[–] 77 points 4 months ago

93.2% macro-F1 for human vs. AI detection and 68.4% macro-F1 for six-way authorship attribution

This isn't what I'd call "reliable".

I'm also not impressed with their methodology, which is heavily based on Gemini.

To generate mirrored AI stories, we reverse-engineer writing prompts from each human story by prompting Gemini 2.5 Flash (Gemini Team, 2025a) to infer the underlying premise

That's too many steps removed from anything you'd encounter in the wild. They're not even testing against human-prompted output.

And then they use Gemini again to analyze all the stories. Relying on proprietary cloud models for the core of your analysis is like building on sand.

  • source
  • [–] 8 points 4 months ago (1 child)

    Google Play Rewards sends you surveys and gives you like 10-20¢ per survey. Each one takes like 5 seconds to complete. I haven't used it in a long time, but years ago most of the surveys were about shopping habits based on my location history, like "did you go to < store> in the past week? Did you pay with your credit card?" Or random things like "have you shopped for auto parts in the past week? Yes/no/prefer not to answer."

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 10 points 4 months ago*

    Two main catalysts:

    1. Seeing how dumb 99% of products are.

    2. Seeing how dumb 99% of users are.

    Call my naive, but I truly did not see it coming. I didn't expect cognitive surrender. I didn't expect the whole world to start continvoucly morging. I didn't expect lawyers to submit fake case citations, again and again and again.

    I didn't expect society as a whole to just shrug their shoulders and decide that accuracy doesn't matter.

    I also didn't expect how much or how rapidly the bubble would inflate. GPU prices were already crazy, but now RAM and even SSD prices have roughly doubled in the past year, with no end in sight, with all production toward data centers. This is a disaster. We're seeing higher prices for downgraded machines, like Microsoft's 8GB Surface.

    Seeing as we're all on Lemmy, I hope that I will not need to belabor the point that centralization is bad. The shift toward data centers and away from personal devices is a shift toward centralization. It's a shift toward greater censorship and away from freedom.

    It's not coincidence that this is happening at the same time as fascism is rising all around the world, that online ID laws are passing all over the world, that privacy-protecting technology like VPNs and end-to-end encryption are under greater and greater attack, and that knowledge repositories like The Internet Archive and Wikipedia are under attack. The shift is toward governmental control of the Internet, of access to knowledge in general.

    Now the US government gets the final say on who will have access to ChatGPT 5.6. Surprise, surprise.

    I'm not anti-AI or anti-LLM per se. I am anti-corruption and anti-bullshit. I am pro-consumer, pro-privacy, pro-individuality. In practice, that means I am anti-AI. Or more generally (but less strongly), I am anti-cloud.

    As for what I would do: well the real solutions are the same as the solutions to most of modern society's problems. We need extensive economic reform. But barring that, we need to do whatever we can to shift the balance back toward personal, private computation. We don't need more datacenters. We don't need trillion-parameter models at all. The only thing they are good at is basic stuff you don't need them for (unless you're an idiot), and generating well-masked bullshit.

    Edit: Oh, and I would also hold all the corporations accountable for their obviously-illegal behavior, like pirating all the copyrighted material in the world. We definitely need more transparency in terms of training data.

  • source
  • [–] 17 points 4 months ago (1 child)

    My experience, also in the US, has been the opposite: I get prescribed addictive painkillers "just in case".

    Last time I had surgery, they told me to take ibuprofen for pain, and they also gave me a prescription for vicodin if the pain was too great. I live in an area with a significant opioid abuse problem, and they're handing it out like candy. They didn't tell me "call back if it's severe" or anything like that, they just gave me the prescription. I stuck with the ibuprofen, and realistically I could have done without even that.

    I suspect your experience is largely due to sexism. I've heard so many stories like this, where doctors don't even think of taking women seriously.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago

    What I’m gathering is that “wave” can refer to a behavioral pattern that is substrate independent — it refers to a logical function more than it does an ontological presence

    I think that's a good way of putting it.

    As for what counts as a "substrate", I have no idea! In the old days, the idea of a substance that permeated seemingly-empty space was common. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aether_theories

    Nowadays, the idea of aether has been discarded for the most part. But that said, there's still plenty we don't understand, like dark matter. There's no consensus on what dark matter is exactly; there are many competing theories. What we know is that there are observable phenomena that can't be explained without something that acts (roughly, at least) like matter in terms of its effect on gravity, but doesn't interact with electromagnetism like normal matter. That "something" is called dark matter, but its fundamental nature is an open question.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›