It only took them 13 years to make a game that discards the essence of the franchise
It could be an interesting system, but from the outside it doesn't look like good game design. Imagine playing the first mission like it's literally any other GTA game, and then getting permanently stuck on hard mode and a bad ending. Or you're in a high speed chase from the cops (kinda what the game is about) and a pedestrian comes out from nowhere and kills themself, lowering your social credit score and locking you to the bad ending after you're like 20 hours into the game
Also the harder difficulty giving the bad ending feels wrong too, it's like heaping a punishment on top of a punishment. Challenge should be rewarded, although I'm not following the game so maybe the real challenge is playing through without anyone witnessing your crimes.
Thematically though, the bad ending is justified for pretty much any GTA. In all of them you play terrible people