He means virtue-washing. You dilute a reasonable conviction (eg. There are no good Billionaires) by confusing the issue with their good decisions. Virtue and vice aren't fungible. If you're a good father, that doesn't mean you're not also a cold blooded murderer. Ask Martin Luther how he felt about paying for wicked indulgences by giving money to charity and the church.
"Emotional gerrymandering" is an awkward way to phrase it, but I can see where OP was going with it