Thank you for your patience. Nowadays I have trans friends and try to understand what these issues and their current discourse are all about. I've studied social sciences and gender research at uni, but I've also grew up in a small town were trans people never were a thing. (Also, I'm a bit gender non-conforming myself, but avoid definitions, because I cannot trust capability of people to understand my idiosyncratic views.) Anyway, there's still a lot to unpack. Most of the misunderstandings here might be caused by my careless way of interchangeably write about my thoughts, speculations about the public opinion, the institutions and so on. I try address a few points:
But it’s important to recognise that even to this day, being trans is not considered a mental illness.
Yes. I've seen some people (although usually bigoted ones) thinking like that, but not sure how common it is. Research might be analytical enough to see them separate, but I wonder what is the reality in clinical settings. I believe, it is de facto a condition to have a medical record about trans-adjacent pathology to be recognised as trans (= juridically + rights to have treatments). My belief could be wrong though.
I don’t see why the public could reasonably accept the suggestion that treating Dysphoria is cosmetic while we’d for obvious reasons not take seriously someone who’s suggesting the same for conditions like ADHD/depression. Other than for the intention of restricting individual bodily autonomy for a targeted minority :p
Yeah, my cynic reasoning was pretty much that average people don't have reasonable views about minority issues—especially, if it becomes more about supporting something positive like gender euphoria, because no fun is allowed. I mean, if there is a trans person with no dysphoria wanting HRT, would an average tax-payer accept to pay for that even with an unlikely possibility and minuscule cost? I'm afraid not, but maybe I'm just pessimistic.
Also, seeing HRT as the treatment for dysphoria is not a transmed position in any way. It’s actually widely agreed and accepted by the vast majority of trans people. I’d be surprised to find a trans person who didn’t agree with that.
As far as I've understood, there are some trans people that would want the HRT even without the dysphoria (or the diagnosis). That's why I was thinking that maybe the public (transmeds?) might want to keep the diagnosis (or some other medical process) as a gatekeeping condition for HRT. Obviously, they have many other reasons too.
And yeah, more funding to healthcare would probably be optimal pretty much everywhere. I've waited years in queues just for the basic mental issues (depression & co) alone.