Luke is also a skilled pilot and an excellent shot. And the movie never establishes how experienced his squadmates are, nor can we just assume they are all highly trained since they are part of a cobbled together resistance and not a traditional military. And the only thing he does better than the others is hit the target. His survival wasn't because he was better, it was because he was the last one left to make the suicide run, and because he was rescued at the last minute.

Oh, and let's not forget that he never could have done it without the wise old mentor. You know, the guy from a previous generation that fought in a great war. The guy who passes on ancient wisdom and who is the only reason look was able to make the shot. Not exactly something that fits the "Our generation is the awesomest" picture the post is trying to paint.

Also, Star Wars came out in 1977, not 1970.

You didn't even once talk about slop and how sticky it could get.

2/10

from watching "fighter pilot reviews" of the movie that was one aspect they said rings true

I'm gonna assume every other aspect of the movie does not ring true because that movie was so bad compared to the first Top Gun. There's a big list of stuff that doesn't make sense.