No problem! I know nowadays it can be hard to find information on the subject, especially with all the misinformation and demonisation of trans people in the media. Some people may get a bit defensive and assume the worst when someone says slightly off when it may just be a misunderstanding, but it's usually just a defensive position due to how often we can get transphobia unfortunately - but I always try to assume someone could just not have all the info and is willing to listen and I'll always assume that until they prove me otherwise! :)
I believe, it is de facto a condition to have a medical record about trans-adjacent pathology to be recognised as trans (= juridically + rights to have treatments). My belief could be wrong though
In the past, that may have been the case, but that would have been decades ago. In the DSM-4 (the DSM being the international mental health manual used for healthcare), it was unfortunately categorised as "Gender Identity Disorder" which did pathologies being trans. That was changed in DSM-5 to only be "Gender Dysphoria" to move the focus away from pathologising the trans identity, and instead only focus on the distress that some can get so that support can be given medically.
I can't speak for other countries as a whole, but it usually is, or at least should be, recorded as Gender Dysphoria in medical records, not being trans. Which is why the distinction between the two is very important.
especially, if it becomes more about supporting something positive like gender euphoria, because no fun is allowed. I mean, if there is a trans person with no dysphoria wanting HRT, would an average tax-payer accept to pay for that even with an unlikely possibility and minuscule cost? I'm afraid not, but maybe I'm just pessimistic.
This unfortunately comes down to a misunderstanding as well, which likely is common for most people. I don't necessarily blame anyone for that either - a lot of it boils down to not really knowing how dysphoria can feel like or how it can affect them (until it sometimes does, even in cis people)
I will say that I'm not taking on the behalf of all trans people, but I would personally say, that if someone is wanting HRT, they highly likely do have some degree of Dysphoria. Gender Euphoria with trans people usually does stem from that dysphoria, but everyone's brain is complex. Some people heavily suppress their dysphoria from a young age without realising it, if that is due to other trauma, or it being masked by other mental health conditions or any other possible reason, only to them later on stumble upon that suppressed part of themselves later when they unravel it
I will add that I'm not suggesting anyone who gets Euphoria is necessary trans, that's for individuals to figure out decide for themselves. Cis people can also get euphoria, as can cis Gender-nonconforming!
So going to your point there, if someone is wanting to go further than just how they're presenting, and want to go down the HRT path that will cause changes to their body, they highly likely do have some form of dysphoria already as they're actively trying to address it with HRT. Someone isn't going to want to take HRT if they're already comfortable with their body if (for example with feminising HRT) HRT would cause them to grow breasts. That would cause conflict between the body and what the brain is expecting, and cause Dysphoria (which unfortunately is what we have to deal with as trans people, via puberty. The body going a different direction to what our brain expects). Cis men usually don't want to grow breasts, cis women don't usually want to grow thicker facial and body hair or have their voice drop. That's why when some cis men, for example, grow breasts (gynecomastia) it causes them distress and they can get medical help to remove them... That is one example of a cis person getting dysphoria, and receiving gender-affirming care to fix it.
If someone wants to go take HRT, then they are trying to address something with their body that the mind currently finds uncomfortable and causing distress
As far as I've understood, there are some trans people that would want the HRT even without the dysphoria (or the diagnosis). That's why I was thinking that maybe the public (transmeds?) might want to keep the diagnosis (or some other medical process) as a gatekeeping condition for HRT. Obviously, they have many other reasons too.
Not 100%. (This may take a bit of an explanation, sorry!) I would agree some do pursue HRT without a diagnosis (for example DIY HRT - which despite what "DIY" might suggest, it just means sourcing the meds from the labs yourself rather than via prescription :) which in most countries is usually legal to do, but always with checking before they do), but imo that is more a symptom of a healthcare system severely failing trans people rather than an issue of the diagnosis. Look at my previous UK example - when it takes nearly 1-2 decades for a trans person to get through the waitlist to finally get an assessment for dysphoria so they can finally get HRT through the public healthcare, that's a further quarter of our life forced to deal with the dysphoria and any further changes the body goes through during that time. So it makes sense that some will pursue HRT without a diagnosis because getting a diagnosis is like walking on hot stones for the next decade.
Imagine if a person with depression had to wait a decade before they could get a formal diagnosis and anti-depressants. They know they're depressed, and yet can't get formal help... I imagine there would be more self-medicating if that was the case. I use depression as an example because Dysphoria can cause depressive symptoms.
This wouldn't be a problem if the system fixed the issues with the process of getting an assessment. I would still argue though that it should be more of an "Informed Consent" model that exists for other medication (you are made aware of exactly what the effects will be via the doctor, any possible side effects etc, then you are free to give consent that you want the meds). As trans people, we shouldn't need to have to convince another person that we're trans for access to our own healthcare.
There are also some people who are trans, and decide they don't want HRT. This could be for many possible reasons. They could have been lucky in the genetic lottery and already have a body that tilts towards their gender (like, they could appear more feminine/masculine without hrt) and just decide they're happy with that, and just need to social transition etc. They could be a Gender Non-conforming trans person. They could be Non-Binary (enby), which falls under the trans umbrella. But with how enby identities can differ, some may just prefer social transition etc (though there are also many of us that do want and need hrt too!).
That's another reason why there is a very important distinction between being Trans and having Gender Dysphoria in a medical sense.
As for Transmeds, they are a very fringe and small part of the trans community that are a bit more exclusionary. And annoyingly, transmeds (knowingly or not) are effectively trying to re-pathologies being Trans). They can differ in severity of views between individuals, but they can usually fall under a few or more points:
- Believing that someone isn't trans until they're on HRT or have surgery (see my issue with the healthcare system as a whole, as to how much of an issue this can be). It is worth noting a lot of transmeds are also pro-DIY HRT alongside most trans people as a whole... transmeds just don't seem to understand that DIY isn't necessarily an option for some people depending on circumstances, but that doesn't make someone suddenly not trans.
- Usually hate Non-binary people... because enbies don't fit in the neat boxes transmeds believe in, despite enby people experiencing dysphoria as well.
- I've come across one or two myself that even try to exclude other binary trans people who have dysphoria, only believing significant dysphoria should count, as if it's measurable... ("Help for me, not for you") Transmeds are really just a smaller group of people that are trying to exclude a significant amount of other trans people from the community and separate them from the healthcare they otherwise need.
And with all of this said ^ (bit of a read again, sorry haha), I don't think it really should be down to what the average person in the public thinks anyways.
And yes, tax payers are paying towards it, but it should also be worth acknowledging that trans people are also tax payers. My taxes are being put towards other people's healthcare, for procedures I may never need, and I'm still happy for that. I don't need to know what someone is getting in their healthcare, nor should I have a say in if they should be allowed it, it's not my business. So for fairness, our taxes should also be put towards our healthcare as well. We shouldn't be made to pay into a service that then excludes us. We all should pay in, and have access to the care we need. Healthcare shouldn't be at the everchanging whims of public opinion. Imagine if a heavily funded campaign happened against anti-depressants, would it be acceptable to take away anti-depressants from public healthcare because of a shifted public opinion?
The average person isn't and shouldn't be aware of what meds someone else is on. There's a reason medical records are confidential. I didn't have to announce to the world and get permission from the average member of the public before I started ADHD meds. It was, and should be, a conversation only between me and my doctor, and no one else. As should everyone's healthcare.