Saw this on women's stuff and didn't wanna engage cause that space isnt for me, but felt like this was a 10/10 post and wanted more people to see and think about it!

Feel free to cross post if you can think of broader communities where more people would be able to see it, this is just the comm that came to mind :)

Visualise Our Social Environments
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 1 point 1 week ago (2 children)

I see. I wonder how much of that can be attributed to youthful folly. A sheltered twenty year old entering the real world for the first time, and eager prove himself to be a good person, tends to be somewhat overzealous on the principles instilled in him from his youth.

It can even look hammy, cheesy, or clumsy. But if we discourage that with a verbal thump on the head, the lesson he's likely to learn isn't "I should be more humble, and do what's right because it's right and not for credit or validation," but rather "Oh, I'm not supposed to do this, so I should stop trying."

I'm not saying we shouldn't make corrections, but we should correct gently and intelligently, explaining better what was wrong about it and how to do it better, not simply leaving it up to their imaginations to figure it out.

Young men lack quality mentorship. It takes a village, you know. And maybe it's time we realize that we need to be a part of that village if we want to see society and our communities improve.

If someone in their thirties or forties still acts like that though, then barring any mitigating circumstances such as developmental disorders, trauma, failure to integrate socially, etc., which may be remediable, then they may be hopeless and I don't suggest that we should waste our energy on those.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 1 week ago (1 child)
  • [–] 1 point 1 week ago* (last edited 1 week ago)

    To put it succinctly, yeah, that's basically the idea.

    Although it isn't always easy in practice, because by nature it's always context-dependent, and there's no hard-coded rationale or logic tree behind it, just a well-tuned intuitive finesse (when it's done well, at least; and some awkward/painful learning moments when it's done poorly).

    But since upaya takes place on the level of conventional reality, knowing one's audience is a prerequisite, and it can lead to some awkward misunderstandings when applied across cultural barriers. Which is why it requires a keen perceptiveness to pull off (i.e. active listening).

  • source
  • parent