It occurred to me that a lot of the current analysis of our election results focuses on the right bloc’s achievement in electing a sizeable national caucus while still electing reasonable numbers of the minor parties. To a lesser extent this was the Maori party’s strategy on the left as well, but made less effective because they are a minor party.

Looking forward, would not all minor parties benefit from reforming the electorate seats so that they are not first past the post? It would seem that we’re stuck with a mostly two-party system unless we can give the minor parties a fighting chance — precisely why, I guess, National and Labour will never support it.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 2 points 1 day ago (3 children)

I would debate that; it seems from my point of view that TPM was significantly more effective than the right block at the vote splitting strategy.

Looking at the results from 2023; TPM got 3.1% of the vote and got 6 seats; with "wasted vote" that entitled them to 4 seats, thus causing a 2 seat overhang.

This time around they got 0.6%, entitling them to 0 seats; but getting 5, but you have to look at where that vote went. Primarily the 2.3% or 3 seats went to the Greens who went from 12 to 16 seats; you could easily argue that TPM with their strategy gained 8 seats for the left.

Nationals 6 seat overhang is the only thing keeping the right in a position of contention.

National went from 38.1% to 29.2% a 8.9% drop; the right bloc went from 55.1% of the vote in 2023 to 49.9% before this years special votes come in; this is a significant drop. The left bloc went from 41.6% to 43.1%, a less significant gain, but a gain none the less.

Obviously a lot of National vote went to Act; but Opportunity also picked up some. NZF gained ~0.7% which is almost an entire seat.

The specials could do strange things to the results; Opportunity needs 0.67% to gain an extra seat; depending on where that % comes from right/left bloc; it could change the balance of power. The other thing that is somewhat amusing is that if National gains 1%; coming from Act or NZF the right could lose two seats; 1 from Act/NZF losing a seat and 1 from the elimination of an overhang seat.

The right has by no means "won" this election; they may just be able to scrape a victory if the specials fall correctly for them. But it could easily still fall the other way for the left.

  • source
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 1 day ago* (last edited 19 hours ago)

    Note: I'm just pointing out that TPM did a better job in my opinion; but that doesn't change my view that we need to overhaul MMP to "fix" the overhang issue, otherwise we will lose even more trust in the processes of government.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] [S] 1 point 4 hours ago

    Thank you for this analysis. I hadn’t understood the results in that way.

    Do you think that the minor parties on the right would prefer the status quo to remain unchanged or to be able to compete on equal terms with National in the electorates going forward?

  • source
  • parent