Did you change thoughts or start anew?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 2 points 2 days ago* (last edited 1 day ago) (2 children)

Islam, for example, is pretty clear that someone who was raised Hindu, and just never converted, always goes straight to jahannam on the day of judgement. Not even the prophet's intercession can save them.

Catholicism is a bit more nuanced. Basically, it's easy to commit mortal sins, and it only takes one mortal sin to at least send you to purgatory, unless you become a practicing catholic. Modern evangelicals, of all kinds, agree with the Muslims. Some non-Abrahamic faiths have some kind of punishment for nonbelievers, as well, although it might just be a little bit of bad karma that comes out in your next life.

There's other schools of Christianity that are closer to what you're talking about, and, while Judaism is clear god has a favourite, the whole family is "in the will". Both of those groups are smaller, at least as formally practiced, though.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 0 points 2 days ago* (1 child)

    What is conversion? If you live by God's standards as delineated in the Qur'an, how far away are you from being a believer, even if you had some emotional and/or intellectual difficulties understanding/believing in God. Would you consider a person who claims to be Muslim, and even goes to the mosque and is called something like Abdirrahim but acts like Hell doesn't exist and transgresses God's limits carelessly and happily more of a believer than someone who calls themselves an atheist but "walks the narrow road" because it's the right thing to do? Would God? You think the mentally restricted, culturally "whimsical" and somewhat unserious, and now old Western grandma who has actually really tried to be a good person (because it feels like the right thing to do) and has put the needs of others before her own constantly is just condemned to Hell because she never really got too analytical with Scripture (maybe just enough to be a casual "Abrahamic polytheist" and no more than that, and stayed sorta ideologically confused whilst still feeling and knowing being righteous and prosocial is the right thing to do)?

    I'm Muslim, I've read the Qur'an head to toe, the mercy of God and how "those who believe in God and do good deeds" have nothing to worry about is repeated constantly. And I tell you, whatever their mouths say and whatever they might think they think, whoever does the Lord's work is more of a believer than whoever doesn't, regardless of what they say, and vice versa (Hegseth, Trump, some crown princes, millionaire preachers etc etc all fit this category). I'm just smart enough (thank God) to understand that many people's so called ideologies are nothing more than superficial, shaky conjecture and the result of hurt feelings that weren't properly analysed. Because I was there too, I'm just quicker so now I'm here and waiting for the rest, hoping and helping so they don't get lost in the way. So, if I can see it, I'm certain God sees it too.

    Idk that much about Trinitarian faiths or else I would comment on them, sorry. And thank you for the comment!

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 2 hours ago* (last edited 1 hour ago)

    If they're raised Hindu, we're talking shirk, not just the wrong version of monotheism. I guess you could still say, Allah wouldn't damn them, because a benevolent god wouldn't. And that's true, but "being nice makes you a Muslim" it's a pretty non-standard take on the theology.

    So, I guess, salaam, brother? (Hey, I try to be good, I think I do a decent job, and so do the people in my life)

  • source
  • parent