If a person learned science and created yourself a certain reputation, then you are an expert. If you encounter a random stranger who did their own research, you should be very careful with any claims they make. That doesn't mean that the strangers are necessarily wrong just because they don't have a PhD or thousands of publications. But as long as you don't have the necessary expertise yourself, they are an untrusted source of information. And if the information is controversial, it's highly likely to be wrong.
During COVID we could vividly see what happens if people self-promote themselves to be health experts and if others followed and multiplicated their advice.