Like what happens if you agree to CNC, everything is going as planned, but you randomly have something unrelated go wrong like you tear a muscle or have a heart attack? Are you meant to have a clause that says “No safewords, unless I say something is medically wrong”? Isn’t that just reinventing safewords?
If you notice a medical concern you point it out and your top will correct it to the extend that they deem appropriate; it doesn’t end the scene however. So no, this isn’t reinventing safeword, because you generally can’t use them to get out overall.
And yes, this isn’t fully safe. But nothing ever is truly safe, you always have risks, no matter what you, the question is just what level of risk is acceptable to you.These kinds of scenes come with a higher level of risk. But frankly: I’d rather have a heart-attack in a scene like this where there is another person that can call an ambulance, than when I’m alone. Because it turns out that a good domme doesn’t want her sub to die and will do what it takes to protect them, possibly even ending the scene, but that is then her decision, not mine.
Or what if there is a sincere misunderstanding of boundaries?
That is a risk that you have to be willing to accept if you want to play on this level. The entire point of this kind of play is that it allows you to meaningfully play outside of your comfort zone. Is that a risk? Sure, which is why this is not something you should teach in a “101 course” that has to start with what consent is.
A true inability to stop is rape in my eyes.
Thank you for telling me that the scene that I longingly think back to on a more than weekly basis, that was probably the best scene I had in my entire life, was a case of me being raped, rather than amazing fun. (And yes, there were moments in that scene were I really didn’t want to continue and they are wonderful to look back to!) And thank you for calling one of my closest friends, a person who in some ways understands me better than anyone else, a rapist for doing to me what I asked her to do me.
BTW: Are people who run thrill-rides at fairs where the safety-mechanisms physically prevent you from leaving the ride and where you can’t stop the ride as it is ongoing also rapists? Because they for all intents and purposes engage in CNC bondage as well? And if not, can you please explain to me why that is different? There is no technical reason why they couldn’t give everyone an emergency-stop button that, if pressed, will bring the right to an end as quickly as safely possible, allowing you to get out quickly if you change your mind…