Two virtual rolls of 20-sided dice. One is a nat 20 with a modifier of -1, resulting in a 19, and the other is a nat 1 with a modifier of 18, also resulting in a 19.
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 17 points 1 year ago (20 children)

Is a nat 20 not treated as a critical success? At least that’s how my 5e DM handles those.

  • source
  • hideshow 20 child comments
  • [–] 39 points 1 year ago (5 children)

    DnD 5e does not have critical successes or failures on ability checks. Only attack rolls have critical successes and failures.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 11 points 1 year ago (3 children)

    Both 5e and the 2024 rules only crit / crit miss on attacks. But Baldur’s Gate 3 introduced them on checks, which muddied the waters.

    BG3 also did drinking potions as bonus actions, which 5e did not do but many DM’s (including those in several well-known real play shows) did as a house rule, then they incorporated it into the 2024 rules.

    What a mess.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 13 points 1 year ago (1 child)

    Baldur's gate didn't really introduce them. It was a house rule so common it may as well been an optional rule.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 4 points 1 year ago

    So common that Critical Success or Failure is literally mentioned in the 5e Dungeon Master's Guide (2014), though more as an enhancer rather than automatic success/failure.

    The example's wording does imply that the roll result needs to be successful for the enhancer to apply. However, it literally states beforehand that it's up to the DM how it manifests, and increase of impact is just a suggestion.

    Personally, I prefer what the example in the DMG implies than automatic success. It depends on the campaign, but giving a wizard with 8 strength a 1/20 chance to lift a Sequoia log by themself is a bit much.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 15 points 1 year ago

    Why is it a mess? It’s just the nature of TTRPGs. Like the books make it very explicit: the rules are only rules insofar as the GM and players agree; and the GM is always the final arbiter.

    “Homebrewing” is just playing the game as intended.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 4 points 1 year ago (12 children)

    Nat 20 adds one to the degree of success, which almost always means a crit unless you are dealing with something way above your level.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 12 child comments
  • [–] 21 points 1 year ago (3 children)

    How some crazies want ability checks to work:

    Player: I gesture vaguely towards the ancient dragon indicating I would like it to give me all of its gold and become my personal pet.

    DM: Roll a persuasion check

    Player: Let's see... Minus 4 because I'm still only level 2.... With a Nat-20 that's totals 16

    DM: Nat-20? By golly I guess that means you succeed - the ancient dragon and its entire hoard of treasure are yours now.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 15 points 1 year ago*

    Heh I would play it as the player is now PART of the hoard and is now the DRAGONS personal pet. The player was too persuasive lol.

    And now the shenanigans is trying to get away from said dragon. And the rest of the group will now be dealing with a dragon that wants its shiny back in its hoard for the entire rest of the campaign.

    Nat 20s can make for some GREAT monkey paw situations. Its really fun.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 10 points 1 year ago

    How critical success ability checks should work:

    DM: "Nat-20? The dragon is amused by your insane audacity and merely punts you out of his chamber instead of turning you into a smoking cinder on the spot. Roll for fall damage."

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 3 points 1 year ago (6 children)

    That's Pathfinder rules, this is 5e

    formally there is no crit success in 5e

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 6 child comments
  • [–] 5 points 1 year ago (5 children)

    I don’t see any indication that it is any specific system being referenced, so I chose the better one.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 1 year ago (2 children)

    Umm, the comment you're replying to specifically says "my 5e DM".

    And again, that's homebrew for pathfinder, not pathfinder. There's only rules for critical hits in pathfinder.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 1 year ago (1 child)

    Flat out wrong. Per page 400 and 401 of the Player Core, “All types of checks, from skill checks to attack rolls to saving throws, follow these basic steps.“ … “You critically succeed when the check's result meets or exceeds the DC by 10 or more.” Furthermore, individual skill actions specifically list a crit effect, such as with Recall Knowledge which grants you additional information or a follow up question.

    Photographic proof from the rulebook attached.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 1 year ago

    Cool. Couldn't find it anywhere on the net that wasn't being attributed to pf2e. Doesn't change the fact that the guy you're replying to said 5e (I did recall playing with this rule in PF, but again couldn't find the rule)

  • source
  • parent