[–] [S] 1 point 4 hours ago

Thank you for this analysis. I hadn’t understood the results in that way.

Do you think that the minor parties on the right would prefer the status quo to remain unchanged or to be able to compete on equal terms with National in the electorates going forward?

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 12 hours ago (1 child)

    In general the vote splitting on the right seemingly did nothing as long as national kept polling around 26-30% (been 26 to 29% all year) they were getting a overhang before anyone ever mentioned vote splitting. If the right block had of seriously committed to the strategy they would have gained more overhang seats

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 23 hours ago* (last edited 19 hours ago)

    Note: I'm just pointing out that TPM did a better job in my opinion; but that doesn't change my view that we need to overhaul MMP to "fix" the overhang issue, otherwise we will lose even more trust in the processes of government.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 1 day ago (3 children)

    I would debate that; it seems from my point of view that TPM was significantly more effective than the right block at the vote splitting strategy.

    Looking at the results from 2023; TPM got 3.1% of the vote and got 6 seats; with "wasted vote" that entitled them to 4 seats, thus causing a 2 seat overhang.

    This time around they got 0.6%, entitling them to 0 seats; but getting 5, but you have to look at where that vote went. Primarily the 2.3% or 3 seats went to the Greens who went from 12 to 16 seats; you could easily argue that TPM with their strategy gained 8 seats for the left.

    Nationals 6 seat overhang is the only thing keeping the right in a position of contention.

    National went from 38.1% to 29.2% a 8.9% drop; the right bloc went from 55.1% of the vote in 2023 to 49.9% before this years special votes come in; this is a significant drop. The left bloc went from 41.6% to 43.1%, a less significant gain, but a gain none the less.

    Obviously a lot of National vote went to Act; but Opportunity also picked up some. NZF gained ~0.7% which is almost an entire seat.

    The specials could do strange things to the results; Opportunity needs 0.67% to gain an extra seat; depending on where that % comes from right/left bloc; it could change the balance of power. The other thing that is somewhat amusing is that if National gains 1%; coming from Act or NZF the right could lose two seats; 1 from Act/NZF losing a seat and 1 from the elimination of an overhang seat.

    The right has by no means "won" this election; they may just be able to scrape a victory if the specials fall correctly for them. But it could easily still fall the other way for the left.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 4 days ago (1 child)

    His biggest frustration? The haka in parliament. Can't have those uppity Murrays doing their uppity Murray stuff in parliament.

    Good riddance to a racist piece of shit.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 5 days ago

    Greens and nats will never work together, they have very opposing ideas on how the earth should be exploited to the last molecule for the benefit of billionaires.

    I think we are going to be stuck with the right wing again for another 3 years most likely.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 5 days ago

    Seeing him in his "soft side" as his exit legacy is a bit disgusting. You can't spend years being an asshole and then afterwards expect people to remember you as a reasonable person based on a few interviews.

    He probably won’t be the only one doing that in the coming year - including those who aren’t as sorted as Luxon (like paying mortgage for their (presumably highly leveraged) property portfolio).

  • source
  • [–] 5 points 5 days ago

    I think there are image problems standing in the way, but holy hell would I like something like this. Imagine if they came up with a set of key objectives they all agreed on, and agreed to pause other policies for the term.

    National is hemorraging votes to Act and NZF though, and I'm sure it would get worse if they actually did this.

  • source
  • [–] 1 point 1 week ago*

    Current election results:

    • Nat @29.2 gets 36+1; 37 E, 0 L
    • Lab @29.4 gets 36; 21 E + 4 E from TPM flip + 5 E from NAt flip, + 6 L
    • Grn @13.3 gets 16; No change to E/L
    • Act @10.9 gets 13; No change to E/L
    • NZF @9.8 gets 12; No change to E/L
    • Opp @6 gets 7; No change to E/L
    • TPM @0.4 gets 0+1; 1 E 0 L

    This gives a 122 seat house, compared to the 131 seats we are looking at.

