make it not a salad (fair enough) but it's not what they actually said.

Edit to paste in the full section

"This is actually a pretty strange definition. It includes things like a plate of mixed nuts, but excludes a caesar salad which you stuck in the microwave for two minutes.

While people might object to serving a hot salad, it certainly seems bizarre and objectionable to exclude it from the definition simply based on temperature.

We conclude that this definition does not meet the necessary rigor for a proper salad definition, "

  • source
  • parent