Dr. Jay Wortman studied Biology and Chemistry at the University of Alberta and Medicine at the University of Calgary. He completed the Family Medicine residency at UBC before starting a private practice in Vancouver. He began combining that with part-time clinics at the STI/HIV the BC Centre for Disease Control where he eventually became the full-time Associate Director. He moved on the First Nations and Inuit Health Branch of Health Canada where he held senior management positions in Ottawa and Vancouver.

In 1992, Dr. Wortman developed type 2 diabetes and quickly discovered that it could be controlled by restricting dietary carbohydrates. He went on to do clinical research on low-carbohydrate diets and became a little bit famous for a study he did in the Namgis First Nation of Alert Bay which was the subject of the CBC documentary film, "My Big Fat Diet". His research interest in the dietary management of obesity, pre-diabetes and diabetes led him back into clinical practice.

summerizerAnti-meat pressure and my own route into low carb

  • Patients often cut back on red meat because they hear it is healthier and better for the environment.
  • The 2019 survey puts health first and environment second as the main motives for eating less meat.
  • My Métis family history of type 2 diabetes made the issue personal, because my grandparents, their children, and my mother all had diabetes.
  • My childhood breakfast of corn flakes, skim milk, and white sugar matched the same skim milk and grain pattern used to fatten pigs.
  • After type 2 diabetes developed, I removed carbohydrates, lost weight rapidly, and saw blood sugar improve.
  • The First Nations traditional-diet project and My Big Fat Diet showed that low-carbohydrate traditional foods could improve metabolic health.
  • Medical training left diet to the food guide, but the food guide had not earned the authority that clinicians give it.

The anti-meat pattern has institutional roots

  • Seventh-day Adventist nutrition history runs through Ellen G. White, Battle Creek, Kellogg, sanitariums, dietetics, and Loma Linda.
  • The vegetarian health halo rests heavily on observational Adventist cohorts, which mix diet with religion, community, abstinence, and other behaviors.
  • The SDA-versus-non-SDA comparison matters because the protective vegetarian signal is stronger inside Adventist studies than outside them.
  • The Adventist water finding shows the weakness of relying on such cohorts, because drinking more water looked more powerful than major drug therapy.
  • Mormon longevity and the Roseto effect make the same point: tight communities can look cardioprotective without the diet being the cause.

Cancer fears about meat are weaker than the public story

  • The IARC cancer process leaned on observational studies and turned mixed red-meat data into a public cancer warning.
  • Red meat colorectal data split almost evenly, while processed-meat data carried more of the adverse signal.
  • David Klurfeld's work and experience inside the IARC process show why confounding, committee structure, and omitted evidence matter.
  • Red meat remains a nutrient-dense food, and the case against it depends on fragile epidemiology.

The climate and protein case for beef is being distorted

  • Environmental fear is the other major reason patients reduce meat, even though the emissions picture is broader than cattle.
  • Greenpeace, European media, fake-meat promoters, and Bill Gates all fit the wider push to cut beef.
  • Frank Mitloehner's comparisons about horses, dairy cows, dogs, and cats expose selective attention in livestock climate messaging.
  • Grazing-land carbon work shows grasslands can store carbon and can offset parts of rural emissions.
  • U.S. emissions data place energy far above agriculture, while land use and forestry are a major sink.
  • Beef net-protein work shows the U.S. beef chain produces more human-edible protein quality than it consumes.
  • Human evolution also fits a meat-heavy pattern, with Pleistocene evidence for a high trophic level and fat-oriented physiology.

Nutrition science has deep reliability problems

  • Richard Horton and John Ioannidis capture the broader problem: much medical and nutritional literature is unreliable.
  • NutriRECS reviewed red and processed meat and made weak recommendations against reducing intake, triggering intense backlash.
  • The backlash before publication, along with True Health Initiative activity, shows how nutrition authorities defend the anti-meat script.
  • Raising my children low carb did not impair their academics, athletics, or development in my household experience.
  • Jared Diamond's agriculture essay fits the skeletal record I use: health markers worsened when humans moved from hunting and gathering to farming.

Q&A and practice points

  • The Netherlands farmer policy, Canadian fertilizer targets, meatless-school policies, and fake-meat promotion all look like parts of the same pressure on animal agriculture.
  • Carnivore and paleo-keto diets helped my neck pain and other patients' joint pain or asthma by removing plants and targeting gut-driven inflammation.
  • The oyster-zinc study shows why plant anti-nutrients matter: black beans reduce zinc absorption and corn tortillas reduce it further.
  • My one-page patient advice is simple: avoid carbohydrates, avoid vegetable oils, and eat fatty meat and fatty dairy.
  • Vegan diets can create fertility, infant, and micronutrient problems when nutrients must come from supplements instead of animal foods.
  • In older or kidney-compromised patients, I am cautious with protein but still use carbohydrate restriction and higher fat when appropriate.
  • My own high-carb vegetarian period ended in diabetes; 21 years of low carb improved my skiing stamina without extra exercise.
  • Hunter-gatherer energy research supports the idea that metabolic health is not mainly a story of exercise volume.
  • TMAO, saturated fat, and kidney-nitrogen fears do not give me a convincing mechanism for meat harm.
  • Ooligan grease shows the sophistication of First Nations fat knowledge, because its fatty-acid profile resembles human adipose tissue.

References

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [S] 3 points 6 months ago* (last edited 6 months ago)

He has a great speaking presence, very easy to listen to. Some of his slides are pretty good.

14:00 “The food guide… it’s not a scientific document. Nobody ever does an RCT with the food guide diet against other diets.”

1:14:00 “I don’t accept the premise. I don’t think meat causes bad health outcomes.”

1:16:00 “To deprive people of arguably the most nutritious food you can eat, I think it’s a bad idea.”

You might wonder how I get through so many long lectures? 3x speed!

"The Science" is a great way to label the ideology driven opposition

At 30:00 when they go over the IARC meat causes cancer publication.... 800 studies "reviewed"... only 56 "considered" for the decision... and the epidemiology is a at odds, and RCTs were dropped. The deck was loaded.

It's all observational data, with very small hazard ratios, and lots of confounding variables, and it's agenda driven

1:05 - Intermittent dosing with carnivore for joint pain

  • 1:08 - Very interesting question. If you have a patient on the edge of a heart attack and you recommend low carb, if they get a heart attack walking out the door low carb is blamed.
  • source