Either. A router just for devices(1) to be totally denied Internet access is likely the cheapest way to go, but beware devices that demand talking to their mothership like the most recent Roku ones and there will be more noise impacting your real network. Routers that can allow association but not Internet access to specific devices are more expensive or require more effort (e.g., installing ddwrt).
(1) Actually MAC addresses, which can be spoofed and some devices might periodically change to one randomly generated. The former to intentionally avoid blocks while the latter might be to enhance privacy that might also "happen" to avoid blocks.