Science thrives on questioning

Science is not a fixed set of truths; it is a process of continuous inquiry. Every landmark shift in medicine, from handwashing to randomized controlled clinical trials, began with someone daring to challenge accepted wisdom.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [S] 1 point 4 months ago* (6 children)

It’s not healthy for the individual

Great, you have scientific backing for this position? I can provide a few counter examples from pre-westernized populations.

desaster for the health of our planet.

Wait.... this is EXACTLY what the article was talking about...

My comment is not about the author of the article,

So yes, you are talking about the article - I suggest you read it.

Update - honoring your opinion it's stupid for people to read the literature and thus you can't provide any scientific backing for your position (as that would be stupid by your own words), allow me to give you a authority who summarizes the literature - https://doi.org/10.1093/af/vfy009

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 6 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 4 months ago (5 children)

    Where do the linked articles promote a carnivore diet? One questions high-carb and purely plant based diets (mainly for specific, rather poor regions of the world where people face malnutrition) and the other is about the role of meat in a healthy diet, not about a diet that's only meat.

    Wikipedia summarizes it quite nicely:

    The carnivore diet is associated with pseudoscientific health claims. The diet lacks dietary fiber, can lead to deficiencies of vitamins, and can increase the risk of chronic diseases.

    If you think your sources can convince the other authors and lead to a different consensus, feel free to update the article with the reapective proofs.

    But as said: my main concern is not about the individual health of someone following that diet. You can do with your body whatever you want and there are plenty of other ways to do harm to it. My main concern is about the impact of the animal industry on climate.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago* (4 children)

    Where do the linked articles promote a carnivore diet?

    The article this post is about is about how science isn't settled. Each post has a different topic and theme.

    One questions high-carb and purely plant based diets (mainly for specific, rather poor regions of the world where people face malnutrition) and the other is about the role of meat in a healthy diet, not about a diet that’s only meat.

    You were saying meat isn't health earlier.

    Wikipedia summarizes it quite nicely:

    The carnivore diet is associated with pseudoscientific health claims. The diet lacks dietary fiber, can lead to deficiencies of vitamins, and can increase the risk of chronic diseases.

    Wikipedia are not medical experts, by your own argument in the first message, it would be stupid to take their advice.

    My main concern is about the impact of the animal industry on climate.

    Ruminants have existed since before farming - they are part of the natural biocycle.

    cows are not eco terrorists

    The industrial agricultural model is not sustainable both for mono-cropping and animals. We need to move to sustainable agriculture, with no fossil fuel inputs. Ruminants are necessary part of sustainable soil redevelopment.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 4 months ago (3 children)

    You were saying meat isn't health earlier

    Meat can be part of a healthy diet. Meat is not a prerequisite for a healthy diet. There is strong evidence that certain forms of meat are unhealthy. Especially for large quantities of red meat and processed meat due to nitrosamines. It's fine for me if scientists question these points and peform further research, but until the respective counter-studies are performed and reviewed, I'd rather stick to what's consensus. And that means limiting your meat intake, especially in the two areas mentioned.

    The industrial agricultural model is not sustainable

    Great, something we can agree on. Without industrial production of meat, meat will become a scarce ressource. Something that most people will be unable to afford, let alone to base their entire nutrition on. So even it carnivore diets were super healthy (which they aren't!) they are still a bad idea.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago* (2 children)

    Meat can be part of a healthy diet. Meat is not a prerequisite for a healthy diet.

    I actually agree on both points. I've waxed poetic on this before - https://discuss.online/post/25952420 . There are many ways to be healthy.

    here is strong evidence that certain forms of meat are unhealthy. Especially for large quantities of red meat and processed meat due to nitrosamines.

    That evidence doesn't stand up to scrutiny, per the meat in a healthy diet expert opinion I supplied earlier.

    I’d rather stick to what’s consensus.

    By all means, if your perfectly healthy, keep doing what your doing!

    And that means limiting your meat intake, especially in the two areas mentioned.

    This advice is not supported by strong evidence (non-observational) and doesn't represent consensus. It's fine for you to run your life, but your opinion isn't sufficient to compel others - As you said you don't mind us here eating meat, so we should be bygones. As you indicated in your first message it would be stupid for people to extrapolate health advice on their own, and doubly stupid to take advice from other lay people. So your proffered opinion by your own words.......

    So even it carnivore diets were super healthy (which they aren’t!) they are still a bad idea.

    You don't have data to support your position, and even expert opinion you can provide will not be informed on a zero-carb population it will be people extrapolating from FFQs on a high carb population.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 4 months ago* (1 child)

    How about this one?

    https://www.bhf.org.uk/informationsupport/heart-matters-magazine/news/behind-the-headlines/carnivore-diet

    It clearly mentions that there is just one (!) single study on the carnivorous diet which has an extreme bias as it only interviewed people (observational!) who sticked to the diet and ignored all the quitters.

    But to repeat myself: your body is yours, you can do to it whatever you want. It's the planet I care about. The planet is ours and therefore I really hope that this diet just disappears again into nowhere.

    From an outsider perspective your community is promoting a unsustainable habit. It's similar as if you advised to use planes and helicopters as your sole way of transport and disregard everything else while the clear consensus is that the usage has to be decreased rather than increased.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 1 point 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago)

    How about this one?

    This article doesn't have a author, and feels LLM generated. So by your earlier criteria it would be ........... etc etc

    Why are you trying to convince me? I'm not trying to convince you. I thought you agreed meat was healthy and we could let each other be bygones.

    It clearly mentions that there is just one (!) single study on the carnivorous diet which has an extreme bias as it only interviewed people (observational!) who sticked to the diet and ignored all the quitters.

    The LLM article isn't up to date, there are far more than one.

    But to repeat myself: your body is yours, you can do to it whatever you want. It’s the planet I care about. The planet is ours and therefore I really hope that this diet just disappears again into nowhere.

    Cool! Thanks for sharing that, i hope the same for your diet and philosophy.

    From an outsider perspective your community is promoting a unsustainable habit.

    Health is a requirement for people, giving people tools to be healthy should never be considered unsustainable.

    What are you trying to achieve here? I gather your a philosophical non-meat eater, how can we reconcile a philosophical position with papers? I'm simply not going to accept the position that ruminants are not part of the natural biocycle.

    Update - Clearly you have a conclusion in mind, and you are trying to find support for your conclusion, that is why you ended up citing a LLM "article" that reinforced your biases. That isn't how science works, that isn't how constructive conversations work, and it really isn't participating in good faith. I just am illustrating that you are driven by a philosophical end point and your trying to back track, which makes this discussion irreconcilable.

  • source
  • parent