    The current election results are quite unfair to TPM under my system; mainly because their strategy to shift party vote was well executed. If they got their 2023 result of 3.1% it wouldn't be so distorted. The numbers would shuffle around a bit and that 3% would likely have come from Lab/Grn.

    TPM 2023 would have got 4 seats + 1 in overhang; giving them 5 instead of the 6 they actually got in 2023.

    2023 would have see a 121 seat house rather than a 122 that we actually got.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 1 week ago (1 child)

    I have been thinking about this for a couple of days now; here is my proposal for how to fix the overhang issue:

    Note - by fix, I mean maintain the two vote system, whilst also preserving proportionality (as closely as possible); whilst also pissing off the fewest people.

    Note 2 - this system does not completely eliminate the overhang, but will significantly limit its influence.

    The proposed system will work; from the voters point of view; exactly as the current system does with a party vote and a candidate vote.

    Each party is afforded precisely one overhang seat if the vote count comes out that way. Limiting the size of parliament to 120 + (the number parties)/2, rounded up. So with seven parties the limit is 124, this is unlikely but possible.

    Any other overhang seats are "flipped"; to the second place getter; starting at the closest races in each electorate. These are the places where a few hundred votes either way would have put the second place candidate in. This is going to piss off a bunch of people, but this is statistically the fewest people that are pissed off.

    The only dispensation where a seat cannot be flipped is if the seat is that of the party leader(s).

    The allowance of one overhang seat; means that parties HAVE to campaign on the party vote, as more seats means nothing to them beyond that. This also allows for TPM to get say 2.5% of the party vote which would allow 3 seats, but have a 4th from their allowed 1 seat overhang.

    The reason I have settled on this as the "best" option, is three fold.

    • Fewest changes for the voters of NZ; educating the public on a new system is difficult.
    • 1 seat overhang, still reflects the will of the people if a party really does have a whole bunch of great candidates but shit party....seems weird but possible.
    • Candidates will really have to work not to have their seat be a "close" race, be visible and serve their communities.
  • source
  • [–] 2 points 1 week ago

    I’m not sure how Op’s idea of MMP+STV would work, but it would probably be better than what we have now? I think?

    It kinda sounds like the candidate with the most votes may not be elected for the electorate based on something outside of their control?

    The more I think about it, the more I realise why Germany just said fuck it. Win enough of the party vote to get your electorate seats, or lose em. It’s definitely simpler.

    Yeah it's not a bad idea. I think maybe we could have a threshold. Like your first overhang seat is free but after that you need the votes. That would make it much harder to manipulate, and the effects of manipulation would be capped.

    I’m honestly just glad this isn’t going to fall to me to figure out.

    Yeah, maybe when we do reviews that produce recommendations perhaps we enact those recommendations? 😂 who am I kidding

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 1 week ago (1 child)

    I have no idea to be honest.

    I had a friend suggest treating the Māori roll separately. For this election that does make the numbers a little more sane (still quite a large parliament, but we potentially wouldn't need a new building lol) but that has all sorts of potential to screw over Māori voters, and I wouldn't trust any solution that tried to separate the two rolls for scaling.

    I'm busy reading about STV, and that has problems too. It's better than FPTP but it does still have a tendency to favour larger parties, and isn't great in terms of proportional representation. I'm not sure how Op's idea of MMP+STV would work, but it would probably be better than what we have now? I think?

    The more I think about it, the more I realise why Germany just said fuck it. Win enough of the party vote to get your electorate seats, or lose em. It's definitely simpler.

    I'm honestly just glad this isn't going to fall to me to figure out.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 1 week ago (2 children)

    Thanks - the solution may well be to reduce the number of electorate seats so that we still have someone nearby to areas but not so many. We could do the same to list seats. Maybe our parliament size is reduced so it's not so unreasonable to keep proportions?

    I'm just spouting things now. Any suggestions on other ways to solve the problem? I think I ultimately believe the parliament share should be approximately proportional to party vote, but I don't have a good idea of how to achieve that.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: next ›