[–] 3 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

Do you think IBM wouldn’t make Red Hat completely proprietary if they had the chance?

No. I don’t. For quite a few reasons.

1 - Red Hat has released new software (quite a lot actually) that they wrote, as GPL since the IBM purchase (rather directly refuting your thought experiment)

2 - A huge amount of Red Hat Enterprise Linux is permissively licensed. They have the chance every day to make this proprietary. They don’t. Again, answering your question.

3 - Red Hat is one of the most profitable parts of IBM.

4 - IBM has left the Product and Engineering teams independent. Because of #3 obviously.

5 - I use facts when forming my opinions

Red Hat is the most commercially successful Open Source company and perhaps the biggest proponent and prolific author of GPL software. They founded (created on purpose) one of the most successful community Linux distributions (Fedora)—a distribution with annoying dedication to free software (eg. codecs). Many of the “leaders” and “contributors” to Fedora are Red Hat employees. Red Hat of course does not make Fedora proprietary since having it be “community” led is a core part of their strategy.

Finally, you do not have to fear a Red Hat take over. Because it already happened.

Half the software (source code) you think of as GNU sits on servers Red Hat manages and controls. This is where that software is developed (not in Savannah—which is just a mirror). I am talking about GCC, Glibc, core utils. Etc.

Do you use systemd, pipewire, Wayland, Mesa, Podman, Cockpit, or Flatpak? Where did all this software come from? From the Free Software Foundation? University students? No, these are all part of the “Linux platform” as defined by Red Hat and they have swept us all along with them as they create it. You can probably add GNOME and GTK to the list at this point.

Has Debian moved to all these technologies? Why? Because of the FSF? No. Because of Red Hat.

Personally, I am ok with it. My core distro uses A LOT of software brought to me by Red Hat and I am thankful for it. But I avoid a lot of Red Hat software like GCC, Glibc, and systemd. But the replacements I use are also mostly corporately funded (Clang, MUSL, and dinit).

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] -3 points 1 year ago*

    Your opponents. You do not get to decide who my allies and opponents are.

    I agree with everything you are saying “for you”. It sounds like the GPL is the perfect choice for code that you wrote (assuming you wrote any).

    But stop telling me what to think and do. Or, at least stop using the word “freedom” while you peddle your authoritarianism.

    My philosophy is single. Those that wrote the code should get to choose the license. Many people prefer the collaboration that permissive licences allow. I do not oppose that.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] -3 points 1 year ago (8 children)

    Permissive license offer greater freedom to users of the code that already exists. The only benefit of copyleft is that it lets you demand future code that you did not write and that the authors do not want to Open Source. It is about restricting their freedom, not enhancing yours.

    Permissive licenses provide all of the “4 freedoms” that the Free Software Foundation talks about. You cannot really talk about the differences between cooyleft and permissive as a “freedom” because they are not.

    The name “permissive” kind of gives it away that permissive licenses offer more freedoms about what you can do with the code you were given.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

    Most Open Source software is written by corporations. The Open Source licenses are an advantage to them.

    The biggest source of GPL software is probably Red Hat (IBM). They maintain most of what people think of when they think of GNU software and they wrote many of the newer GPL projects that everybody uses (like systemd).

    The trend has been towards permissive licenses for a long time. The have led to more Open Source software, not less.

    Look at Clang vs GCC. Clang attracts a greater diversity of corporate contribution and generates greater Open Source diversity. Zig and Rust appeared on LLVM for a reason.

    What we should be worried about is the cloud. It allows big companies to outsell the little companies writing Open Source software. Neither permissive nor copyleft licenses prevent this.

  • source
  • [–] 1 point 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago) (3 children)

    Everything runs under Wayland. That should be your default expectation.

    At this point, Wayland is the preferred environment for GTK and Qt apps. Unless the app is exploiting some specific aspect of X11, all GTK (3 and up) and Qt (5 and up) apps work fine under Wayland.

    As for other toolkits, FLTK, Electron, and SDL apps run in Wayland too.

    And by “preferred”, I mean that these apps (like Thunar) will run natively on Wayland even if Xwayland is available.

    There are Wayland only toolkits now but not really any “modern” toolkits that do not support Wayland. When Thunar gets ported to GTK5, it will be Wayland only.

    Obviously ancient x11 specific stuff like XCB or Athena, and things built on them like Motif will require Xwayland or Xsatellite. So if you want to run, xv or motif nedit, you need those. This list includes GTK2 as well. But even they work well enough you may not notice. I mean, xeyes won’t track your mouse I guess.

    And just in case mentioning xeyes brings out the Wayland critics, you can build an xeyes app that works in Wayland. I think the Wayland Maker compositor project has one for example (WindowMaker in Wayland).

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 0 points 1 year ago*

    Alberta just retired all their coal burning electricity generation by moving to natural gas. LNG almost by definition reduces coal burning anywhere it gets shipped.

    Europe coal consumption is going up to avoid buying Russian gas.

    The profitability of gas in Canada reduces investment in oil (and vice versa). Gas sells in North America for a couple bucks and in Japan for close to $12 (as LNG).

    So, naturally, all the environmentalists want to stop shipping LNG.

    Apparently it is more important to feel good than to do good.

    All that said, I am quite happy to cancel anything that benefits Trump and his buddies.

  • source
  • [–] 11 points 1 year ago (4 children)

    Without OCLP, the latest release of macOS that a 2015 MacBook Pro will run is Monterey (5 releases ago).

    The final release of Monterey was July 2024. So no, it is not getting updates anymore. Worse, many programs require a newer release of macOS to run at all.

    This is a perfect system to migrate to Linux. It will run faster, be more secure, and will have totally up-to-date software.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›