It's below freezing!

This post is for casual conversation if you don’t feel like making a post of your own.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 1 point 2 days ago* (1 child)

They didn't directly administer an ADHD scale at all, and they really just focused in on the last two weeks, and gave me a PHQ-9.

I am not trying to invalidate anything you are saying, but even for the ADHD tests a lot of it is "In the last two weeks have you..." Just mentioning so you can be prepared and not feel that is them just fucking it up. You can see a lot of the common tests (autism and ADHD) on this website (which some people consider problematic for some of their practices, but it's still a handy collection): https://embrace-autism.com/autism-tests/

Like imagine a psychiatrist saying, "So we administered the test and it says you are very depressed." And the patient says, "Yes, ever since my entire family was mudered in front of me last week, I have been feeling rather glum. It's also hard because I am living on the street and the police shredded my tent two nights ago and I keep getting attacked by a schizophrenic guy that is convinced I'm a spy for the world government." And the psychiatrist responds, "Well, with your PHQ-9 score, I'd recommend starting you on Prozac."

Lol I get it. I was diagnosed with and the undiagnosed with Bipolar II in the range of two years almost 20 years ago. On an intellectual level I can get why. I was super depressed because of ongoing abuse and I can see why autistic joy can be misinterpreted as hypomania. But if you decide I'm not bipolar and you just shrug it off? (Or tell me that maybe it's borderline personality disorder) That feels fucked up. I had been inpatient twice at this point so it's clear it wasn't something that was going to just fix itself.

I mean, I'd get it if these people were working at walmart out of high school, but I just can't accept that this is the cream of the social crop, the people that studied the hardest for the greatest reward of working society--becoming a doctor.

If I can share my perspective: I think we as a society put too much expectation of perfection on certain professions. Doctors are just people. They should be thorough and I totally agree you are being failed by your doctors! But I think we need to accept that they are just as flawed as the rest of us.

Working as an engineer for almost 15 years has kind of reinforced that lol. Very few people are really certain about what they are doing and I think the people who feel very confident that they know exactly that to do are the most dangerous. I have a few credentials that give me authority to do certain work but my education level is just bachelor. I used to feel self conscious about that but after a few years of working with people with Ph.Ds I stopped lol. Not that they aren't (mostly) excellent engineers and that getting a Ph.D isn't hard. But it's indication of a high level of mastery in a small realm, not being really good at the field as a whole or even having common sense. I had one guy constantly talk down to me about why I was refusing to let him solve a problem for me (I just kept saying, "No thanks, that's not a problem we have! 😊😊😊" ) because clearly I didn't understand his genius. So I eventually got sick of it and invited him to tour the facility he was offering to optimize. He pretty quickly saw he had no fucking clue what he was talking about and left me alone after that.

I also draw a parallel between the way a physicist might simplify a complex object as a sphere in order to make broad generalizations and the way general medical practice or even psychiatry is performed. It's generally not good enough to make detailed conclusions about an individual but it might work on a population level. More care needs to be applied to the individual case.

On top of that, we've made them the gatekeepers of our entire system and given them such great responsibility, but they are so bone-crunchingly stupid I just can't process it. And the cherry on top of the cake is that this is the system that has decided I'm not qualified to work within it.

Yes this is bullshit and I'm sorry you have experienced it. I'll spare you my rant but self-regulation has a lot of problems and I say this as someone in a self regulated profession too.

The ADHD meds are there to help me develop some job skills, the psych evals are there to help me apply for disability, and my neurodviergent therapist is there to help me with my emotions. i think I'm on a good track, but a long road.

Good luck with everything! Do you have access to occupational therapy? I only bring it up because the meds did not really help with skills for me. They made existing easier but there is a huge gap between that and learning actual skills to adapt life (including work) to my abilities. I used an OT to develop the list of accommodations because if I just look at a list of the common ones I'm just like "nah I don't need that!" but I still don't fully understand the mechanism behind my struggles so it's really hard to see how they can help and more broadly what else I can do to help. Two things I would have never done but make a tremendous difference (very personalized, not suggesting this for you):

  • using the windows colour overlay to make my monitor not hurt to look at all the time.I thought that was just what monitors felt like and why we are encouraged to take breaks, and I already have blue light filtering lenses in my glasses.
  • my primary care person "prescribed" that my husband ignore me for the first 30 mins after I get home from work to make the transition easier for me and to take the edge off being perceived. He's 100% on board and this addresses the fact that I am not even aware that I'm getting overwhelmed and am therefore unusually sensitive. It prevents hurt feelings (imagine greeting your spouse and having them burst out crying) and takes care of my needs at the same time.
  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • I admire your general contempt for humanity, but I think you're doing a disservice to psychology/psychiatry for not singling it out for harsher treatment. It really has no effective accountability like engineering does. A building collapses, you find a reason. A plane falls out of the sky, you find out why and fix it so it doesn't happen. With psych, your patient doesn't get better and you don't really know why, but when they do get better, of course you take the credit. It's not really a science. And because it's not really a science, it really depends on parading itself as a science and being exactly the kind of overconfident engineer you think do the most harm, because an accurate reading of the research behind therapy and psychiatry would be absolutely devastating to the social status of the profession which currently has a monopoly on treating Life.

    One example was that after years of medication treating me for bipolar, my psychiatrist asked if I'd ever had a manic episode absent being on anti-depressants. I said no. She said, oh, well, then you probably don't have bipolar, then, your mania was likely triggered by the anti-depressants. Cool, said I, then I can go off the meds. Absolutely not!, was her reply.

    A few short months later she said, "The meds clearly aren't working and we've tried the ones that would work. I think it's time to consider a trial of electrconvulsive therapy." And I said, "Ok, so I can go of the meds, now, then?" Absolutely not!, was her reply.

    So here I was taking meds for a disorder I did not have which were working so poorly that she was recommending a treatment that causes permanent brain damage, and she still insisted I be on the meds? And she was the head psychiatrist of the clinic.

    My perspective is the opposite of yours: I only got better when I walked away from the psych establishment. By insisting I was bipolar, by insisting that I needed to fix my mood, it was pulling into me a cycle of despair that I could not get away from any more than I could get away from my unrecognized neurodivergency.

    Re: OT. I don't think I have anything accomodations can take care of. Like I've told you before, my problem is that I have no real job skills, so I'm just kinda stuck with the same jobs that any NT slob can do, jobs where pleasing the boss and the customers comes first, and not making little mistakes of attention come second. My autism sinks me on the first score, my ADHD on the second.

  • source
  • parent