Dr Michael Greger is the Physician, bestselling author, and speaker who advocates a plant-based, whole foods diet to reverse and prevent, fatal disease and illness.

He is a graduate of Cornell University and the Tufts University School of Medicine, and his New York Times bestselling book “How Not To Die” examines the fifteen top causes of death in America.

He has appeared in numerous documentary films including “What The Health”, “Prescription: Nutrition” and “Eating you Alive.”

Michael Greger’s website, nutritionfacts.org, has thousands of videos giving research-based advice, about specific foods and health-related issues.

transcriptInterviewer: On the low-fat diets you are talking about right now, what about Jordan Peterson? I know Dr. Jordan Peterson is on the carnivore diet, and I know his daughter feels a lot better on it. Some people swear by it. What do you think is happening there?

Dr. Gregor: I don't know.

Dr. Gregor: Some people feel better when they eliminate foods they are reacting to. Someone who has a wheat allergy may go gluten-free and feel better. That does not mean gluten-free is the answer for everyone.

Dr. Gregor: The same thing can happen with soy. Someone may have an undiagnosed soy allergy, start eating veggie burgers, feel terrible, then stop eating soy and feel better. They may think the benefit came from eating meat again, but it may have come from removing the food that was bothering them.

Dr. Gregor: If someone cuts down to a very narrow diet, they may remove whatever was causing the problem. If instead of a carnivore diet they tried a sweet-potato-only diet, they might feel just as good, because they removed the same offending foods.

Interviewer: So the benefit may be from elimination, not from the meat itself?

Dr. Gregor: Exactly. You cannot know from anecdotes alone. People try all kinds of diets, and short-term changes can happen for many reasons.

Interviewer: But people say they are doing well on it.

Dr. Gregor: In the short term, people can do all sorts of things and report benefits. The question is what happens long term. We do not have long-term evidence showing that a carnivore diet is safe or beneficial.

Dr. Gregor: A zero-fiber diet is not what I would look to for health. We need to look at outcomes, not just testimonials.

Interviewer: What about ketogenic diets?

Dr. Gregor: Ketogenic diets do have a medical use. They can be used as a third-line treatment for pediatric epilepsy, particularly for children with seizure disorders who do not respond to drugs. In that context, changing brain chemistry can be lifesaving.

Dr. Gregor: But that is different from saying everyone should eat that way. When people are put on these diets for long periods, there can be serious problems. It is not something to generalize casually.

Interviewer: Are these long-term diet questions something you want to address more?

Dr. Gregor: Every year, experts review the evidence on diets. The question should be: what do we actually have data for?

Dr. Gregor: We have enough evidence now to know what kind of diet has been shown to reverse heart disease in the majority of patients. That should be the starting point.

Dr. Gregor: If another diet is claimed to be better, then it needs evidence. Until then, anecdotes are not enough.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [S] 0 points 5 months ago*

Here is a fun super-cut of Dr Gregors verbal stutters https://youtu.be/111MjzOHal4

The (heavily cleaned up) transcript makes him sound MUCH more cogent and put together then his actual speaking patterns, the video itself is a experience.

it may have come from removing the food that was bothering them

He does successfully identify that Carnivore is a elimination diet that people benefit from, everything else he surrounds that with is bias and expectations his expectations.

A zero-fiber diet is not what I would look to for health.

I would love to see his outcome data on fibre.

  • source