The reason I'm inclined to turn to online dating is because the real me is someone whose dream life would be spending most of his days sitting around with a good friend playing with cats. It's not like I have no solo interests at all, they're just not ones that can invite a connection by doing them in public. Sometimes I read math, I have papers on the arXiv on category theory and categorical homotopy theory, but I'm out of academia right now so that's not a way to connect with real people.

I absolutely love talking to people and forming connections, but just with one other person at a time, otherwise I get behind the conversation and go into deep introversion. I like getting to listen to someone tell their stories and talk about themselves. One of my favorite activities is reading books out loud with a friend. I don't know how to go out into the real world and just do that with one other person. Online I can, and have made some wonderful connections. It's just that dating apps specifically look like a nightmare.

If I were really into hiking or whatever I would be all about living that out. Unfortunately, the person I am is someone who would be doing activities as a means to socialize, rather than the other way around. Doing those things would very much not be the real me. It's not easy to live a solitary life for an extended period and not dream about more, and those dreams start to feel like an ulterior motive if I'm seeking out new connections.

I don't think at all about what "top" should mean in a dating pool, it hadn't even crossed my mind, so I'm not sure why you're bringing that up. I don't care about whether I find someone in a top percentile of anything, I just want to find someone who is empathetic and who I connect with.