Pretty sure, yes. I'm probably just explaining badly.
There's a full 360 degrees of rays perpendicular to (AH) starting at H. That would be true of line to a point in 3D. In 2D there would be exactly 2 possibilities (left and right), while in 4D they would correspond to an ordinary sphere, and hyperspheres in higher dimensions yet.
Together, they take up a plane. Only points on a certain (infinite) line going through this new plane and H will actually orthogonally map to H, and it's the same one that's normal to to original plane. Let's call the line L.
If point P wasn't in this plane, (PH) couldn't be perpendicular to (AH). It is in the new plane, but we still don't know for sure it's on line L, so it's not true that that implies it projects to H.