The ethics of eating red meat have been grilled recently by critics who question its consequences for environmental health and animal welfare, but if you want to minimise animal suffering and promote more sustainable agriculture, adopting a vegetarian diet might be the worst possible thing you could do.

....

Published figures from CSIRO and other sources in relation to Australia suggest that producing wheat and other grains to service a vegetarian/vegan diet results in at least 25 times more sentient animals being killed per kilogram of useable protein, more environmental damage and a great deal more animal cruelty.

Full Paper - https://doi.org/10.7882/AZ.2011.051

TLDR: Meat results in 25x less death per kg of protein vs plant based protein sources.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago

Great thoughts! Thanks for sharing them. Your right! There are lots of holes here.

Comparing protein of wheat to beef instead of calories, or instead of a more protein-dense plant.

Humans don't run on calories, we run on substrates (fat, protein, carbohydrates) and then bioavailability is important. Part of the whole CICO fiasco is focusing on calories when we need to acknowledge we are hormonal machines and we live in a era of abundant calories and people are under consuming protein.

In my food weight comparison post last week : https://midwest.social/post/47382176 my best effort estimate of total daily food weight on a nutritionally adequate whole food plant based diet came in at 2.3kg a day. That isn't taking into account bioavailability even (which would increase the weight).

That gives us a weight comparison of 350g vs 2,300g per day. We can plug in any vertebrate death estimates per unit of g of food we like, but it's hard to beat one death per year per adult (cow).

They are basing their numbers only on Australian land that works for ungulate grazing but would require terraforming to be usable for planting.

There is a 3:1 of pastoral land (land that only works for grazing) vs cropland in the world. Yes, even in the USA.

in the US the vast majority of beef is grain fed.

Any grain fed animal farming still poisons mice to keep them out of the feed.

any grain fed animals it’s intentionally misleading.

I think you will find every carnivore here prefers grass feed ruminants and doesn't want grain fed. We want to improve the food system to get away from industrialization and move to natural biocycles. Ruminants should not be fed grain!

  • source
  • parent